Why Technical Manuals Must Go Through Full APA Rulemaking
As the agencies move forward with the new proposed Waters of the United States (WOTUS) rule, the biggest issue may not be the definitions themselves—but the technical materials used to apply them in the field. Our recently submitted public comment focuses directly on this problem, and we want to highlight its core message for our community of wetland professionals.
(A link to the full, formal comment is provided below.)
The Central Issue: Substantive Technical Standards Require APA Rulemaking
Our comment emphasizes a straightforward principle supported by longstanding administrative law:
When a technical manual or scientific tool determines whether a water or wetland is jurisdictional under the Clean Water Act, that document functions as a substantive rule—and must be adopted through the Administrative Procedure Act’s notice-and-comment process.
Today, many of the documents that control jurisdictional decisions are not regulations. They were never put out for public comment, never published in the Federal Register, and never formally adopted as rules. Yet they are treated as mandatory in the field.
This gap creates legal risk, regulatory inconsistency, and confusion for the regulated public.
A Key Distinction: The Regional Supplements Did It Right
One important point we stress in the comment is that the Corps’ Regional Supplements did go through a full, structured public vetting process, including:
- publication of drafts,
- scientific peer review,
- stakeholder engagement, and
- incorporation of public feedback.
They stand as an example of how technical standards should be developed—transparently, scientifically, and with public involvement.
However, the problem arises because the Regional Supplements rely on a suite of other documents that did not undergo this process.
This includes:
- The Field Indicators of Hydric Soils (v9.2)
- The 2025 National OHWM Manual
- The Streamflow Duration Assessment Method (SDAM)
- The Antecedent Precipitation Tool (APT v3.0)
- WebWIMP
- The 1987 Wetland Delineation Manual
Although the Regional Supplements themselves were publicly vetted, they incorporate these additional materials—some even through dynamic incorporation—causing jurisdictional criteria to change outside any APA process.
The Exception That Proves the Rule: The National Wetland Plant List
One of the clearest examples of proper procedure is the National Wetland Plant List (NWPL).
The Corps—and its federal partners—recognized years ago that classifications of plant wetland status have real regulatory consequences. Whether a species is classified as obligate, facultative wetland, or upland can determine whether a site has hydrophytic vegetation and thus whether it is jurisdictional.
Importantly:
- The NWPL was published in the Federal Register.
- Revisions do undergo public notice and comment.
- Stakeholders can review, challenge, and respond to proposed changes.
- The agencies respond publicly to comments and issue updated lists based on that record.
This process is transparent, predictable, and legally defensible.
It is also the only major jurisdictional technical framework that has been treated this way.
The NWPL proves that the agencies know how to properly adopt a scientific standard through APA rulemaking. The comment argues that the same process must be applied consistently across all jurisdictional tools.
Hydric Soil Indicators: A Central Example
The NRCS Field Indicators of Hydric Soils are scientifically rigorous and invaluable to delineation, but they were created for internal USDA program use—not Clean Water Act jurisdiction.
When the Corps relies on these indicators to determine whether a wetland is regulated, the indicators effectively become federal rules. Revisions to these indicators can shift jurisdictional outcomes without:
- public notice,
- opportunity for comment, or
- a formal rulemaking record.
Our comment argues that this places both landowners and practitioners in an untenable position and exposes the agencies to unnecessary legal vulnerability.
The Same Issue Appears Across Key Hydrologic Tools
Several critical methodologies—now widely used and often considered mandatory—were also never adopted as rules:
- Streamflow Duration Assessment Method (SDAM)
- Antecedent Precipitation Tool v3.0 (APT)
- 2025 National OHWM Manual
- WebWIMP geospatial screening system
Each directly influences jurisdictional determinations. Each can change outcomes. And none were formally promulgated.
Courts have repeatedly held that agencies cannot enforce such documents without following proper rulemaking procedures.
Why Listening Sessions Are Not a Substitute for APA Rulemaking
Although EPA has held various listening sessions, outreach meetings, and stakeholder briefings on technical wetland materials over the years, these activities do not constitute Administrative Procedure Act (APA) notice-and-comment rulemaking. Listening sessions provide opportunities for discussion and information exchange, but they are not published as proposed rules, do not open a formal docket, do not create an administrative record, and do not require the agency to respond to public input. Under the APA, substantive standards must be adopted through a structured process that includes Federal Register publication of a proposed rule, written public comments, agency responses, and publication of a final rule. Listening sessions can complement that process, but they cannot replace it. For technical materials that determine Clean Water Act jurisdiction, only full APA rulemaking ensures transparency, public participation, and legal durability.
What We Recommended to the Agencies
Our comment proposes a clear and workable solution:
- Adopt all jurisdiction-determining manuals and tools through APA notice-and-comment rulemaking.
- End the practice of dynamic incorporation, which allows external committees or other agencies to change federal jurisdiction without public participation.
- Include regulatory text in the new WOTUS rule stating that no technical standard may be used to determine jurisdiction unless it has been formally adopted as a rule.
- Require all future revisions to such technical standards to undergo the same APA process.
This would bring clarity, transparency, and legal durability to the entire WOTUS implementation framework.
Why This Matters for Wetland Professionals
If adopted, these changes would:
- provide greater certainty for consultants,
- ensure transparency in future revisions,
- strengthen jurisdictional determinations against legal challenge, and
- support consistent application of the WOTUS rule nationwide.
In short, formalizing the technical backbone of delineation work is essential for the long-term stability of Clean Water Act implementation.
Learn More in January: 2026 Wetland Status & Trends Webinar
This issue, along with the broader implications of the new WOTUS proposal, will be a major focus of our upcoming:
2026 Wetland Status & Trends Webinar
January 22, 2026 • 1 PM Eastern
We’ll break down:
- evolving jurisdictional standards,
- the status of technical manuals and tools,
- anticipated regulatory shifts in 2026, and
- how consultants can prepare for the coming changes.
Read the Formal Comment
For those who want the detailed and technical reasoning, including citations, our full public comment is available here:
Disclaimer: This summary is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult qualified legal counsel for guidance on specific regulatory or compliance matters.
