Posted on — Leave a comment

The New WOTUS Proposal Promises Less Paperwork. It Could Create a Corps Backlog.

The proposal promises less paperwork, but it could turn one wetland delineation into two boundary investigations—and the agencies have not published a method for drawing the second boundary.

By Marc Seelinger, SPWS

EPA and the Department of the Army published a new WOTUS proposal today that could remove most intermittent streams—and potentially large portions of many wetlands—from federal Clean Water Act jurisdiction.

It is being presented as deregulation. The agencies predict fewer federal permits, lower costs, and greater certainty. The Army has placed the effort under its “Building Infrastructure, Not Paperwork” initiative.

But there is a serious problem: the agencies have not provided a credible method for applying either of the new jurisdictional tests.

The proposal may reduce federal jurisdiction. It does not reduce the work needed to prove where jurisdiction ends. In practice, it could create more investigations, more disputes, and a new nationwide backlog of Corps jurisdictional-determination reviews.

That helps no one—not even developers.

The Supplemental Notice of Proposed Rulemaking was published September 9, 2026, at 91 FR 57284. Comments are due October 9 under Docket No. EPA-HQ-OW-2025-0322. Read the published proposal.

Two new alternatives

The proposal adds two alternatives to the WOTUS rule proposed in November 2025. Neither is current law.

The first would generally limit “relatively permanent waters” to perennial waters. A stream would need standing or continuously flowing water every day of an ordinary year. One ordinary interruption lasting up to 30 consecutive days could be allowed.

The word one creates an immediate problem. A stream that is dry once for 30 days could qualify. A stream that is dry twice for one day each could fail—even though the second stream contains water on 28 more days during the year.

That is a legal bright line, not a scientifically credible measure of stream permanence. The agencies acknowledge that there is no precise, scientifically grounded, nationally consistent basis for the 30-day limit.

The second alternative concerns wetlands. It would require perennial surface water within a wetland to be continuously connected to surface water in a jurisdictional water. The connection must make it difficult to tell where the jurisdictional water ends and the wetland begins.

Only the connected portion of the wetland might be federally jurisdictional. This could create two separate boundaries on the same property: the scientifically delineated wetland boundary and a new federal boundary somewhere inside it.

The agencies anticipate that most intermittent streams would fail the first test. They also anticipate that a majority of wetlands currently regulated as adjacent wetlands would fail the second because most wetlands do not contain perennial surface water.

There is no published procedure for making these decisions

The Swamp School reviewed the proposal, existing Corps and ERDC procedures, and relevant scientific literature. We found useful methods for studying streamflow duration and wetland connectivity. We did not find a validated procedure capable of answering the exact legal questions the agencies propose.

A one-time site visit cannot establish whether water was present every day of an ordinary year. Finding a dry stream does not reveal when it dried, whether this was its first or second interruption, or whether the cause was ordinary or anomalous.

Streamflow Duration Assessment Methods can estimate whether a stream is typically ephemeral, intermittent, or perennial. They do not reconstruct a day-by-day record or distinguish one interruption from two. EPA scientists have explained that streamflow duration exists along a continuum and that classifications require regional calibration and treatment of uncertainty. Fritz et al. (2020)

Maps, models, and satellite imagery cannot fill the gap. Tree canopy, shadows, narrow channels, shallow water, cloud cover, mapping errors, and time between images prevent them from proving daily surface-water conditions at property scale.

For wetlands, the problem is harder. Existing delineation methods identify the boundary between wetland and non-wetland. They were not designed to locate a second boundary inside one continuous wetland based on the daily persistence of surface water.

Published connectivity studies have required water-level instruments, repeated site visits, precipitation records, channel inspections, and elevation data. That research is valuable, but it is not a national jurisdictional-boundary protocol. McDonough et al. (2015)

The proposal nevertheless suggests that a landowner could identify the connected portion of a wetland by observation or “the naked eye.” That claim is difficult to reconcile with a test requiring proof of perennial water, ordinary conditions, drought exceptions, and no more than one qualifying interruption.

Why developers should be concerned

The agencies assume narrower jurisdiction will mean fewer Section 404 permits and lower costs. That may be true after a property owner obtains a defensible non-jurisdictional decision. The unanswered question is what it will cost—and how long it will take—to get that decision.

A developer cannot finance and design a project based on a national estimate that “most” intermittent streams or wetlands will be excluded. The developer needs a reliable answer for the specific property. Lenders, purchasers, engineers, local governments, and investors may also demand Corps confirmation.

Under the new alternatives, consultants may need to document streamflow over time, distinguish ordinary conditions from drought, investigate separate interruptions, map perennial surface water inside wetlands, and defend an internal jurisdictional boundary.

That work occurs before anyone knows whether a permit has been avoided.

Delays at that stage can affect purchase contracts, financing, engineering plans, local approvals, construction schedules, and mitigation decisions. A theoretical reduction in jurisdiction has little value if the project waits months for an answer that no published method can reliably produce.

Why the Corps backlog could grow

Without a national procedure, each Corps district—and potentially each project manager—will have to decide what evidence is sufficient.

How many site visits are enough? How long must monitoring continue? What water depth counts? Where should sensors be placed? Which drought category controls? What happens when field observations conflict with maps or imagery? How is the internal wetland boundary surveyed?

Different applicants will submit different evidence. Corps reviewers will request additional information, resolve conflicting indicators, and prepare decisions capable of surviving administrative appeals and litigation.

The likely result is more case-by-case analysis and more requests for AJDs. The Corps may eventually process fewer permit applications, but it could first inherit a larger and substantially more complicated jurisdictional-review workload.

This is paperwork moved to the front of the project, where delay is often most expensive.

A rule that helps no one

Developers do not benefit from an uncertain and potentially slower approval process. The Corps does not benefit from being handed new tests without validated procedures or additional resources. Consultants do not benefit from inconsistent district expectations. States and Tribes may inherit responsibility for excluded waters without uniform programs or additional capacity. Environmental interests could lose federal protections without gaining a clear or scientifically defensible boundary.

The agencies should withdraw both alternatives in their current form.

Before adopting either one, EPA and the Army should disclose any technical review conducted by Corps districts or ERDC, complete a geographically representative multi-district pilot study, quantify the expected effect on AJD workloads and processing times, and demonstrate acceptable accuracy and inter-observer reproducibility.

Any resulting methodology should be published for public comment before the jurisdictional standard is finalized—not developed afterward through inconsistent case-by-case decisions.

This is not an argument for broader federal jurisdiction for its own sake. It is an argument for a rule that can actually be implemented.

If the administration wants less regulatory burden, it must evaluate the entire process. A rule that excludes more waters but requires longer, costlier, and less predictable investigations to identify them is not meaningful deregulation.

It is a regulatory backlog waiting to happen.

Comments must be received by October 9, 2026. Identify Docket No. EPA-HQ-OW-2025-0322 and submit comments through Regulations.gov.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Surface Water Connections in 2026: Where the Real Jurisdictional Risk Is

Surface Water Connections in 2026: Where the Real Jurisdictional Risk Is

Surface Water Connections in 2026: Where the Real Jurisdictional Risk Is

An overview for consultants and project teams navigating today’s tighter jurisdictional standards.

Regulatory Briefing • March Field Season Readiness

Cut through the noise. Focus on what delays projects.

If you’re working in wetlands, streams, mitigation, or environmental permitting, you already feel it: the jurisdictional debate isn’t loud anymore. It’s technical.

In 2026, most project delays aren’t coming from sweeping policy changes. They’re coming from a narrower, higher-stakes question:

Does a wetland have a continuous surface water connection to a relatively permanent water?

This isn’t politics. It’s field execution and documentation discipline. And that’s where the real risk sits.

The question that’s now driving everything

The analysis has tightened around physical hydrologic connectivity. The old comfort of broad, functional reasoning has been replaced by something far more demanding: observable, mappable, defensible surface continuity.

That means conclusions increasingly rise or fall on what you can document in the field and in the report—not what you can infer.

Where the risk is actually concentrated

The highest-risk areas are not obvious perennial stream systems. And they’re not clearly isolated upland depressions either. The real exposure sits in transitional features like:

  • Roadside ditches and ditch-modified landscapes
  • Shallow swales and broad, low-gradient connectors
  • Floodplain depressions and backwater areas
  • Culvert crossings, berms, and roadway barriers
  • Seasonal connectors that appear “disconnected” during dry months
  • Modified drainage systems in agricultural and suburban settings

These are the places where flow is seasonal, infrastructure complicates interpretation, and elevation differences matter more than assumptions.

The two overcorrections we’re seeing

Across the country, firms are responding in two opposite—and equally risky—ways:

1) Over-asserting connectivity.
Carrying forward older adjacency logic and assuming continuity where evidence is thin. If the connection can’t be shown visually and supported spatially, defensibility suffers.

2) Over-disclaiming jurisdiction.
Under-calling features based on dry-season observations alone. That can create exposure in review, enforcement, and in states with independent wetland programs.

In both cases, the problem isn’t ideology. It’s documentation: what was observed, how it was recorded, and how clearly it was explained.

Why this matters financially

Surface water connection determinations now directly affect:

  • Mitigation requirements and bank credit demand
  • Project redesign costs and construction sequencing
  • Schedule predictability and permitting timelines
  • Property valuation and client risk tolerance
  • Long-term liability exposure

A misclassified connection can mean months of delay, significant mitigation expense, or future problems when projects are evaluated under a different lens—sometimes years later.

The trend we’re watching in 2026

One trend is clear: reviewers are increasingly verifying conclusions using geospatial and historic data. The era of “narrative-only” justification is fading.

Expect more reliance on: LiDAR, historic aerials, elevation modeling, and seasonal imagery comparisons.

In this environment, reports that don’t anticipate verification may not age well. Projects outlive field visits.

Where we go deeper: the premium analysis

Inside the Regulatory Briefing Subscription, we’re releasing a full premium white paper:

“Surface Water Connections in 2026: Where Jurisdictional Risk Actually Sits.”

It breaks down what’s driving real project risk, including:

  • How “continuous” is being interpreted in practice
  • Where ditch-based connections become vulnerable
  • How culverts and artificial barriers should be evaluated and documented
  • Why intermittent vs. ephemeral classification now carries amplified consequences
  • What documentation protocols reduce exposure going into field season
  • How to write reports that hold up in both permitting and enforcement contexts

This is not commentary. It is applied regulatory analysis built for professionals managing real projects.

The Regulatory Briefing is designed for signal, not noise

The regulatory environment is not quiet. But most of the noise is not useful. The purpose of the Regulatory Briefing is simple:

  • No political commentary
  • No outrage cycles
  • No speculation disguised as certainty
  • Just clear analysis of what changes mean for real work in the field

Read more about the subscription

If you’re responsible for wetland delineations, jurisdictional determinations, mitigation planning, or environmental compliance strategy, surface water connection analysis is not optional reading in 2026.

Learn about the Regulatory Briefing Subscription

Next month’s release is especially important going into field season—because the risk isn’t where most people are looking. It’s in the transitional spaces.

The Swamp School Regulatory Briefing
Practical, apolitical analysis for professionals working at the intersection of wetlands science and regulation.

Posted on — 1 Comment

EPA’s Proposed Section 401 Rule: Environmental Protection, Scientific Rigor, and Practical Implications

On January 15, 2026, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) proposed revisions to the Clean Water Act (CWA) Section 401 water quality certification regulations. The docket Number is: EPA-HQ-OW-2025-2929. While the proposal has sparked debate across environmental advocacy, regulatory, and consulting communities, it is best understood not as a simple expansion or rollback of environmental protection, but as a structural realignment of how water quality science is applied within federal permitting.

Viewed through an environmental and environmental scientist lens, the proposal reflects both clear scientific advantages and legitimate ecological concerns, with important implications for how environmental professionals engage in water resource protection going forward.

Re-centering Section 401 on Water Quality Science

At its core, Section 401 asks a focused scientific question:

Will a discharge into waters of the United States comply with applicable water quality standards?

EPA’s proposed rule reinforces this framing by limiting certification review to point source discharges associated with federally licensed or permitted activities. This approach aligns Section 401 with the Clean Water Act’s post-1972 structure, which emphasizes effluent limits, water quality criteria, and compliance monitoring as the primary tools for protecting aquatic resources.

From an environmental scientist’s perspective, this clarity strengthens the technical foundation of Section 401 decisions by:

  • Reinforcing measurable cause-and-effect relationships
  • Anchoring analysis in numeric and narrative water quality standards
  • Improving transparency and reproducibility in certification determinations

Supporters of the rule view this as restoring Section 401 to a role that science is well equipped to support.

Environmental Concerns Rooted in Ecosystem Complexity

Environmental nonprofits and applied scientists have raised concerns that are also grounded in ecological science. Aquatic systems respond not only to discrete discharges, but to cumulative, indirect, and interacting stressors, such as hydrologic alteration, habitat fragmentation, and incremental wetland loss.

From this perspective, narrowing Section 401 review raises questions about:

  • Whether cumulative impacts can still be adequately addressed
  • How changes to flow, connectivity, and habitat quality will be evaluated
  • Whether other Clean Water Act programs are sufficient to capture ecosystem-scale effects

These concerns do not reject discharge-based science. Rather, they reflect the reality that not all ecologically significant impacts are easily attributable to a single discharge point, even when those impacts are measurable and biologically meaningful.

Precision Versus Breadth: A Scientific Tradeoff

The tension underlying EPA’s proposal is not science versus protection, but precision versus breadth.

From a pro-rule scientific standpoint:

  • Section 401 should focus on discharges because that is what the statute regulates
  • Expanding certification to entire project “activities” blurs scientific causation
  • Broader ecosystem concerns are more appropriately addressed through other Clean Water Act tools, such as water quality standards (Section 303), wetland permitting (Section 404), and nonpoint source programs

Critics counter that:

  • Those complementary programs are unevenly implemented
  • Narrowing Section 401 increases pressure on already limited regulatory pathways
  • Fragmenting environmental review risks leaving some impacts insufficiently addressed

Scientifically, both perspectives acknowledge the same constraint: no single Clean Water Act program can address all dimensions of ecosystem health.

Timelines, Data, and Decision Quality

EPA’s proposal reinforces the statutory one-year deadline for certification decisions and restricts withdrawal-and-resubmittal practices that have historically prolonged reviews.

From an environmental science perspective, this change:

  • Encourages earlier and more targeted data collection
  • Reduces procedural delay that does not necessarily improve scientific outcomes
  • Places greater emphasis on baseline data quality at the outset

Environmental advocates note that complex projects and data-limited watersheds may require more time to fully understand impacts, especially under climate-driven hydrologic variability. Scientifically, this highlights the growing importance of long-term monitoring and proactive data development, independent of permitting timelines.

What This Means for Environmental Consultants

The proposed rule also reshapes how environmental consultants and environmental scientists contribute to permitting and water quality protection.

Clearer Scope, More Focused Science

By limiting Section 401 review to point source discharges, consultants gain clearer boundaries for analysis. This supports more precise study design focused on:

  • Discharge characterization
  • Receiving water conditions
  • Applicable standards and criteria
  • Defensible cause-and-effect relationships

More Front-Loaded Technical Work

Standardized certification requirements and firm timelines are likely to shift consulting effort earlier in the project lifecycle. Consultants may be engaged sooner to ensure that:

  • Baseline data are adequate before submittal
  • Discharge-related impacts are fully evaluated upfront
  • Certification requests are technically complete

From a scientific standpoint, this front-loading improves decision quality by providing regulators with stronger data earlier in the process.

Increased Emphasis on Defensible Analyses

A discharge-focused framework elevates the importance of:

  • Quantifiable methods
  • Reproducible results
  • Clear linkage to water quality standards

This favors technically rigorous analyses—such as modeling, targeted monitoring, and biologically relevant indicators—over broader, less precise narratives.

Redistribution of Broader Environmental Work

Broader ecosystem concerns emphasized by environmental nonprofits do not disappear under the proposed rule. Instead, they are more likely to shift to:

  • Section 404 permitting and mitigation
  • Watershed-scale assessments
  • Water quality standards development and impairment analysis
  • Nonpoint source and cumulative impact studies

For consultants, this may result in more integrated, multi-program project roles, rather than reduced demand.

Reduced Procedural Rework

Limiting withdrawal-and-resubmittal practices may reduce repeated sampling and analysis driven solely by administrative delay, shifting consultant effort toward getting the science right the first time.

An Integrated Environmental Takeaway

From an environmental and environmental scientist perspective, EPA’s proposed Section 401 rule represents a re-definition of responsibility rather than a reduction in protection.

The proposal:

  • Strengthens scientific defensibility by focusing on discharge-based impacts
  • Clarifies regulatory expectations for data and analysis
  • Limits Section 401’s scope, increasing reliance on other Clean Water Act tools for ecosystem-scale protection

The critical question moving forward is not whether Section 401 should address every environmental concern, but whether the entire Clean Water Act framework is functioning as an integrated system capable of protecting the chemical, physical, and biological integrity of aquatic resources.

Public comments on the proposal are due February 17, 2026, offering environmental scientists, nonprofits, consultants, and regulators an opportunity to shape how clarity, scientific rigor, and environmental protection advance together.

Posted on — Leave a comment

The 2026 Nationwide Permits and Florida’s Status Under Nationwide Permit 24

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers finalized the 2026 Nationwide Permits (NWPs) on January 8, 2026. These permits replace the 2021 Nationwide Permits and will govern a large portion of Clean Water Act Section 404 authorizations nationwide for the next five years. While the overall structure of the nationwide permit program remains largely unchanged, the final rule includes clarifications and targeted revisions that affect how permits are applied, how Clean Water Act Section 401 is implemented, and how state and federal permitting authority is understood.

One of the most discussed changes in the final rule is the removal of Florida from Nationwide Permit 24, which applies in states that have assumed administration of the Section 404 program. Understanding this change requires looking at both how nationwide permits function and how Florida’s assumed program has evolved.

Overview of the Nationwide Permit Program

Nationwide permits are issued by the Corps under Section 404(e) of the Clean Water Act and, where applicable, Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act. They authorize categories of activities that the Corps has determined will result in no more than minimal individual and cumulative adverse environmental effects.

Nationwide permits are designed to streamline permitting for common activities such as utility crossings, bank stabilization, minor road crossings, and maintenance work. They operate subject to:

  • Nationwide permit specific terms and limits
  • Nationwide General Conditions
  • Regional conditions imposed by Corps divisions
  • Clean Water Act Section 401 water quality certification
  • Pre construction notification requirements where applicable

The 2026 Nationwide Permits become effective March 15, 2026 and are scheduled to expire on March 14, 2031.

Key Themes in the 2026 Nationwide Permits

The 2026 NWPs do not represent a major expansion or contraction of the program. Instead, the final rule emphasizes clarity and consistency. Notable themes include:

  • Clarification of how Section 401 water quality certification applies to nationwide permits
  • Greater emphasis on compliance with general conditions
  • Reinforcement of district engineer discretion through regional conditions
  • Clarification of how multiple nationwide permits may be used for a single project

These changes reflect a broader trend toward strengthening the administrative record and reducing ambiguity in permit implementation.


What Nationwide Permit 24 Is

Nationwide Permit 24 is different from most nationwide permits because it applies only in states that have assumed administration of the Clean Water Act Section 404 program under Section 404(g).

When a state assumes the Section 404 program, it becomes the primary permitting authority for most discharges of dredged or fill material into waters of the United States. Federal law, however, does not allow states to assume jurisdiction over all waters. The Corps retains authority over traditionally navigable waters, waters subject to Section 10, and certain adjacent waters.

Nationwide Permit 24 exists to authorize activities in those retained federal waters within assumed states. Its use depends on a clear and legally stable division of permitting authority between the state and the Corps.

Florida’s Section 404 Program Background

Florida began administering a state Section 404 program in December 2020 following approval by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The assumption did not transfer all federal permitting authority to the state. As a result, Florida operated under a divided regulatory framework in which both the state and the Corps issued permits depending on the type and location of waters affected.

Following EPA’s approval, litigation challenged whether the approval complied with the Endangered Species Act, particularly with respect to program level consultation. Federal courts vacated portions of the approval, creating uncertainty regarding the legal foundation of the assumed program.

Removal of Florida From Nationwide Permit 24

In the 2025 proposed Nationwide Permits, Florida continued to be listed as an assumed state under Nationwide Permit 24. The proposal did not suggest removing Florida or solicit comment on that issue.

In the 2026 final rule, the Corps removed Florida from Nationwide Permit 24. The Corps described this change as administrative and stated that it does not affect the number of activities authorized by nationwide permits. The removal aligns the nationwide permits with the current legal status of Florida’s Section 404 program at the time of finalization.

The change becomes effective March 15, 2026, when the 2026 Nationwide Permits take effect.

Practical Implications for Permitting in Florida

With Florida no longer listed under Nationwide Permit 24, the Corps remains the primary federal permitting authority for Section 404 activities involving waters of the United States in Florida, subject to the limits of federal jurisdiction.

Projects in Florida may still rely on other applicable nationwide permits or individual permits issued by the Corps, provided all applicable requirements are met. Clean Water Act Section 401 water quality certification remains required before a nationwide permit authorization becomes valid.

From a practical standpoint, the change underscores the importance of:

  • Verifying permitting authority early in project planning
  • Confirming which nationwide permits apply
  • Tracking state Section 401 certification decisions and conditions
  • Accounting for regional conditions imposed by the Corps

Broader Context

The Florida Nationwide Permit 24 issue highlights how nationwide permits depend on program level legal stability. Nationwide permits are intended to operate consistently across Corps districts. When the status of a state assumed program is uncertain, applying a permit designed specifically for assumed states becomes more complex.

The final rule does not resolve broader questions about the future of Florida’s assumed Section 404 program. Those issues remain subject to future administrative actions and court decisions.

Looking Ahead

The 2026 Nationwide Permits will guide federal wetland permitting through 2031. While many aspects of the program remain familiar, understanding targeted changes and state specific issues such as Florida’s status under Nationwide Permit 24 is essential for effective compliance and project planning.

The Swamp School will be addressing these topics in upcoming training, including a Nationwide Permits webinar on February 19, 2026, which will provide a detailed review of the final permits and their practical implications.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Unseen but Binding: How Technical Standards Quietly Shape WOTUS—and Why That Must Change

Why Technical Manuals Must Go Through Full APA Rulemaking

As the agencies move forward with the new proposed Waters of the United States (WOTUS) rule, the biggest issue may not be the definitions themselves—but the technical materials used to apply them in the field. Our recently submitted public comment focuses directly on this problem, and we want to highlight its core message for our community of wetland professionals.

(A link to the full, formal comment is provided below.)

The Central Issue: Substantive Technical Standards Require APA Rulemaking

Our comment emphasizes a straightforward principle supported by longstanding administrative law:

When a technical manual or scientific tool determines whether a water or wetland is jurisdictional under the Clean Water Act, that document functions as a substantive rule—and must be adopted through the Administrative Procedure Act’s notice-and-comment process.

Today, many of the documents that control jurisdictional decisions are not regulations. They were never put out for public comment, never published in the Federal Register, and never formally adopted as rules. Yet they are treated as mandatory in the field.

This gap creates legal risk, regulatory inconsistency, and confusion for the regulated public.

A Key Distinction: The Regional Supplements Did It Right

One important point we stress in the comment is that the Corps’ Regional Supplements did go through a full, structured public vetting process, including:

  • publication of drafts,
  • scientific peer review,
  • stakeholder engagement, and
  • incorporation of public feedback.

They stand as an example of how technical standards should be developed—transparently, scientifically, and with public involvement.

However, the problem arises because the Regional Supplements rely on a suite of other documents that did not undergo this process.

This includes:

  • The Field Indicators of Hydric Soils (v9.2)
  • The 2025 National OHWM Manual
  • The Streamflow Duration Assessment Method (SDAM)
  • The Antecedent Precipitation Tool (APT v3.0)
  • WebWIMP
  • The 1987 Wetland Delineation Manual

Although the Regional Supplements themselves were publicly vetted, they incorporate these additional materials—some even through dynamic incorporation—causing jurisdictional criteria to change outside any APA process.

The Exception That Proves the Rule: The National Wetland Plant List

One of the clearest examples of proper procedure is the National Wetland Plant List (NWPL).

The Corps—and its federal partners—recognized years ago that classifications of plant wetland status have real regulatory consequences. Whether a species is classified as obligate, facultative wetland, or upland can determine whether a site has hydrophytic vegetation and thus whether it is jurisdictional.

Importantly:

  • The NWPL was published in the Federal Register.
  • Revisions do undergo public notice and comment.
  • Stakeholders can review, challenge, and respond to proposed changes.
  • The agencies respond publicly to comments and issue updated lists based on that record.

This process is transparent, predictable, and legally defensible.

It is also the only major jurisdictional technical framework that has been treated this way.

The NWPL proves that the agencies know how to properly adopt a scientific standard through APA rulemaking. The comment argues that the same process must be applied consistently across all jurisdictional tools.

Hydric Soil Indicators: A Central Example

The NRCS Field Indicators of Hydric Soils are scientifically rigorous and invaluable to delineation, but they were created for internal USDA program use—not Clean Water Act jurisdiction.

When the Corps relies on these indicators to determine whether a wetland is regulated, the indicators effectively become federal rules. Revisions to these indicators can shift jurisdictional outcomes without:

  • public notice,
  • opportunity for comment, or
  • a formal rulemaking record.

Our comment argues that this places both landowners and practitioners in an untenable position and exposes the agencies to unnecessary legal vulnerability.

The Same Issue Appears Across Key Hydrologic Tools

Several critical methodologies—now widely used and often considered mandatory—were also never adopted as rules:

  • Streamflow Duration Assessment Method (SDAM)
  • Antecedent Precipitation Tool v3.0 (APT)
  • 2025 National OHWM Manual
  • WebWIMP geospatial screening system

Each directly influences jurisdictional determinations. Each can change outcomes. And none were formally promulgated.

Courts have repeatedly held that agencies cannot enforce such documents without following proper rulemaking procedures.

Why Listening Sessions Are Not a Substitute for APA Rulemaking

Although EPA has held various listening sessions, outreach meetings, and stakeholder briefings on technical wetland materials over the years, these activities do not constitute Administrative Procedure Act (APA) notice-and-comment rulemaking. Listening sessions provide opportunities for discussion and information exchange, but they are not published as proposed rules, do not open a formal docket, do not create an administrative record, and do not require the agency to respond to public input. Under the APA, substantive standards must be adopted through a structured process that includes Federal Register publication of a proposed rule, written public comments, agency responses, and publication of a final rule. Listening sessions can complement that process, but they cannot replace it. For technical materials that determine Clean Water Act jurisdiction, only full APA rulemaking ensures transparency, public participation, and legal durability.

What We Recommended to the Agencies

Our comment proposes a clear and workable solution:

  1. Adopt all jurisdiction-determining manuals and tools through APA notice-and-comment rulemaking.
  2. End the practice of dynamic incorporation, which allows external committees or other agencies to change federal jurisdiction without public participation.
  3. Include regulatory text in the new WOTUS rule stating that no technical standard may be used to determine jurisdiction unless it has been formally adopted as a rule.
  4. Require all future revisions to such technical standards to undergo the same APA process.

This would bring clarity, transparency, and legal durability to the entire WOTUS implementation framework.

Why This Matters for Wetland Professionals

If adopted, these changes would:

  • provide greater certainty for consultants,
  • ensure transparency in future revisions,
  • strengthen jurisdictional determinations against legal challenge, and
  • support consistent application of the WOTUS rule nationwide.

In short, formalizing the technical backbone of delineation work is essential for the long-term stability of Clean Water Act implementation.

Learn More in January: 2026 Wetland Status & Trends Webinar

This issue, along with the broader implications of the new WOTUS proposal, will be a major focus of our upcoming:

2026 Wetland Status & Trends Webinar

January 22, 2026 • 1 PM Eastern

We’ll break down:

  • evolving jurisdictional standards,
  • the status of technical manuals and tools,
  • anticipated regulatory shifts in 2026, and
  • how consultants can prepare for the coming changes.

Read the Formal Comment

For those who want the detailed and technical reasoning, including citations, our full public comment is available here:

Disclaimer: This summary is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult qualified legal counsel for guidance on specific regulatory or compliance matters.

Posted on — 1 Comment

WOTUS and Swampbuster Compliance for Agricultural Producers

Why Non-Jurisdictional Wetlands Can Still Trigger USDA Penalties

Disclaimer: This document is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Producers and consultants should seek guidance from qualified legal counsel regarding specific compliance obligations under the Food Security Act, the Clean Water Act, or related federal programs.

I. Introduction

The Environmental Protection Agency and the Department of the Army released the 2025 Proposed Definition of Waters of the United States. This action has generated significant confusion among agricultural producers about which wetlands fall under EPA authority and which remain subject to the Food Security Act administered by the United States Department of Agriculture.

A common misconception is that a wetland must be regulated under the Clean Water Act in order for a producer to face federal penalties for filling it. This is incorrect. The Food Security Act often applies to wetlands even when those same wetlands are not considered Waters of the United States. The purpose of this brief is to explain the legal frameworks and clarify when and why USDA penalties apply.

II. Statutory Framework

A. Clean Water Act Jurisdiction

The Clean Water Act governs the discharge of dredged or fill material into navigable waters as defined at 33 U.S.C. 1362(7). The 2025 Proposed WOTUS rule emphasizes two key factors: relatively permanent flow and a continuous surface connection. Wetlands that do not meet these criteria are not jurisdictional under the Clean Water Act and do not require permits under Section 404.

B. Food Security Act Wetland Compliance

The Food Security Act of 1985 creates wetland conservation requirements known as the Swampbuster provisions. These are codified at 16 U.S.C. 3801 through 16 U.S.C. 3862. The statutory provisions relevant to wetland identification and conversion include:

  1. 16 U.S.C. 3801(a)(27) which defines wetlands for USDA purposes.
  2. 16 U.S.C. 3821 which makes producers ineligible for USDA benefits following a wetland conversion.
  3. 16 U.S.C. 3822 which outlines certification processes including restoration, minimal effect, and mitigation criteria.

These statutory requirements are implemented through USDA regulations at 7 C.F.R. Part 12. NRCS defines wetlands based on hydric soils, hydrophytic vegetation, and wetland hydrology. There is no requirement for hydrologic connection to navigable waters. This means USDA wetland determinations operate independently from the WOTUS definition.

III. Independence of USDA Wetland Determinations

The 2025 WOTUS rule explicitly reaffirms that USDA makes its own determinations for the Food Security Act. EPA and the Corps acknowledge that the USDA retains full authority over prior converted cropland determinations and wetland certification for agricultural programs.

The agencies state that the USDA is responsible for making determinations as to whether land is prior converted cropland for its Food Security Act purposes.¹

They also state that USDA determinations of prior converted cropland will continue to be recognized for Clean Water Act purposes.²

This confirms that USDA wetlands are governed by the Food Security Act, not the Clean Water Act, and that the WOTUS rule has no bearing on Swampbuster applicability.

IV. USDA Penalties Apply Regardless of WOTUS Status

Under 16 U.S.C. 3821(a), a producer who converts a USDA-designated wetland becomes ineligible for a wide range of USDA program benefits until the wetland is restored or mitigation is approved. This penalty applies even if the wetland is not jurisdictional under the Clean Water Act.

Example

A producer fills a depressional wetland that has no continuous surface connection. The wetland is not WOTUS under the 2025 rule so no Section 404 permit is required. However, NRCS identifies the area as containing hydric soils, hydrophytic vegetation, and wetland hydrology. It is therefore a Swampbuster wetland. The producer becomes ineligible for FSA subsidies, crop insurance premium assistance, and other USDA benefits until compliance is restored.

This scenario illustrates the independence of the two systems. EPA and USACE may lack jurisdiction, yet USDA penalties still apply.

V. Prior Converted Cropland Under Both Statutory Schemes

Prior Converted Cropland is defined at 7 C.F.R. 12.2(a)(8) and 16 U.S.C. 3801(a)(8). The 2025 WOTUS rule continues to exclude PCC from jurisdiction unless abandoned. Abandonment occurs when the land has not been used for agricultural purposes for more than five years and wetland characteristics return.³

Importantly, abandonment for Clean Water Act purposes may not result in abandonment under USDA rules, and vice versa. USDA PCC determinations are made independently using the Food Security Act and the National Food Security Act Manual.

VI. USDA Conservation Programs Use USDA Definitions

USDA conservation programs, including the Wetland Reserve Program and Wetland Reserve Easements, rely exclusively on NRCS wetland determinations, not EPA jurisdiction. If a producer alters or damages a wetland protected under a USDA conservation contract, penalties, repayment obligations, and restoration requirements may be imposed regardless of Clean Water Act jurisdiction.

VII. Conclusion

A wetland does not need to be a Water of the United States for the Food Security Act to apply. Clean Water Act jurisdiction is not required for USDA to impose penalties for wetland conversion. The two statutes provide distinct definitions, regulatory standards, and enforcement authorities. Compliance with one statute does not guarantee compliance with the other, and producers must consider both before altering land that could contain wetland characteristics.

Agricultural producers and consultants should seek qualified legal counsel before conducting activities that may affect wetland areas or prior converted cropland, particularly under changing federal regulatory frameworks.

Endnotes

1. Environmental Protection Agency and Department of the Army, Updated Definition of Waters of the United States (Proposed Rule), prepublication version signed Nov. 17, 2025, p. 149.

2. Ibid., p. 150.

3. Ibid., pp. 143 to 144.

4. Food Security Act of 1985, Pub. L. 99 198, codified at 16 U.S.C. 3801 et seq.

5. 16 U.S.C. 3821. Ineligibility for program benefits for certain conversions of wetlands.

6. 16 U.S.C. 3822. Certification of wetlands including restoration, mitigation, and minimal effect provisions.

7. 7 C.F.R. Part 12. Highly Erodible Land and Wetland Conservation.

8. 7 C.F.R. 12.2(a)(27). Definition of wetland for USDA purposes.

9. 7 C.F.R. 12.2(a)(8). Definition of prior converted cropland.

10. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. National Food Security Act Manual, Parts 513 to 527.

Posted on — Leave a comment

The Future of NEPA: Implications of CEQ’s Regulation Removal on Wetlands and Environmental Protection

Summary of the Interim Final Rule on the Removal of National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Implementing Regulations and Its Impact on Wetlands

Overview of the Regulation Change

The Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) has issued an interim final rule removing its NEPA implementing regulations from the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), effective April 11, 2025. This decision follows Executive Order (E.O.) 14154, Unleashing American Energy, issued by President Trump on January 20, 2025, which rescinded E.O. 11991—the original directive that required CEQ to issue binding NEPA regulations. The rule is open for public comment until March 27, 2025.

The removal of CEQ’s regulations means that individual federal agencies will now be responsible for developing and implementing their own NEPA procedures without CEQ’s oversight. This shift aims to streamline environmental reviews and expedite project approvals, particularly for energy and infrastructure projects. However, it also raises concerns about weakened environmental protections, including for wetlands, mitigation banking, and stormwater management.

Background and Justification for CEQ’s Decision

NEPA, enacted in 1969, requires federal agencies to assess the environmental impacts of major projects before approval. In 1978, CEQ issued its first binding NEPA regulations under E.O. 11991, issued by President Carter. These regulations standardized environmental review procedures across federal agencies.

E.O. 14154 revokes CEQ’s authority to issue NEPA regulations and instead directs CEQ to issue non-binding guidance while allowing agencies to develop their own NEPA compliance rules. CEQ argues that without E.O. 11991, it may lack legal authority to maintain its NEPA regulations. Furthermore, recent court rulings—such as a D.C. Circuit Court decision in 2024 and a North Dakota district court ruling in February 2025—have questioned whether CEQ has the power to issue legally binding NEPA rules.

By removing its regulations, CEQ asserts that agencies will have greater flexibility in designing environmental review processes while reducing bureaucratic delays in permitting. However, critics argue that this move will weaken environmental oversight, particularly for projects that impact wetlands, mitigation banks, and floodplains.

Impact on Wetlands Management and Mitigation Banking

1. Increased Risk of Wetland Impacts

NEPA plays a crucial role in wetlands protection by requiring federal agencies to evaluate environmental impacts before permitting activities that may drain, fill, or alter wetlands. Without CEQ’s standardized regulations, wetlands may be at a higher risk for impacts due to:

  • Weakened Federal Oversight: Agencies like the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) and the EPA may adopt less rigorous environmental review standards for projects that impact wetlands.
  • Increased Wetland Fill Permits: Developers seeking permits under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act (CWA) could face less scrutiny, leading to more wetland impacts from highways, pipelines, and industrial sites.
  • State-Level Disparities: Some states have strong wetland protections, while others rely heavily on federal oversight. Without CEQ-mandated consistency, states with weaker regulations may approve more projects affecting wetlands.

2. Potential Risks to Mitigation Banking

Mitigation banking allows developers to offset wetland impacts by purchasing credits from restored or created wetlands. While mitigation banking can be an effective tool for conservation, removing CEQ’s NEPA regulations introduces several risks:

  • Easier Approval of Low-Quality Mitigation Banks: Without consistent federal review standards, mitigation banks with lower ecological value may receive approval.
  • “Paper” Mitigation Banks: Some mitigation banks may meet legal requirements but fail to provide meaningful wetland restoration.
  • More Development Without Adequate Offsets: Weaker NEPA reviews could lead to increased development in wetlands, without requiring developers to provide sufficient compensatory mitigation.

3. Possible Positive Outcomes

  • Faster Approvals for Wetland Restoration Projects: NEPA reviews can sometimes delay beneficial wetland restoration efforts. If agencies streamline their review processes, projects aimed at restoring degraded wetlands could proceed more quickly.
  • More Private Investment in Mitigation Banking: A less burdensome regulatory process could attract more private investors to mitigation banking markets, potentially expanding wetland restoration efforts.

Broader Implications of CEQ’s NEPA Regulation Removal

1. Who Benefits?

  • Developers and industries seeking faster permitting for infrastructure, energy, and construction projects.
  • Mitigation bankers looking for less regulatory red tape in establishing new mitigation sites.
  • State agencies that want more control over their environmental review processes.

2. Who Loses?

  • Conservation groups and environmental advocates, who rely on NEPA-mandated reviews to prevent wetland impacts.
  • Communities at risk of flooding, as wetlands play a key role in stormwater retention and flood control.
  • Future mitigation banking credibility, if lower-quality mitigation projects receive approval without strong oversight.

Regulatory Considerations and Legal Challenges

The interim final rule raises several legal and procedural issues:

  • Uncertainty Over NEPA Compliance: Agencies must now develop their own NEPA procedures, leading to inconsistencies in how environmental reviews are conducted.
  • Increased Litigation Risks: Environmental groups may challenge weaker agency-led NEPA reviews, leading to more lawsuits that delay projects.
  • State and Tribal Government Impacts: The rule shifts responsibility to states and tribal governments, which may lack resources to develop robust NEPA compliance frameworks.

Conclusion: More Risks Than Benefits for Wetlands and Environmental Protection

The removal of CEQ’s NEPA implementing regulations marks a major shift in federal environmental policy, reducing national oversight and placing more responsibility on individual agencies. While the intent is to streamline permitting, the greatest risks lie in the potential for weaker environmental reviews, particularly for projects impacting wetlands and mitigation banking.

  • Short-term impact: Increased approvals of development projects, with fewer environmental safeguards for wetlands.
  • Long-term impact: Uneven environmental protection, with some agencies tightening their NEPA procedures while others loosen them.
  • Biggest risk: Increased wetland impacts, weaker mitigation banking oversight, and a higher likelihood of legal challenges.
  • Potential benefit: Faster approvals for wetland restoration projects and increased private investment in mitigation banking.

The overall effect depends on how federal agencies respond—whether they strengthen their own NEPA processes or weaken environmental oversight to prioritize faster project approvals.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Turbulent Waters: Court Ruling Challenges White House Power Over Water Protections

How a Recent Court Ruling Could Complicate Waters of the United States (WOTUS) Rulemaking

A recent court decision in Marin Audubon Society v. FAA (No. 23-1067) may have significant implications for how the White House and federal agencies issue environmental regulations, particularly those related to the Clean Water Act’s (CWA) definition of “Waters of the United States” (WOTUS). The decision, issued by the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit on November 12, 2024, has sparked questions around the authority of the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) to set binding environmental rules under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA). As WOTUS regulations continue to be a critical component of federal water protection, this ruling could add complexity to the rulemaking process, opening the door to new challenges and delays.

Understanding the CEQ’s Role in Environmental Regulation

The CEQ, part of the Executive Office of the President, was created to coordinate federal environmental efforts and ensure that agencies adhere to NEPA. Traditionally, CEQ issues guidelines that all federal agencies follow to conduct NEPA environmental assessments, which include evaluating the impacts of major actions on the environment. This standardization helps create a consistent framework across agencies for environmental protection.

In Marin Audubon Society v. FAA, however, the court raised doubts about CEQ’s ability to enforce binding regulations across federal agencies, arguing that its authority is primarily derived from executive orders rather than direct Congressional approval. Judge Randolph’s opinion suggested that CEQ’s rulemaking power might not hold up in court, challenging the notion that agencies are bound to follow CEQ’s NEPA guidelines. For WOTUS rulemaking, this raises substantial questions about how federal agencies like the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) will conduct their environmental reviews and establish regulatory consistency.

Key Ways This Ruling Could Affect WOTUS Rulemaking

Here’s how the court’s decision could potentially complicate future WOTUS regulations:

1. Limiting CEQ’s Influence Over Federal Environmental Reviews

The CEQ has long set the NEPA guidelines for federal agencies to ensure consistency in environmental impact assessments. By questioning whether CEQ has the authority to issue binding NEPA rules, the court has created uncertainty about the future of this standardized approach. Without a binding CEQ framework, agencies might no longer be required to use a single approach to assess the environmental impacts of WOTUS rules, making it more challenging to create uniform protections for waters and wetlands across the nation.

Potential Impact: The EPA and USACE could face challenges in setting a consistent environmental baseline when drafting WOTUS rules. This could create inconsistencies across administrations, especially if each agency must interpret NEPA standards independently. With a fragmented regulatory approach, the White House might struggle to align WOTUS rulemaking with broader environmental objectives, such as national water quality and biodiversity goals.

2. Increased Legal Challenges to WOTUS Rules

The court’s ruling introduces a heightened level of scrutiny on executive authority. Since WOTUS rules often rely on extensive environmental assessments, a lack of clear CEQ authority could make these assessments vulnerable to legal challenges. Opponents of WOTUS rules could argue that without CEQ’s centralized authority, the environmental analyses conducted by agencies lack sufficient legal backing, increasing the likelihood of lawsuits that could block or delay WOTUS rule implementations.

Potential Impact: Legal battles have already been a major obstacle for WOTUS rules. If challengers focus on procedural aspects related to NEPA compliance, the rulemaking process could face further delays. Such challenges could undermine agencies’ ability to protect critical waters and wetlands, forcing EPA and USACE to revisit or revise their environmental analyses.

3. Shift Toward Agency-Specific NEPA Guidelines

If CEQ’s authority is ultimately limited, federal agencies may need to establish or strengthen their own NEPA compliance processes rather than relying on CEQ guidelines. This could lead to inconsistencies in how agencies interpret and apply NEPA standards, as each agency might develop unique procedures for assessing environmental impacts.

Potential Impact: WOTUS regulations could face delays as agencies work to create or adjust their own NEPA guidelines. This would not only slow the process of protecting water resources but also introduce complexity as each agency may weigh environmental impacts differently. Developing these agency-specific rules could lengthen the timelines for WOTUS rulemaking and might complicate enforcement if there are varying interpretations of environmental impacts across agencies.

4. Potential Constraints on the White House’s Climate and Water Protection Goals

The White House often relies on consistent, CEQ-led NEPA standards to ensure cohesive action across federal agencies, especially for ambitious goals such as those related to water conservation and climate change. With limitations on CEQ’s binding authority, it may become harder for the White House to drive a uniform environmental agenda and ensure that federal actions collectively work towards shared conservation objectives.

Potential Impact: WOTUS rules are essential for regulating water quality and protecting wetlands, which in turn play a crucial role in carbon sequestration, flood control, and habitat preservation. Without a consistent NEPA framework, the White House might find it challenging to align WOTUS rulemaking with broader environmental policies, potentially hampering efforts to meet water quality and climate goals. Additionally, a decentralized approach could lead to variability in enforcement, as agencies might follow different standards based on their unique NEPA guidelines.

5. Potential Rethink of Environmental Regulatory Strategy

The ruling could prompt the White House to explore alternative approaches to achieve its environmental objectives, especially if CEQ’s centralized authority remains in question. This might include working more closely with Congress to gain legislative backing for WOTUS or encouraging states to take a more active role in water protection.

Potential Impact: One option could be to shift more responsibility for water protection to the states, reducing federal reliance on WOTUS rules. Alternatively, the White House might pursue more public-private partnerships to address water conservation through collaborative projects rather than regulation alone. Such approaches could help the White House advance its goals despite the procedural challenges posed by the court’s decision, though they may be less effective than a cohesive federal approach.

Conclusion

The court’s ruling in Marin Audubon Society v. FAA (No. 23-1067) has introduced new complexities into the regulatory landscape for federal water protections like WOTUS. By calling into question the CEQ’s authority to issue binding environmental rules under NEPA, the court’s decision could slow down the WOTUS rulemaking process, open the door to more legal challenges, and limit the White House’s ability to enforce consistent environmental protections across agencies.

For those invested in the protection of U.S. water resources, this ruling highlights the importance of clear, well-supported regulatory authority. The White House may need to adapt by seeking legislative support for CEQ’s role or by exploring alternative regulatory strategies to continue advancing WOTUS protections. As federal agencies navigate these changes, the fate of critical waters and wetlands will remain a closely watched issue, with implications for conservation, climate resilience, and clean water access nationwide.

Posted on — Leave a comment

The Swamp School WOTUS Rule

Personal Statement: Why We Need the Swamp School WOTUS Rule

As a professional who has dedicated over 40 years to working with wetlands, I have had a front-row seat to the evolution—and at times, the decay—of the WOTUS program. I’ve watched policies shift from stringent federal control to more localized approaches, and I’ve seen the impacts these changes have had on our wetlands and waterways, our communities, and our economy. I’ve worked with landowners who are uncertain about their responsibilities, developers who are frustrated by regulatory delays, and conservationists who are determined to protect our water resources amidst shifting policies. This journey has reinforced my conviction that it is time for us to take matters into our own hands and build a WOTUS framework that is fair, responsible, and sustainable.

Throughout my career, I have witnessed both the strengths and weaknesses of federal oversight. There is no doubt that the Clean Water Act has played a vital role in protecting critical water resources and improving water quality across the country. However, as the regulatory landscape has changed, so too have the complexities and challenges of defining and enforcing WOTUS. Too often, jurisdictional determinations have become bottlenecks, with regulatory uncertainty leading to delays, increased costs, and growing frustration for everyone involved. The current system, while well-intentioned, has become a maze that is difficult to navigate, often leaving landowners, businesses, and environmental professionals at odds over water resources that are vital to all of us.

The Swamp School WOTUS Rule represents a new way forward, one that is rooted in my decades of experience and in the lessons I have learned from working directly with the land and water. This rule acknowledges the critical role of federal protections for key water resources, but it also respects the sovereignty and expertise of states to manage waters that fall outside federal jurisdiction. By reserving isolated, ephemeral, and other local waters for state management, we create a framework that empowers states to act in ways that make sense for their own unique landscapes, communities, and economies.

One of the most critical aspects of the Swamp School WOTUS Rule is the privatized jurisdictional determination process. Over the years, I have come to believe that water resources are best understood by those who have specialized training and on-the-ground experience. That’s why this rule calls for Certified WOTUS Determination Professionals (CWDPs) to lead the jurisdictional determination process. These trained professionals will make responsible, accurate, and timely determinations based on consistent criteria, backed by both federal and state oversight. By empowering certified professionals to assess jurisdiction, we streamline the process, reduce delays, and ensure that decisions are informed by real-world expertise.

I am also a firm believer in the principles of cooperative federalism, which have been woven into the very fabric of the Clean Water Act since its inception. The Swamp School WOTUS Rule builds on these principles by creating a partnership between federal agencies and the states, and between certified professionals and government regulators. This collaborative approach will give rise to a more efficient, accountable, and responsive WOTUS program that serves the needs of all Americans.

For me, the Swamp School WOTUS Rule is not just another regulation; it is a culmination of my life’s work and a commitment to the sustainable stewardship of our water resources. It’s a blueprint for a balanced approach that protects our most critical waters, respects the rights of states, and empowers trained professionals to do what they do best. This rule reflects decades of knowledge, and it embodies a vision for the future that is fair, sustainable, and grounded in the belief that effective water management must be practical, science-based, and adaptable to our changing world.

Of course, as much as I’d like to think we could officially call it the Swamp School WOTUS Rule, I’m pretty sure the powers-that-be will come up with something a little less colorful! I can almost hear it now: “The Clean Waters Collaborative Determination Act” or maybe “The Federated Waters Determination Framework.” But whatever name they choose, the heart of the rule will remain the same—protecting our water resources in a way that’s both responsible and sustainable. And hey, as long as they remember where it came from, they can call it whatever they like!

In closing, my hope is that the Swamp School WOTUS Rule will help foster a new era of water management—one that can evolve with the times while remaining steadfast in its commitment to responsible stewardship. This is more than a policy; it’s a promise to future generations that we are committed to protecting our waters with integrity, respect, and a deep understanding of their vital role in our lives. – Marc Seelinger, SPWS

The Swamp School WOTUS Rule

Purpose: The Swamp School WOTUS Rule offers a comprehensive and efficient approach to defining Waters of the United States (WOTUS), balancing federal oversight with enhanced state autonomy. It privatizes the jurisdictional determination process through a certification program for professionals authorized to assess water bodies as either federally or state-regulated. This rule focuses federal jurisdiction on waters essential to interstate commerce and environmental health, while empowering states to manage other water resources through state-specific programs.


Key Provisions of the Swamp School WOTUS Rule

1. Jurisdictional Waters Under Federal Authority

The rule focuses federal jurisdiction on water bodies with continuous, significant connections to traditional navigable waters (TNWs). These core water resources are critical for interstate commerce and ecological connectivity, making them subject to federal oversight under the Clean Water Act.

  • Traditional Navigable Waters (TNWs): Large rivers, lakes, bays, and tidal waters that are currently or historically used in interstate or foreign commerce.
  • Interstate Waters: Waters crossing or forming state boundaries with continuous surface connections to TNWs.
  • Relatively Permanent Tributaries: Perennial or intermittent streams, rivers, and other natural channels that flow into TNWs or interstate waters.
  • Adjacent Wetlands with Continuous Surface Connections: Wetlands directly abutting TNWs or relatively permanent tributaries, without natural or artificial barriers.
  • Impoundments of Jurisdictional Waters: Dams, reservoirs, or other impoundments that maintain a direct hydrological connection to a jurisdictional water.

2. Non-Jurisdictional Waters Reserved for State Management

Certain waters that do not meet federal criteria fall under state jurisdiction. States are empowered to manage these waters according to local priorities, creating unique regulations and programs tailored to specific environmental and economic needs. State jurisdiction covers:

  • Ephemeral Streams and Temporary Channels: Features that flow only after rainfall and lack continuous flow to TNWs.
  • Isolated Wetlands and Non-Continuous Interstate Waters: Wetlands without direct surface connections to TNWs or other jurisdictional waters.
  • Ditches and Man-Made Water Features Not Functioning as WOTUS: Non-navigable ditches, canals, and artificial features disconnected from WOTUS.
  • Groundwater: All groundwater remains outside the scope of federal jurisdiction.
  • Prior Converted Cropland and Certain Artificial Water Bodies: Agricultural lands and water bodies, such as irrigation ponds, disconnected from jurisdictional waters.

3. Certified WOTUS Determination Professionals (CWDPs) for Federal Determinations

The Swamp School WOTUS Rule establishes a privatized jurisdictional determination process through a network of Certified WOTUS Determination Professionals (CWDPs). CWDPs are authorized to conduct official WOTUS determinations and to classify water features as either federally regulated or state-regulated, based on the Swamp School WOTUS Rule.

  • Certification Process:
    • CWDPs complete rigorous training in federal WOTUS standards, hydrology, wetland science, and water law.
    • Certification requires passing a written exam and completing a field practicum demonstrating real-world skills in assessing water features.
    • Certified professionals must maintain credentials through continuing education to stay current with updates in regulation and environmental science.
  • Authority and Oversight:
    • CWDPs’ determinations are binding and subject to periodic review by the EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for quality assurance.
    • Determinations are documented in reports that include data, maps, and justification, ensuring transparency and consistency.
  • Transparency and Documentation: CWDPs submit detailed determination reports accessible to federal and state agencies, providing accountability and clarity for stakeholders.

4. State Jurisdictional Determination Program

In addition to the federal determination program, the Swamp School WOTUS Rule establishes a State Jurisdictional Determination Program. Under this system, each state has its own certification and licensing requirements for professionals conducting state-level jurisdictional determinations, similar to professional licensing in fields like law or medicine. This program ensures that individuals working in a particular state are qualified to make jurisdictional determinations in alignment with state-specific water management standards.

  • State-Specific Certification:
    • Each state will develop its own certification program for jurisdictional determinations, with specific training and licensure requirements tailored to regional priorities.
    • State-certified professionals must meet standards similar to CWDPs, with state-administered exams and field practicums relevant to local hydrology and environmental considerations.
    • Continuing education will be required to maintain state certification, ensuring that professionals remain knowledgeable about both state and federal changes.
  • Distinct Licensing Requirements: State-certified professionals will be licensed in their respective states, much like attorneys, to ensure they have in-depth knowledge of regional water management standards, ecosystems, and regulatory frameworks.
  • Collaborative Standards and Support: Federal agencies will provide resources and technical support to help states establish and maintain rigorous certification programs, promoting consistency and high standards nationwide.

5. Federal Oversight and Cooperative Federalism

The Swamp School WOTUS Rule emphasizes cooperative federalism, recognizing that water management is best achieved through collaboration between federal, state, and private sectors. Federal agencies support the certified professional network and work alongside states to maintain consistent, high standards in water resource management.

  • Federal Guidance and Resources: The EPA and Army Corps of Engineers will provide training materials, tools, and technical resources to support CWDPs and state certification programs.
  • Grant Programs for State Initiatives: States can apply for federal grants to support water management projects, including conservation, restoration, and water quality initiatives.
  • Interstate Collaboration: For shared water resources, federal agencies will facilitate cooperation between states, helping to harmonize water quality standards and regulatory approaches.

Benefits of The Swamp School WOTUS Rule

  1. Enhanced Efficiency and Consistency: By delegating jurisdictional determinations to certified professionals, the rule accelerates decision-making and reduces regulatory bottlenecks, benefiting landowners, developers, and conservationists.
  2. Increased Professional Accountability: Certified WOTUS Determination Professionals (CWDPs) and state-certified professionals bring high levels of expertise and accountability, ensuring reliable and accurate water assessments nationwide.
  3. Empowered State Management and Local Control: States gain primary responsibility over non-jurisdictional waters, allowing them to regulate based on regional needs and priorities, fostering innovation in water management.
  4. Transparent and Predictable Process: The rule creates a clear, predictable process for determining jurisdiction, with transparent documentation and accessible reports, which benefit all stakeholders by reducing uncertainty.
  5. Balanced Federal Protection for Key Waters: Federal jurisdiction is focused on core water resources that impact interstate commerce, downstream health, and ecological stability, while states retain autonomy over isolated and ephemeral waters.

Conclusion: A Balanced and Modern Approach to Water Management

The Swamp School WOTUS Rule represents a forward-thinking solution to defining Waters of the United States, blending federal protections with state rights and privatizing the jurisdictional determination process to increase efficiency and accuracy. By empowering a network of certified professionals and recognizing state-specific licensing, this rule fosters a cooperative approach that respects both national interests and local autonomy. It is a sustainable, balanced framework designed to ensure the protection and responsible management of America’s water resources, addressing the needs of today while paving the way for future generations.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Understanding the Proposed Clean Water Act of 2023: A New Era in Water Protection?

The Clean Water Act (CWA) has long been the cornerstone of water protection in the United States, but the environmental landscape has shifted, prompting lawmakers to propose updates to address modern challenges. In October 2023, a group of House Democrats introduced the Clean Water Act of 2023 (H.R. 5983), which aims to restore protections to U.S. waters following the Supreme Court’s Sackett v. EPA decision earlier in the year. The proposed changes could have significant implications for water management, environmental protection, and business regulation across the country.

Why a New Clean Water Act?

The primary motivation behind this update is the Supreme Court’s May 2023 ruling in Sackett v. EPA, which narrowed the definition of waters protected under the original Clean Water Act. This decision stripped federal protection from a significant portion of the nation’s wetlands and streams, reducing their regulation. The Clean Water Act of 2023 seeks to restore these protections by expanding the definition of Waters of the United States (WOTUS) and reinstating federal oversight over critical waterways.

Key Provisions of the 2023 Act

  1. Expanded Definitions of Protected Waters
    The Act aims to broaden the scope of protected waters, ensuring that small streams, wetlands, and other water bodies that lost federal protection after the Sackett ruling are once again regulated under federal law. This would close loopholes that have allowed pollution and degradation of these critical water sources.
  2. Stricter Permitting Processes
    The proposed law introduces tougher requirements for obtaining permits to discharge pollutants into protected waters. This is expected to have major implications for industries like construction and agriculture, which frequently interact with water bodies that may now fall under federal jurisdiction again.
  3. Focus on Wetland Conservation
    Recognizing the role wetlands play in flood control, water purification, and habitat provision, the new Act promotes stronger protections and increased restoration efforts for these ecosystems. Wetland mitigation banking is also supported, allowing developers more flexibility while still maintaining conservation goals.
  4. Climate Resilience
    The Act incorporates climate resilience into water management strategies. By funding green infrastructure projects and improving natural flood defenses like wetlands, the legislation seeks to mitigate the effects of climate change on U.S. water systems.

Important Dates and Legislative Progress

The Clean Water Act of 2023 was introduced in the House on October 18, 2023, by Rep. Rick Larsen (D-WA), alongside co-sponsors Rep. Grace Napolitano (D-CA), Rep. Don Beyer (D-VA), and Rep. Melanie Stansbury (D-NM). It was referred to the House Committee on Transportation and Infrastructure on October 25, 2023, and then to the Subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment on October 27, 2023.

On September 11, 2024 a hearing of the subcommittee on Water Resources and Environment was held. The hearing featured testimonies from various stakeholders, including representatives from:

  • Ms. Emma Pokon, Commissioner, Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation
  • Ms. Nicole Rowan, Director, Water Quality Control Division, Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment
  • Ms. Courtney Briggs, Chairman, Waters Advocacy Coalition, on behalf of the American Farm Bureau Federation
  • Mr. Vincent E. Messerly, P.E., President, Stream and Wetlands Foundation, on behalf of the National Association of Home Builders

They discussed the impacts of the Sackett decision on environmental protection, economic development, and the balance between federal and state regulatory roles.

Looking Ahead: What’s Next?

As the Clean Water Act of 2023 moves through the legislative process, it faces both support and opposition. Advocates for the bill emphasize its importance for restoring critical protections and promoting environmental health, while opponents argue that the expansion of federal water regulation could hamper economic development.

With the increasing challenges posed by climate change and population growth, the Clean Water Act of 2023 could play a pivotal role in shaping U.S. water policy for years to come. Keep an eye on this bill as it progresses through Congress, as its final form could have far-reaching impacts on water protection and management.