Posted on — Leave a comment

Wetland Wednesday: Can You Crack the Hydric Soil Challenge?

Your next field adventure starts below the surface.

Grab your virtual field kit and explore Below the Surface, our free hydric soil adventure from The Swamp School.

Travel across the map, investigate soil profiles, and follow the evidence. Your mission: identify the hydric soil indicators the evidence supports, then defend your call.

The app uses the latest USDA/NRCS Field Indicators of Hydric Soils in the United States, Version 9.3. Practice with the current indicator guidance, explore the built-in field guide, and sharpen your memory with photo flashcards.

Free to play. No student account required.

Ready for another adventure? Visit swampschool.org and find our Choose Your Adventure interactives, including The Friday Deadline and The Closing Clock. Make decisions through a wetland project or Phase I environmental assessment, and reach the end to receive a $100 coupon toward eligible Swamp School classes.

Bring your curiosity. Then challenge a colleague to compare field calls!

Posted on — Leave a comment

What the Corps Wants Applicants to Know About Wetland Reviews

Three professionals in hard hats review a site plan in a wetland area during autumn, with a construction site visible in the distance.

WOTUS changes, review backlogs, and practical lessons from a Wilmington District discussion.

You have the fieldwork. You have the plans. You have submitted the application.

Now the project team wants a date.

When will the Corps respond? Does the project need a jurisdictional determination? Will the town accept anything else? What happens if the wetland rules change while everyone is waiting?

These questions were at the center of a public meeting hosted by the North Carolina Association of Environmental Professionals (NCAEP) on November 5, 2026, at Stantec’s office on Jones Franklin Road in Raleigh, with representatives of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ Wilmington District.

The discussion offered a candid look at the pressures facing reviewers and applicants alike. Staff acknowledged delays, explained what makes applications harder to process, and described changes they hope will improve coordination.

Here are the takeaways for environmental professionals, landowners, engineers, and developers.

Another WOTUS rule may arrive in spring 2027

Corps staff said headquarters was projecting a new “waters of the United States,” or WOTUS, rule for spring 2027.

That is a planning estimate. Staff did not present a confirmed release date, an effective date, or the final details of the rule.

They also acknowledged a familiar challenge: agency personnel and the people preparing applications need to understand how a new rule will work, often with limited time to prepare.

Staff discussed training and outreach once more information becomes available. For anyone planning work around wetlands and streams, the spring projection is something to watch. It is not a basis for assuming what the final requirements will be.

The backlog is substantial, but it is moving

Corps representatives reported approximately 601 pending jurisdictional determinations in the Wilmington District, down from 742 in recent months.

That reduction represents progress. It also leaves a considerable workload.

The same staff must handle permits, jurisdictional reviews, compliance matters, and other responsibilities. Administration priorities, including certain energy and transportation projects, also influence which work receives attention.

To distribute assignments, projects may go to a regional review team or someone outside the applicant’s usual field office.

That can be frustrating when a consultant has already spent time explaining a complicated site to another project manager. Staff encouraged applicants to flag cases where reassignment could disrupt substantial prior coordination so the office could evaluate how to proceed.

For applicants, keeping a clear record of earlier discussions can help preserve continuity when a project changes hands.

Start by identifying the decision you need

Several documents commonly discussed as “wetland approvals” answer different questions.

A wetland delineation identifies where wetlands occur and establishes their boundaries.

A delineation concurrence documents the Corps’ agreement with aquatic-resource boundaries without resolving whether those resources are federally jurisdictional.

An approved jurisdictional determination, or AJD, provides the Corps’ formal determination of whether jurisdictional waters are present or absent and the extent of federal jurisdiction.

A preliminary jurisdictional determination, or PJD, allows an applicant to pursue permitting while setting aside the jurisdictional question and treating the identified resources as jurisdictional for that process.

An AJD is not a permit authorizing construction or filling. Likewise, agreement with a wetland boundary does not necessarily establish whether the wetland is federally regulated.

Staff encouraged applicants to discuss which review serves the project’s needs. Some permit applications can proceed without a separate jurisdictional determination.

An AJD can be valuable when federal jurisdiction affects project design, mitigation costs, investment decisions, or the ability to proceed. It also requires more review than a delineation concurrence.

Before requesting a document, the project team should be able to explain what decision depends on it.

“Best in, first out” puts application quality in focus

One phrase from the meeting deserves attention: “best in, first out.”

Staff explained that a well-supported application that can be resolved efficiently may move ahead of an older submission requiring substantial follow-up.

Applicants cannot control agency staffing. They can make their submissions easier to understand and verify.

The Corps highlighted several useful practices:

  • Provide clear maps showing aquatic resources and proposed impacts.
  • Include complete field documentation and photographs that explain site conditions.
  • Use consistent project names so reviewers can connect current work with earlier actions.
  • Give attachments descriptive filenames.
  • Explain each impact in plain language.

For example, a stream crossing may involve a culvert, temporary dewatering, riprap, and bank stabilization. Describing those components helps a reviewer understand what will happen and how the impact quantities relate to the plans.

A reviewer who can follow the project from the map to the data to the impact table has fewer questions to send back.

Explain the design decisions behind the impacts

The mitigation discussion began before anyone talked about buying credits.

Staff emphasized the full sequence: avoid impacts, minimize those that cannot be avoided, and then address compensation for remaining unavoidable impacts.

An application should explain how the design reached that point.

Was a road shifted away from a wetland? Was a retaining wall used to reduce the grading footprint? Were slopes adjusted? Can the construction schedule accommodate environmental restrictions?

These decisions may already be familiar to the design team. They still need to appear in the application.

A clear narrative helps the Corps document its review without reconstructing months of design work through emails and information requests.

Coordinate species and historic-resource reviews early

Corps representatives also discussed information about listed species, habitat, and historic resources.

They asked consultants to provide useful supporting information while coordinating with the Corps on the scope of its review. Depending on the project and applicable requirements, that scope may differ from the entire development site.

Staff explained that independent coordination with other agencies can create additional work when it addresses a different area from the one relevant to the Corps’ action.

An early conversation can help establish what information is needed and how consultation should proceed. Staff also asked applicants to provide access to relevant U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service project information when submitting applications.

The practical lesson is to establish the review approach before different participants begin working from different assumptions.

RRS improvements are still underway

The Regulatory Request System, or RRS, remains the Corps’ submission platform.

Staff acknowledged technical frustrations and described ongoing work to improve coordination with North Carolina’s joint application process. The goal is to reduce duplicate entries and improve information exchange between federal and state systems.

They encouraged specific feedback about problems that affect preparation or review.

A useful comment identifies the step, explains what happens, and describes the extra work it creates. Participants also discussed opportunities for consultants who frequently use the system to help test improvements.

Local approvals can depend on federal paperwork

Participants raised concerns about municipalities withholding building permits or certificates of occupancy while applicants wait for AJDs.

Corps representatives explained that a local requirement does not obligate the Corps to issue a determination on the municipality’s schedule. They offered to discuss documentation needs directly with local governments.

The discussion did not settle whether any particular local requirement is valid. Corps guidance recognizes that applicants may request AJDs to satisfy state or local authorization requirements, while also describing agency discretion and its general practice of honoring requests. Regulatory Guidance Letter 16-01 provides additional background.

When a project is stalled, the first step is to identify the exact document being requested and the concern it is intended to resolve.

Is the question about federal jurisdiction? Wetland boundaries? Compliance with an approved plan? An earlier permit?

Those questions may involve different documents, different professionals, and different paths forward.

More conversation before submission, and more outreach afterward

Staff encouraged pre-application coordination for projects with questions that would benefit from discussion before a full submission.

They also acknowledged that arranging those conversations has sometimes taken too long and discussed improving responsiveness.

Corps representatives expressed interest in more regular outreach through meetings, newsletters, and virtual presentations as new information becomes available.

That continued communication will matter as applicants work through the current backlog, adapt to the application system, and prepare for another possible WOTUS change.

For your next project meeting, consider putting three questions on the agenda: What decision do we need? What information supports it? Who needs to act next?

This article summarizes comments made during the November 5, 2026, public NCAEP meeting with Wilmington District staff. Projections and processing practices discussed at the meeting may change. The discussion did not establish new regulatory requirements or decide individual projects.

What question would you like the Corps to address at a future outreach meeting? Share it in the comments.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Two Minutes to Build Your Wetland Field Skills

Two field researchers crouch by a marsh, examining a clump of soil and roots while the man points to it as the woman takes notes nearby.

Introducing Swamp School Field Briefs—free, practical lessons delivered Tuesdays and Thursdays.

Where should you place a vegetation plot? Why can plant cover total more than 100%? What is the difference between identifying a wetland and determining federal jurisdiction?

These are small questions with practical consequences. They influence what you observe, what you record, and how clearly you explain your findings.

You may have encountered them in a course, worked through them on a project, or wished you could ask an instructor while standing beside a soil pit.

Our new Swamp School Field Briefs series gives these questions a place of their own.

One topic. Two minutes. Something you can use.

Each Field Brief explores one specific wetland topic in about two minutes.

You’ll find a clear takeaway, a practical example, a common mistake to watch for, and a short question to help you apply the idea. Sources are included so you can explore the subject further.

The lessons are designed for a quick read before a field day, between projects, or whenever you want to revisit a concept.

What will we cover?

Wetland plants: Representative sampling, plant cover, indicator ratings, and evaluating the surrounding community.

Hydric soils: Reading Munsell colors, identifying the matrix, and describing contrasting soil features.

Hydrology: Looking below the surface, recognizing evidence of past water, and considering rainfall when interpreting site conditions.

Regulations: Understanding the purpose and scope of delineations, jurisdictional determinations, and other regulatory documents.

Field methods: Writing useful notes, taking photographs with context, and connecting observations to conclusions.

Start with a question you’ve had in the field

Our opening lessons include:

  • Where Should You Place Your Vegetation Plot?
  • Why Plant Cover Can Add Up to More Than 100%
  • What Does “10YR 4/2” Actually Mean?
  • No Standing Water? Check Below the Surface.

The Start Here post introduces the series and provides a growing topic index. As lessons are published, you’ll be able to explore related subjects and return to earlier briefs.

For new practitioners—and experienced teams

If you are new to wetland work, use the series to build familiarity with individual skills.

If you have years of experience, use it to revisit a difficult concept or start a discussion with a newer colleague. Supervisors can share a relevant brief before a field assignment and discuss the practice question with their team.

These short lessons complement the detailed instruction and field practice offered through Swamp School courses.

Join us Tuesdays and Thursdays

Field Briefs are free. Subscribe to The Swamp School on Substack and enable Field Briefs in your subscription preferences to receive the lessons.

What question has made you pause during wetland fieldwork? Leave a comment. Your question could become a future Field Brief.

Marc Seelinger, SPWS
Founder, The Swamp School

Posted on — Leave a comment

A Two-Acre Turning Point? What the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act Could Mean for Wetlands

Dawn scene of a wetland with still water, grasses, and trees, a construction excavator on a dirt hill to the right.

September 30, 2026 | Washington, D.C.

A proposed federal permitting bill could substantially change how the United States authorizes wetland impacts, even without rewriting the definition of “waters of the United States.”

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 would change several important parts of the Clean Water Act, including nationwide permits, state water quality certifications, EPA oversight, and challenges to permit decisions.

The legislation was introduced September 30, 2026, as S. 5653. It remains a proposal, so the changes discussed here depend on what Congress ultimately passes.

For wetland scientists, landowners, engineers, and environmental consultants, the central issue is straightforward: a wetland could remain federally jurisdictional while becoming substantially easier to impact through the permitting process.

WOTUS and permitting answer different questions

Wetland regulation involves two separate questions.

First, is the wetland a water of the United States, commonly called WOTUS? That determines whether the Clean Water Act applies.

Second, if the wetland is jurisdictional, what authorization is needed to discharge dredged or fill material into it?

The bill’s Clean Water Act provisions focus heavily on that second question. They do not directly establish a new definition of WOTUS or a new continuous surface connection test.

Section 1201 would, however, change where challenges to federal WOTUS definitions are heard by adding those agency actions to the Clean Water Act’s direct federal appeals court review provisions.

For practitioners, this distinction matters. A broader permitting pathway does not make a wetland non-jurisdictional. Delineation and jurisdictional analysis would still be essential to determining which requirements apply.

Less than two acres would receive special treatment

One of the most consequential provisions appears in Section 1204.

For general-permit decisions, the bill would direct the Army Corps of Engineers to consider the effects of a discharge of dredged or fill material into less than two acres of navigable waters to be a minimal adverse environmental effect.

That is a significant policy choice. Congress would establish an acreage-based conclusion about environmental effects rather than leave the entire determination to agency evaluation.

The precise wording matters: the attached text says less than two acres, not two acres or less.

The bill would also require the Corps to maintain nationwide permits for qualifying activities associated with five specified permits:

Nationwide permitActivity category
NWP 12Oil or natural gas pipeline activities
NWP 14Linear transportation projects
NWP 43Stormwater management facilities
NWP 57Electric utility line and telecommunications activities
NWP 58Utility line activities for water and other substances

For this requirement, the bill uses a threshold of less than two acres for each “single and complete project,” incorporating specified regulatory definitions.

This would not create a blanket exemption allowing anyone to fill any wetland smaller than two acres. The provision concerns discharges, general permitting, specified activity categories, and project definitions. Permit conditions and other applicable requirements would still need to be evaluated.

The potential consequence is nevertheless substantial: more impacts could move through general permitting rather than a more extensive individual-permit process.

An acreage threshold cannot describe every wetland’s value

From a wetland science perspective, acreage provides useful information, but it does not fully describe function.

A small wetland may occupy an important position in a watershed, provide habitat, retain floodwater, or intercept pollutants. Its importance depends on its characteristics and location, as well as its size.

The bill’s proposed threshold raises an important question: Should a discharge into less than two acres be treated as minimally adverse because of acreage alone?

There is also a cumulative-effects concern. Numerous individually small impacts can add up across a watershed.

For linear infrastructure, how the incorporated “single and complete project” definitions apply to individual crossings would deserve close attention. A threshold applied to separate qualifying crossings is different from one applied to the entire length of a pipeline or utility corridor.

These are practical implementation questions with consequences for both project planning and aquatic resource protection.

General-permit review would focus on water quality

Section 1204 would also narrow the Corps’ analysis when determining environmental effects under the general-permit provisions.

The Corps would be directed to consider only the effects of dredged or fill discharges on compliance with defined water quality requirements.

That would constrain the ability to weigh wetland functions as independent considerations in that determination. Wildlife habitat, flood storage, and other functions would not necessarily receive separate consideration simply because they are environmentally important.

Some of those functions may relate to applicable water quality requirements. The concern is that the proposed statutory test would be narrower than a broader evaluation of wetland ecological effects.

My assessment is that this could simplify general-permit decisions while reducing the range of wetland values those decisions expressly address.

States and Tribes would face tighter certification limits

Section 1202 would substantially revise Section 401 water quality certification.

The bill would limit certification to compliance with specifically defined water quality requirements. It would also require a certifying authority to support a denial with clear and convincing evidence that no modification or reasonable condition could allow certification without violating those requirements.

Conditions would face similar scrutiny. The authority would need clear and convincing evidence that they are necessary, the least burdensome means of ensuring compliance, and consistent with the federal license or permit requirements.

For applicants, this could provide greater predictability and stronger grounds to challenge conditions.

For states and Tribes, it would narrow discretion and increase the evidentiary burden supporting their decisions.

The bill also establishes application procedures and review deadlines, including a maximum nine-month review period for specified interstate natural gas and electric transmission projects. Those projects would receive special treatment focused on direct point source discharges.

These changes concern federal Section 401 certification. They should not be read as automatically eliminating separate state wetland, buffer, stormwater, or other permitting requirements.

Permit programs could operate on longer cycles

The bill would extend the maximum term of Section 404 general permits from five years to ten years. It expressly preserves the ability to modify a general permit during its term or renewal.

Section 1203 would also extend the statutory maximum term for NPDES permits issued under approved state programs from five years to ten years.

Longer terms could reduce administrative workload and give applicants greater continuity. They could also mean longer intervals between routine program reconsideration.

For wetland professionals, the practical question would be how agencies use their remaining authority to respond to changing conditions during those longer permit terms.

EPA oversight and court remedies would be restricted

The proposal would limit EPA’s Section 404(c) authority to prohibit or restrict disposal sites to the period between submission of a complete permit application and issuance of the permit. That amendment would apply to applications submitted after enactment.

This would give applicants more certainty about when EPA could intervene, while removing that authority outside the specified window.

Section 1205 would also generally establish a 150-day deadline for challenges to Section 404 permits and general-permit verifications, unless a shorter deadline applies.

Even when a court finds a permitting decision unlawful, the bill would sharply restrict its ability to halt the authorized activity. The court would generally need to find an imminent and substantial danger to human health or the environment for which no other equitable remedy is available.

That matters for wetlands because correcting a permit decision after filling has occurred may not restore the resource that was lost.

What wetland professionals should take away

The legislation could change the consequences of a jurisdictional finding without changing the finding itself.

A wetland could remain WOTUS, yet its proposed impacts could qualify for a broader general-permit pathway, face narrower certification conditions, and receive stronger protection against later permit disruption.

Consultants would still need accurate delineations, defensible jurisdictional documentation, clear impact calculations, and careful analysis of project boundaries. They would also need to explain the difference between a jurisdictional determination, a permit authorization, and compliance with other applicable laws.

Faster and more predictable permitting is a legitimate goal. The scientific question is whether the proposed shortcuts preserve meaningful evaluation of wetland functions and cumulative losses.

For those who work in wetlands, this bill deserves attention alongside the continuing WOTUS debate. Which waters are protected and how impacts to those waters are authorized are equally important parts of the regulatory picture.

#Wetlands #CleanWaterAct #WetlandPermitting #EnvironmentalRegulations #WetlandWednesday #TheSwampSchool

Posted on — Leave a comment

Ecobot’s Lee Lance Joins Swamp School LIVE! on October 29th

Field researcher in a blue shirt and hat uses a yellow water-quality probe in shallow mangrove estuary, taking notes beside the water.

Thursday, October 29, 2026, at 1 PM Eastern

A day in the wetlands can generate a lot of information: vegetation lists, soil descriptions, hydrology observations, photographs, and boundary locations. Getting those observations into an organized, accurate report is another part of the job.

For our next Swamp School LIVE!, we’re excited to welcome Lee Lance, co-founder and CEO of Ecobot, for a conversation about how technology is changing that workflow.

Lee will join Marc Seelinger of The Swamp School to discuss Ecobot’s features and how wetland scientists can use them in the field and back at the office. We also plan to include a live screen demonstration so you can see how field observations become project deliverables.

What will we cover?

We’ll explore practical questions that come up during wetland delineation and reporting:

  • How does Ecobot move information from a field sample point to a completed wetland data form?
  • What works when you are out of cell service?
  • How can AI-assisted plant identification and hydric soil suggestions support field work?
  • What can software catch during quality review, and what still requires and experienced scientist?
  • How can maps, photographs, and observations help document continuous surface connection?
  • What should a small consulting firm know before adopting a new field data system?

We’ll also ask Lee about Ecobot’s precipitation analysis tools, reporting capabilities, and what is coming next.

Throughout the conversation, we’ll focus on how these tools support the decisions wetland scientists make. A completed form is only useful when the observations and reasoning behind it are sound. We want to hear how Ecobot helps users preserve that connection between the fieldwork and the finished report.

Bring your questions

This is a live conversation, and you can participate through our call-in and chat Q&A. Whether you already use Ecobot, are considering it, or simply want to understand where wetland field technology is heading, this is an opportunity to ask questions directly.

Call-in number: (919)-297-2540

Mark your calendar for October 29 at 1 PM Eastern and join us for Swamp School LIVE!
The recording will also be posted on YouTube and Substack for those who cannot attend live.

#Ecobot #DataCollection #WetlandDelineation #SwampSchoolLIVE #WetlandWednesday #TheSwampSchool

Posted on — Leave a comment

The New WOTUS Proposal Promises Less Paperwork. It Could Create a Corps Backlog.

The proposal promises less paperwork, but it could turn one wetland delineation into two boundary investigations—and the agencies have not published a method for drawing the second boundary.

By Marc Seelinger, SPWS

EPA and the Department of the Army published a new WOTUS proposal today that could remove most intermittent streams—and potentially large portions of many wetlands—from federal Clean Water Act jurisdiction.

It is being presented as deregulation. The agencies predict fewer federal permits, lower costs, and greater certainty. The Army has placed the effort under its “Building Infrastructure, Not Paperwork” initiative.

But there is a serious problem: the agencies have not provided a credible method for applying either of the new jurisdictional tests.

The proposal may reduce federal jurisdiction. It does not reduce the work needed to prove where jurisdiction ends. In practice, it could create more investigations, more disputes, and a new nationwide backlog of Corps jurisdictional-determination reviews.

That helps no one—not even developers.

The Supplemental Notice of Proposed Rulemaking was published September 9, 2026, at 91 FR 57284. Comments are due October 9 under Docket No. EPA-HQ-OW-2025-0322. Read the published proposal.

Two new alternatives

The proposal adds two alternatives to the WOTUS rule proposed in November 2025. Neither is current law.

The first would generally limit “relatively permanent waters” to perennial waters. A stream would need standing or continuously flowing water every day of an ordinary year. One ordinary interruption lasting up to 30 consecutive days could be allowed.

The word one creates an immediate problem. A stream that is dry once for 30 days could qualify. A stream that is dry twice for one day each could fail—even though the second stream contains water on 28 more days during the year.

That is a legal bright line, not a scientifically credible measure of stream permanence. The agencies acknowledge that there is no precise, scientifically grounded, nationally consistent basis for the 30-day limit.

The second alternative concerns wetlands. It would require perennial surface water within a wetland to be continuously connected to surface water in a jurisdictional water. The connection must make it difficult to tell where the jurisdictional water ends and the wetland begins.

Only the connected portion of the wetland might be federally jurisdictional. This could create two separate boundaries on the same property: the scientifically delineated wetland boundary and a new federal boundary somewhere inside it.

The agencies anticipate that most intermittent streams would fail the first test. They also anticipate that a majority of wetlands currently regulated as adjacent wetlands would fail the second because most wetlands do not contain perennial surface water.

There is no published procedure for making these decisions

The Swamp School reviewed the proposal, existing Corps and ERDC procedures, and relevant scientific literature. We found useful methods for studying streamflow duration and wetland connectivity. We did not find a validated procedure capable of answering the exact legal questions the agencies propose.

A one-time site visit cannot establish whether water was present every day of an ordinary year. Finding a dry stream does not reveal when it dried, whether this was its first or second interruption, or whether the cause was ordinary or anomalous.

Streamflow Duration Assessment Methods can estimate whether a stream is typically ephemeral, intermittent, or perennial. They do not reconstruct a day-by-day record or distinguish one interruption from two. EPA scientists have explained that streamflow duration exists along a continuum and that classifications require regional calibration and treatment of uncertainty. Fritz et al. (2020)

Maps, models, and satellite imagery cannot fill the gap. Tree canopy, shadows, narrow channels, shallow water, cloud cover, mapping errors, and time between images prevent them from proving daily surface-water conditions at property scale.

For wetlands, the problem is harder. Existing delineation methods identify the boundary between wetland and non-wetland. They were not designed to locate a second boundary inside one continuous wetland based on the daily persistence of surface water.

Published connectivity studies have required water-level instruments, repeated site visits, precipitation records, channel inspections, and elevation data. That research is valuable, but it is not a national jurisdictional-boundary protocol. McDonough et al. (2015)

The proposal nevertheless suggests that a landowner could identify the connected portion of a wetland by observation or “the naked eye.” That claim is difficult to reconcile with a test requiring proof of perennial water, ordinary conditions, drought exceptions, and no more than one qualifying interruption.

Why developers should be concerned

The agencies assume narrower jurisdiction will mean fewer Section 404 permits and lower costs. That may be true after a property owner obtains a defensible non-jurisdictional decision. The unanswered question is what it will cost—and how long it will take—to get that decision.

A developer cannot finance and design a project based on a national estimate that “most” intermittent streams or wetlands will be excluded. The developer needs a reliable answer for the specific property. Lenders, purchasers, engineers, local governments, and investors may also demand Corps confirmation.

Under the new alternatives, consultants may need to document streamflow over time, distinguish ordinary conditions from drought, investigate separate interruptions, map perennial surface water inside wetlands, and defend an internal jurisdictional boundary.

That work occurs before anyone knows whether a permit has been avoided.

Delays at that stage can affect purchase contracts, financing, engineering plans, local approvals, construction schedules, and mitigation decisions. A theoretical reduction in jurisdiction has little value if the project waits months for an answer that no published method can reliably produce.

Why the Corps backlog could grow

Without a national procedure, each Corps district—and potentially each project manager—will have to decide what evidence is sufficient.

How many site visits are enough? How long must monitoring continue? What water depth counts? Where should sensors be placed? Which drought category controls? What happens when field observations conflict with maps or imagery? How is the internal wetland boundary surveyed?

Different applicants will submit different evidence. Corps reviewers will request additional information, resolve conflicting indicators, and prepare decisions capable of surviving administrative appeals and litigation.

The likely result is more case-by-case analysis and more requests for AJDs. The Corps may eventually process fewer permit applications, but it could first inherit a larger and substantially more complicated jurisdictional-review workload.

This is paperwork moved to the front of the project, where delay is often most expensive.

A rule that helps no one

Developers do not benefit from an uncertain and potentially slower approval process. The Corps does not benefit from being handed new tests without validated procedures or additional resources. Consultants do not benefit from inconsistent district expectations. States and Tribes may inherit responsibility for excluded waters without uniform programs or additional capacity. Environmental interests could lose federal protections without gaining a clear or scientifically defensible boundary.

The agencies should withdraw both alternatives in their current form.

Before adopting either one, EPA and the Army should disclose any technical review conducted by Corps districts or ERDC, complete a geographically representative multi-district pilot study, quantify the expected effect on AJD workloads and processing times, and demonstrate acceptable accuracy and inter-observer reproducibility.

Any resulting methodology should be published for public comment before the jurisdictional standard is finalized—not developed afterward through inconsistent case-by-case decisions.

This is not an argument for broader federal jurisdiction for its own sake. It is an argument for a rule that can actually be implemented.

If the administration wants less regulatory burden, it must evaluate the entire process. A rule that excludes more waters but requires longer, costlier, and less predictable investigations to identify them is not meaningful deregulation.

It is a regulatory backlog waiting to happen.

Comments must be received by October 9, 2026. Identify Docket No. EPA-HQ-OW-2025-0322 and submit comments through Regulations.gov.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Two New WOTUS Alternatives

Why We Are Objecting

EPA and the Army say the new alternatives could provide a clearer jurisdictional line. In the field, they may create more uncertainty, more documentation, and longer Corps reviews.

EPA and the Department of the Army have added two new alternatives to the ongoing rulemaking over the definition of “waters of the United States,” or WOTUS. If adopted, the first could remove most intermittent streams from federal jurisdiction. The second could divide a single scientifically delineated wetland into jurisdictional and non-jurisdictional portions.

That is a major change in how federal jurisdiction could be evaluated. It is also important to say what this announcement is not: these alternatives are proposals, not current law. They should not be used today as the standard for a jurisdictional determination.

The agencies describe the alternatives as possible bright lines that would implement the Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Sackett v. EPA. The stated goals include predictability, reduced permitting burdens, and a more durable rule. Those are worthwhile goals. Our concern is that neither alternative is supported by a published method capable of producing consistent, defensible decisions in the field.

The problem is not simply that the proposed standards are narrow. The deeper problem is that they ask landowners, consultants, and Corps project managers to prove highly specific hydrologic facts without supplying the measurement rules needed to do so.

Alternative 1: A perennial-only test for relatively permanent waters

The first alternative concerns “relatively permanent waters,” often shortened to RPWs.

Under the agencies’ November 2025 proposal, a water could qualify as relatively permanent if it contained standing or continuously flowing water year-round or at least during the wet season. The new alternative would remove the wet-season option. A water would generally have to be perennial—containing standing or continuously flowing water every day during ordinary conditions.

The proposal provides two possible exceptions. An anomalous event, such as an unusually severe drought or dry spell, would not necessarily cause the water to lose perennial status. The alternative would also allow one regularly occurring interruption lasting no more than 30 consecutive days during the year.

The word “one” matters. A stream that is dry for one continuous 30-day period could still qualify. A stream that is dry for two separate one-day periods could fail, even though it contains water for more days of the year. The agencies also acknowledge that most intermittent streams would not meet the proposed test.

Why Alternative 1 is not scientifically credible

Streamflow duration is real, measurable, and important. But the published science generally treats perennial, intermittent, and ephemeral flow as regional and multi-year hydrologic patterns. Those patterns vary with climate, geology, watershed position, groundwater inputs, water withdrawals, and weather from one year to the next.

The literature does not establish one national, scientifically meaningful breakpoint at one interruption of 30 days. In fact, the supplemental notice acknowledges that there are no precise, scientifically grounded, nationally consistent time limits supporting that number. Calling 30 days approximately one month may make it easy to write into a regulation, but it does not explain why one 30-day dry period is hydrologically acceptable while two much shorter interruptions are not.

The alternative also creates a proof problem. A field visit shows conditions on the day of the visit. It cannot establish that water was present every other day of the year. Seeing a dry channel does not reveal when the dry period began, how long it lasted, whether another interruption occurred elsewhere in the reach, or whether the condition was ordinary or anomalous.

The tools identified by the agencies do not solve that problem:

  • Stream gages provide daily records, but only for a tiny fraction of potentially regulated waters.
  • The Corps’ Antecedent Precipitation Tool and the U.S. Drought Monitor provide climatic context; they do not reconstruct daily flow at a particular stream reach.
  • Streamflow duration assessment methods can help classify a stream from multiple indicators, but they were not designed to count dry days or distinguish one interruption from two.
  • Aerial imagery, national hydrography data, and remote-sensing products are useful screening tools, but their resolution, revisit frequency, canopy limitations, and missing observations prevent them from proving uninterrupted daily flow at parcel scale.
  • Sensors can collect better site-specific records, but the proposal does not say how many are needed, where they must be installed, what counts as detectable water, or how missing data should be handled.

Several essential terms are also unresolved. What is the relevant stream reach? Does water in an isolated pool count as standing water for the whole reach? Which 12-month period controls? When does a normal dry spell become anomalous? How should flow affected by a release, withdrawal, beaver dam, or storm pulse be treated?

Until those questions have objective answers, Alternative 1 is not a bright line. It is a collection of case-by-case judgments hidden behind a precise-looking number.

Alternative 2: Drawing a federal line inside a wetland

The second alternative would apply an equally strict version of the “continuous surface connection” test to wetlands.

Under this approach, a wetland may need perennial surface water that is continuously connected to a jurisdictional water. The connection would need to make it difficult to determine where the jurisdictional water ends and the wetland begins. The same anomalous-event and single 30-day interruption concepts would apply.

The most consequential part is the proposed treatment of the wetland itself. The agencies suggest that only the portion of a wetland containing the required perennial surface-water connection would be jurisdictional. Federal jurisdiction could end where the perennial surface water “runs out,” even though the scientifically delineated wetland continues farther landward.

That would create two different boundaries on the same site:

  1. The wetland boundary established under the Corps Wetlands Delineation Manual and the applicable regional supplement.
  2. A new internal federal jurisdictional boundary based on the extent and duration of surface water.

The land beyond the second line would still be wetland. It could remain regulated under state, Tribal, or local law. But under the proposed federal alternative, it might no longer be WOTUS.

Why Alternative 2 cannot be implemented reliably

No published EPA or Corps manual provides a validated procedure for drawing this internal line. The Corps’ established wetland-delineation methods distinguish wetland from non-wetland using vegetation, soils, and hydrology. They do not divide one continuous wetland into federal and nonfederal portions based on the day-by-day persistence of surface water.

Academic studies can measure when water moves between wetlands and streams. Researchers have used sensors, repeated site visits, detailed elevation surveys, aerial imagery, radar, and satellite data. Those studies are valuable, but they generally produce observations at instrument locations, estimates of inundation extent, or probabilities of connection. They do not produce a stable, survey-ready federal boundary that has been validated across different wetland types and regions.

Wetlands are especially difficult places to draw such a line. Surface water responds to small changes in elevation and may occupy channels, pools, swales, hollows, and depressions. It can disappear at one point while remaining connected by another pathway. The apparent edge can move substantially between seasons and years. Forest canopy may hide shallow water from optical imagery, while many satellite products are too coarse to resolve project-scale conditions.

A one-time “naked eye” observation therefore cannot establish that water was present every day under ordinary conditions. Nor can it determine where that condition ended throughout an irregular wetland. More monitoring might improve the evidence, but the proposal supplies no national requirements for monitoring duration, sensor spacing, water-depth thresholds, survey accuracy, climatic normalization, uncertainty, or conflicting data.

Our objection is not that wetland-stream connectivity cannot be studied. It can. Our objection is that existing research has not been converted into an accuracy-tested, reproducible regulatory procedure for the legal decision the agencies propose.

A rule intended to reduce burden could increase it

Both alternatives could greatly increase the work required to obtain an Approved Jurisdictional Determination.

Alternative 1 would require the Corps to decide whether a stream contained water every day, whether each gap was ordinary or anomalous, whether one or multiple interruptions occurred, and where the relevant perennial reach begins and ends.

Alternative 2 would require a second, case-specific investigation after the ordinary wetland delineation is complete. Each wetland on a property could need its own hydrologic record, internal boundary analysis, supporting imagery, climatic evaluation, and surveyed line. A property with several wetlands could therefore produce several separate mini-investigations.

Without a national method, Corps districts and individual project managers may reasonably reach different conclusions from similar evidence. Applicants are likely to submit larger documentation packages and request more Approved JDs because the legal consequences are substantial. The predictable results are more requests for information, repeat field visits, disputes, appeals, and longer processing times.

That outcome would run directly against the Army’s “Building Infrastructure, Not Paperwork” initiative and the agencies’ stated objective of reducing regulatory uncertainty. Excluding waters from jurisdiction may reduce some permitting obligations, but it does not eliminate the cost of determining whether federal jurisdiction exists in the first place.

What the law does, and does not, require

The Supreme Court held in Sackett that covered wetlands must have a continuous surface connection with a relatively permanent covered water, making it difficult to determine where the water ends and the wetland begins. But the Court did not require a perennial-only stream definition, select a one-period 30-day allowance, or instruct the agencies to draw a separate federal boundary through the interior of a wetland.

Those are policy and technical choices made by the agencies. They therefore need support in the administrative record. A durable rule should show a rational connection between the evidence and the standard, tell the regulated public how the standard will be measured, and give Corps personnel enough guidance to apply it consistently. A number in a regulation is not meaningful notice if no one can reliably determine the facts to which the number applies.

The Swamp School is preparing separate public comments asking EPA and the Army to withdraw both alternatives. At a minimum, the agencies should first disclose any technical review conducted by Corps district personnel or the Engineer Research and Development Center, complete a multi-district pilot study, measure inter-observer reproducibility, and quantify the effects on AJD workloads and processing times. Any resulting methodology should then be published for public comment before the substantive jurisdictional standard is finalized.

What happens next

As of September 8, 2026, the supplemental proposal is on public inspection and is scheduled for publication in the Federal Register on September 9. The 30-day comment period is expected to close on October 9, 2026. Before filing, commenters should confirm the final deadline on the published notice.

The official docket is EPA-HQ-OW-2025-0322. The EPA WOTUS page, Federal Register public-inspection page, and Regulations.gov docket provide the current documents and filing information.

The agencies are right to seek a WOTUS definition that is understandable, legally durable, and practical to administer. But these two alternatives do not yet meet that standard. They replace familiar jurisdictional questions with new ones that are more data-intensive, less reproducible, and unsupported by an established field method.

That is not regulatory certainty. It is uncertainty with a stopwatch and a new line on the map.

This article is for educational purposes and is not legal advice.

#WOTUS #WetlandDelineation #CleanWaterAct #PublicComment #Wetlands #EnvironmentalProfessionals #WetlandWednesday #TheSwampSchool

Posted on — Leave a comment

EPA’s WOTUS Rule Hits Another Round of Review

Cattail marsh in the Bosque del Apache National Wildlife Refuge in New Mexico. Photograph courtesy of Sue Major Holmes, the Associated Press, and E&E News by Politico.

Just when it looked like the latest “Waters of the United States” rulemaking was moving toward a final rule, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) appears to be taking another step back. According to reporting by Miranda Willson of GREENWIRE and E&E News by POLITICO, the EPA has sent a supplemental proposed rule to the White House for review. The article reports that the EPA sent the proposed supplement to its WOTUS definition for review on Tuesday, signaling that the administration is amending some part of the original proposal released in November 2025. ([Willson and E&E News by POLITICO][1])

That is significant. The November 2025 proposal was presented as an effort to provide a clearer, more durable definition of WOTUS following the Supreme Court’s decision in Sackett v. EPA. The EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) said the proposed rule was intended to clarify federal jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act, improve predictability, and respect the role of states and Tribes in managing local water resources. The comment period for that proposal closed on January 5, 2026. Now, only months later, the agencies appear to be preparing a supplement.

Why This Matters

A supplemental proposal does not necessarily mean the EPA is abandoning its original approach. It may mean the agency is trying to clarify, revise, or strengthen part of the rule before it becomes final. But for landowners, developers, consultants, engineers, and regulators, the practical message is simple: the WOTUS uncertainty is not over.

The Clean Water Act definition of WOTUS determines which wetlands, streams, ditches, ponds, and other aquatic features may require federal permits. That definition affects wetland delineations, jurisdictional determinations, project planning, mitigation requirements, enforcement risk, and real estate development decisions. When the rule changes, the risk profile changes; when the rule is delayed, uncertainty remains.

The Likely Pressure Points

The biggest unresolved issue appears to be how the agencies will define and apply terms from the Sackett decision, especially “relatively permanent” waters and wetlands with a “continuous surface connection.” The November 2025 proposal attempted to narrow and clarify federal jurisdiction by focusing on waters that are relatively permanent and wetlands that are directly connected to those waters. The EPA’s own materials state that the proposal would define several key terms, including “relatively permanent,” “continuous surface connection,” “tributary,” “ditch,” “prior converted cropland,” and “waste treatment system.”

Those terms sound simple, but they are difficult to apply in the field. For example, what does “relatively permanent” mean for a stream that flows during the wet season but dries out later in the year? How should the Army Corps evaluate a wetland that has surface water connection during part of the year, but not at the time of inspection? What evidence should be used to decide whether a surface connection exists? How should regional differences in rainfall, evapotranspiration, and hydrology be handled?

These are not minor technical questions. They are the questions that determine whether a feature is federally jurisdictional.

The Wet Season Problem

One of the most important issues to watch is the “wet season” concept. The November 2025 proposal discussed waters that flow year-round or at least during the wet season. That approach creates an immediate practical problem: the wet season is not the same everywhere, and it does not always line up neatly with the day a field inspection occurs.

In some parts of the country, the wet season may be obvious. In other regions, especially arid or highly seasonal areas, it may be more complicated. Even in the eastern United States, a stream or wetland may respond to rainfall, groundwater, soil saturation, or evapotranspiration on a delayed schedule. That means the agencies may need to be more precise about how field staff, consultants, and regulators should document wet-season flow or surface connection. If they do not, the final rule could invite the same kind of inconsistent application and litigation that has followed prior WOTUS rules.

This May Be About Legal Durability

The EPA has repeatedly stated that the goal is a durable WOTUS rule that follows the Supreme Court’s direction in Sackett. That is easier said than done. The agencies must write a rule narrow enough to satisfy the Supreme Court’s limits on federal authority, but clear enough for field implementation. They also need to explain their reasoning well enough to survive the next round of litigation.

That may be why a supplemental proposal is now in play. The supplement could provide additional explanation, revise a definition, respond to comments, or reopen a specific issue for public input. Until the text is released, we do not know exactly what the EPA is changing. But the fact that the rule has gone back to the White House for review suggests the agencies are still working through important details.

What This Means for Current Projects

For now, project teams should be careful about assuming that the November 2025 proposal represents the final rule. It does not. Until a final rule is published and effective, current jurisdictional decisions still need to be made under the applicable existing regulatory framework and current agency guidance. For projects involving wetlands, streams, ditches, or uncertain aquatic features, the safest approach is to document field conditions carefully and avoid relying on broad assumptions about what the final WOTUS rule will say. That is especially true for projects involving:

  • Seasonal streams
  • Wetlands near ditches or tributaries
  • Wetlands with intermittent surface connections
  • Prior converted cropland
  • Roadside or agricultural ditches
  • Older wetland delineations or jurisdictional determinations
  • Sites where the presence or absence of surface water connection is disputed

The proposed rule may eventually narrow federal jurisdiction, but the details will matter. A small change in the definition of “relatively permanent” or “continuous surface connection” could make a significant difference on the ground.

The Practical Takeaway

The EPA may still be heading toward a narrower post-Sackett WOTUS rule, but the path to finalizing that rule appears less settled than officials suggested when the November 2025 proposal was released. For consultants and developers, this is a reminder that WOTUS is still a moving target. The key is not just watching the headlines. The key is watching the technical language. The next version of the proposal may tell us how the EPA and the Army Corps intend to handle the hard field questions: wet-season flow, surface connections, tributaries, ditches, and the evidence needed to support a jurisdictional determination.

Until then, the best advice is simple: document the site conditions, preserve the record, and be cautious about making final jurisdictional assumptions based on a rule that is still under revision.

[1] Willson, Miranda. EPA heads back to the drafting board on WOTUS rule. GREENWIRE and E&E News by POLITICO. https://www.eenews.net/articles/trump-admin-prepares-tweaks-to-wotus-rule/. Accessed on July 2, 2026.

#WOTUS #EPA #USACE #CleanWaterAct #Wetlands #WetlandDelineation #EnvironmentalConsulting #EnvironmentalScience #RegulatoryUpdate #WaterResources #WetlandWednesday #TheSwampSchool

Posted on — Leave a comment

Why the Regulatory Briefing Matters More Than Ever

For professionals who work in wetlands, streams, permitting, land development, and environmental compliance, regulatory change is not background noise. It shapes how projects are planned, how risks are evaluated, and how decisions are made in the field.

That is why the Regulatory Briefing exists.

The Regulatory Briefing is designed for people who need more than headlines. It is a practical, professional resource that explains what is changing in the regulatory world, why it matters, and how those changes may affect real projects. Instead of leaving readers to sort through public notices, guidance documents, district announcements, court decisions, and agency memos on their own, the briefing pulls those developments together and puts them into context.

What makes the Regulatory Briefing valuable is not simply that it reports developments. It explains the connections between them.

That matters because regulatory work rarely changes in one clean, isolated step. A new report standard may alter how field data is collected. A shift in agency interpretation may change how those facts are viewed later in the permitting process. A revised permit condition may affect whether a project stays on a streamlined track or gets pushed into a more complicated review.

A good example is the Corps’ recent rollout of new Aquatic Resource Delineation Report resources. In August 2025, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers announced recommended minimum standards, data collection quality standards, and a template intended to improve the consistency and completeness of ARDRs and make reviews more efficient.

At first glance, that may sound like a narrow technical update. It is anything but narrow.

An ARDR is not supposed to make the final legal call on whether a feature is jurisdictional. Its primary role is to document the presence, extent, and characteristics of aquatic resources. But the Corps’ recommended standards make clear that delineation reports can include information highly relevant to later jurisdictional analysis, including flow regime, physical indicators, and site conditions that help inform how aquatic features relate to downstream waters.

That is where the connection to WOTUS becomes so important.

Since Sackett, the question of what qualifies as a water of the United States has become even more dependent on carefully documented, site-specific facts. EPA’s current WOTUS implementation materials note that the agencies announced a proposed rule in November 2025 intended to clarify the definition and fully implement the Supreme Court’s decision. In practical terms, that keeps attention focused on the factual record supporting jurisdictional decisions.

In other words, ARDRs and WOTUS are deeply interconnected. The delineation report may not be the jurisdictional determination itself, but it often supplies the foundation for later discussions about connectivity, aquatic resource classification, and regulatory significance. If that record is incomplete, unclear, or out of step with current expectations, the effects can show up later in the process through added questions, review delays, or disputes over how a site should be treated.

This is exactly the kind of connection the Regulatory Briefing is built to cover. It does not just say that a new ARDR template was released. It explains why that matters in a post-Sackett world and why technical documentation choices may now carry greater downstream consequences than many practitioners realize.

The same is true for developments involving Nationwide Permits. On January 8, 2026, the Corps published its final action reissuing 56 existing nationwide permits and one new permit, with the 2026 NWPs taking effect on March 15, 2026. But that national action is only part of the story. Corps divisions and districts may impose regional conditions, and those conditions can materially affect how the permits function in practice.

That is the type of issue many busy professionals miss until it is already affecting a project. A permit that appears straightforward at the national level may become more restrictive once regional conditions are applied. Notification thresholds, documentation requirements, and impact limitations can all shift depending on location. The difference between a manageable permitting pathway and a difficult one may come down to details that never make mainstream news.

The Regulatory Briefing helps readers catch those developments early and understand their practical consequences.

Just as important, it helps reduce the time burden of staying informed. Most environmental professionals do not have hours each week to monitor agency websites, compare new notices to prior guidance, and figure out what changes are actually meaningful. The briefing does that work for them, delivering timely analysis in a format that is clear, useful, and grounded in the realities of consulting and permitting practice.

That is also why the Regulatory Briefing is not just for attorneys or policy specialists. It is for wetland scientists, project managers, consultants, engineers, developers, and anyone whose work depends on understanding where regulatory expectations are heading next.

The value of subscribing is simple. It helps you stay ahead of developments that can affect scope, schedule, cost, and strategy. It helps you see how technical delineation expectations connect to bigger jurisdictional questions. And it helps you recognize when a seemingly small policy change may actually signal a much larger shift in how agencies are approaching aquatic resources and permitting.

In a field where the details matter and the consequences of missing a change can be expensive, staying current is not optional.

The Regulatory Briefing exists to make that easier and more useful.

Subscribe to the Regulatory Briefing today and stay informed on the regulatory changes that matter most. From ARDR expectations to WOTUS interpretations to new permit conditions, you will get clear, practical insight to help you plan smarter, respond faster, and avoid costly surprises.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Where Things Stand: EPA & Army Corps “Updated Definition of WOTUS” Rulemaking (February 2026)

As of February 25, 2026, there is no final rule published in the Federal Register for the EPA and Army Corps rulemaking commonly described as the “Updated Definition of ‘Waters of the United States’” (WOTUS).

That is the clean answer.

Despite significant anticipation — and significant public engagement — the agencies remain in a post-comment, pre-finalization phase.

In other words: the proposal has closed for comment, but there is no documentary evidence of a final rule.

What Is Confirmed

On November 20, 2025, EPA and the Army Corps published a proposed rule titled:

Updated Definition of “Waters of the United States”

The proposal includes:

  • FR Doc: 2025-20402
  • RIN: 2040-AG44
  • Docket: EPA-HQ-OW-2025-0322
  • Comment deadline: January 5, 2026

The public response was substantial. The Regulations.gov docket reflects:

  • 219,729 comments received
  • 14,829 comments posted

That is not a modest rulemaking record. That is a regulatory endurance event.

The comment period officially closed on January 5, 2026. As of February 25, 2026:

  • There is no final rule published.
  • There is no final rule posted to Federal Register Public Inspection.
  • There is no OIRA review pending for a Final Rule stage under RIN 2040-AG44.
  • There is no Unified Agenda update moving the rule beyond Proposed Rule stage.

OIRA concluded review of the Proposed Rule stage on November 7, 2025. Since then, no public signals indicate the rule has entered final review.

In plain terms: the most defensible public-facing status is post-comment development inside EPA/Army.

What That Means

In a typical significant rulemaking, the next “status flip” becomes visible through one of the public tripwires — a Public Inspection posting, a Final Rule entry in the Federal Register, an OIRA Final Rule stage submission, or a final package posted in the docket.

None of those downstream signals are present as of February 25, 2026.

That strongly suggests the agencies are doing the quiet work that happens after comments close:

  • Reviewing the administrative record
  • Drafting and clearing responses to comments
  • Revising regulatory text
  • Preparing economic and technical analyses
  • Running internal and interagency clearance steps

In other words: a lot can be happening — but nothing that is verifiable has surfaced publicly yet.

The Broader Context: Fragmented Implementation

Overlaying this rulemaking is the ongoing litigation environment affecting the January 2023 rule and the September 2023 conforming amendments. EPA’s own litigation update explains that implementation differs across states due to court orders.

In practical terms, some states are operating under the January 2023 rule (as amended), while others are operating under the pre-2015 regulatory regime (as informed by Sackett).

This fragmented posture increases both the urgency and complexity of finalizing — and later implementing — any new WOTUS definition. It also increases implementation risk.

What to Watch Next

If you’re tracking this rule closely, the most reliable public signals usually appear in this order:

  1. Federal Register Public Inspection (often the earliest public signal of a final posting)
  2. Federal Register Final Rule entry matching the title and/or RIN 2040-AG44 (publication date and effective date)
  3. OIRA/Reginfo “Pending Review” listing for a Final Rule stage submission
  4. Regulations.gov docket EPA-HQ-OW-2025-0322 updates (final package, response-to-comments, final analyses)
  5. EPA and USACE hub pages for formal announcements and fact sheets once published

Until one of those appears, there is no final rule — and no effective date.

The Real Takeaway for Environmental Managers

The absence of a final rule does not mean stability. It means continued uncertainty layered on top of an already fragmented implementation landscape.

Surface water connection interpretation remains central. Documentation standards remain critical. And jurisdictional consistency remains variable across states — even before a new final action is released.

Whatever is ultimately published will still operate within the constraints of Sackett. The legal boundary is set. The policy mechanics are still moving.

Stay Ahead of the Shift

This is exactly why we created the Regulatory Intelligence Briefing. Each month, we analyze active rulemakings, litigation posture, Federal Register signals, OIRA movements, and the field-level implications for documentation and defensibility.

Not just what changed — but what it means for exposure and implementation decisions.

If you are responsible for regulatory interpretation, permitting risk, or jurisdictional strategy, staying reactive is not a strategy. Staying informed — with context — is.

Stay current.
Stay defensible.
Stay ahead.