Posted on — Leave a comment

Surface Water Connections in 2026: Where the Real Jurisdictional Risk Is

Surface Water Connections in 2026: Where the Real Jurisdictional Risk Is

Surface Water Connections in 2026: Where the Real Jurisdictional Risk Is

An overview for consultants and project teams navigating today’s tighter jurisdictional standards.

Regulatory Briefing • March Field Season Readiness

Cut through the noise. Focus on what delays projects.

If you’re working in wetlands, streams, mitigation, or environmental permitting, you already feel it: the jurisdictional debate isn’t loud anymore. It’s technical.

In 2026, most project delays aren’t coming from sweeping policy changes. They’re coming from a narrower, higher-stakes question:

Does a wetland have a continuous surface water connection to a relatively permanent water?

This isn’t politics. It’s field execution and documentation discipline. And that’s where the real risk sits.

The question that’s now driving everything

The analysis has tightened around physical hydrologic connectivity. The old comfort of broad, functional reasoning has been replaced by something far more demanding: observable, mappable, defensible surface continuity.

That means conclusions increasingly rise or fall on what you can document in the field and in the report—not what you can infer.

Where the risk is actually concentrated

The highest-risk areas are not obvious perennial stream systems. And they’re not clearly isolated upland depressions either. The real exposure sits in transitional features like:

  • Roadside ditches and ditch-modified landscapes
  • Shallow swales and broad, low-gradient connectors
  • Floodplain depressions and backwater areas
  • Culvert crossings, berms, and roadway barriers
  • Seasonal connectors that appear “disconnected” during dry months
  • Modified drainage systems in agricultural and suburban settings

These are the places where flow is seasonal, infrastructure complicates interpretation, and elevation differences matter more than assumptions.

The two overcorrections we’re seeing

Across the country, firms are responding in two opposite—and equally risky—ways:

1) Over-asserting connectivity.
Carrying forward older adjacency logic and assuming continuity where evidence is thin. If the connection can’t be shown visually and supported spatially, defensibility suffers.

2) Over-disclaiming jurisdiction.
Under-calling features based on dry-season observations alone. That can create exposure in review, enforcement, and in states with independent wetland programs.

In both cases, the problem isn’t ideology. It’s documentation: what was observed, how it was recorded, and how clearly it was explained.

Why this matters financially

Surface water connection determinations now directly affect:

  • Mitigation requirements and bank credit demand
  • Project redesign costs and construction sequencing
  • Schedule predictability and permitting timelines
  • Property valuation and client risk tolerance
  • Long-term liability exposure

A misclassified connection can mean months of delay, significant mitigation expense, or future problems when projects are evaluated under a different lens—sometimes years later.

The trend we’re watching in 2026

One trend is clear: reviewers are increasingly verifying conclusions using geospatial and historic data. The era of “narrative-only” justification is fading.

Expect more reliance on: LiDAR, historic aerials, elevation modeling, and seasonal imagery comparisons.

In this environment, reports that don’t anticipate verification may not age well. Projects outlive field visits.

Where we go deeper: the premium analysis

Inside the Regulatory Briefing Subscription, we’re releasing a full premium white paper:

“Surface Water Connections in 2026: Where Jurisdictional Risk Actually Sits.”

It breaks down what’s driving real project risk, including:

  • How “continuous” is being interpreted in practice
  • Where ditch-based connections become vulnerable
  • How culverts and artificial barriers should be evaluated and documented
  • Why intermittent vs. ephemeral classification now carries amplified consequences
  • What documentation protocols reduce exposure going into field season
  • How to write reports that hold up in both permitting and enforcement contexts

This is not commentary. It is applied regulatory analysis built for professionals managing real projects.

The Regulatory Briefing is designed for signal, not noise

The regulatory environment is not quiet. But most of the noise is not useful. The purpose of the Regulatory Briefing is simple:

  • No political commentary
  • No outrage cycles
  • No speculation disguised as certainty
  • Just clear analysis of what changes mean for real work in the field

Read more about the subscription

If you’re responsible for wetland delineations, jurisdictional determinations, mitigation planning, or environmental compliance strategy, surface water connection analysis is not optional reading in 2026.

Learn about the Regulatory Briefing Subscription

Next month’s release is especially important going into field season—because the risk isn’t where most people are looking. It’s in the transitional spaces.

The Swamp School Regulatory Briefing
Practical, apolitical analysis for professionals working at the intersection of wetlands science and regulation.

Posted on — 1 Comment

EPA’s Proposed Section 401 Rule: Environmental Protection, Scientific Rigor, and Practical Implications

On January 15, 2026, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) proposed revisions to the Clean Water Act (CWA) Section 401 water quality certification regulations. The docket Number is: EPA-HQ-OW-2025-2929. While the proposal has sparked debate across environmental advocacy, regulatory, and consulting communities, it is best understood not as a simple expansion or rollback of environmental protection, but as a structural realignment of how water quality science is applied within federal permitting.

Viewed through an environmental and environmental scientist lens, the proposal reflects both clear scientific advantages and legitimate ecological concerns, with important implications for how environmental professionals engage in water resource protection going forward.

Re-centering Section 401 on Water Quality Science

At its core, Section 401 asks a focused scientific question:

Will a discharge into waters of the United States comply with applicable water quality standards?

EPA’s proposed rule reinforces this framing by limiting certification review to point source discharges associated with federally licensed or permitted activities. This approach aligns Section 401 with the Clean Water Act’s post-1972 structure, which emphasizes effluent limits, water quality criteria, and compliance monitoring as the primary tools for protecting aquatic resources.

From an environmental scientist’s perspective, this clarity strengthens the technical foundation of Section 401 decisions by:

  • Reinforcing measurable cause-and-effect relationships
  • Anchoring analysis in numeric and narrative water quality standards
  • Improving transparency and reproducibility in certification determinations

Supporters of the rule view this as restoring Section 401 to a role that science is well equipped to support.

Environmental Concerns Rooted in Ecosystem Complexity

Environmental nonprofits and applied scientists have raised concerns that are also grounded in ecological science. Aquatic systems respond not only to discrete discharges, but to cumulative, indirect, and interacting stressors, such as hydrologic alteration, habitat fragmentation, and incremental wetland loss.

From this perspective, narrowing Section 401 review raises questions about:

  • Whether cumulative impacts can still be adequately addressed
  • How changes to flow, connectivity, and habitat quality will be evaluated
  • Whether other Clean Water Act programs are sufficient to capture ecosystem-scale effects

These concerns do not reject discharge-based science. Rather, they reflect the reality that not all ecologically significant impacts are easily attributable to a single discharge point, even when those impacts are measurable and biologically meaningful.

Precision Versus Breadth: A Scientific Tradeoff

The tension underlying EPA’s proposal is not science versus protection, but precision versus breadth.

From a pro-rule scientific standpoint:

  • Section 401 should focus on discharges because that is what the statute regulates
  • Expanding certification to entire project “activities” blurs scientific causation
  • Broader ecosystem concerns are more appropriately addressed through other Clean Water Act tools, such as water quality standards (Section 303), wetland permitting (Section 404), and nonpoint source programs

Critics counter that:

  • Those complementary programs are unevenly implemented
  • Narrowing Section 401 increases pressure on already limited regulatory pathways
  • Fragmenting environmental review risks leaving some impacts insufficiently addressed

Scientifically, both perspectives acknowledge the same constraint: no single Clean Water Act program can address all dimensions of ecosystem health.

Timelines, Data, and Decision Quality

EPA’s proposal reinforces the statutory one-year deadline for certification decisions and restricts withdrawal-and-resubmittal practices that have historically prolonged reviews.

From an environmental science perspective, this change:

  • Encourages earlier and more targeted data collection
  • Reduces procedural delay that does not necessarily improve scientific outcomes
  • Places greater emphasis on baseline data quality at the outset

Environmental advocates note that complex projects and data-limited watersheds may require more time to fully understand impacts, especially under climate-driven hydrologic variability. Scientifically, this highlights the growing importance of long-term monitoring and proactive data development, independent of permitting timelines.

What This Means for Environmental Consultants

The proposed rule also reshapes how environmental consultants and environmental scientists contribute to permitting and water quality protection.

Clearer Scope, More Focused Science

By limiting Section 401 review to point source discharges, consultants gain clearer boundaries for analysis. This supports more precise study design focused on:

  • Discharge characterization
  • Receiving water conditions
  • Applicable standards and criteria
  • Defensible cause-and-effect relationships

More Front-Loaded Technical Work

Standardized certification requirements and firm timelines are likely to shift consulting effort earlier in the project lifecycle. Consultants may be engaged sooner to ensure that:

  • Baseline data are adequate before submittal
  • Discharge-related impacts are fully evaluated upfront
  • Certification requests are technically complete

From a scientific standpoint, this front-loading improves decision quality by providing regulators with stronger data earlier in the process.

Increased Emphasis on Defensible Analyses

A discharge-focused framework elevates the importance of:

  • Quantifiable methods
  • Reproducible results
  • Clear linkage to water quality standards

This favors technically rigorous analyses—such as modeling, targeted monitoring, and biologically relevant indicators—over broader, less precise narratives.

Redistribution of Broader Environmental Work

Broader ecosystem concerns emphasized by environmental nonprofits do not disappear under the proposed rule. Instead, they are more likely to shift to:

  • Section 404 permitting and mitigation
  • Watershed-scale assessments
  • Water quality standards development and impairment analysis
  • Nonpoint source and cumulative impact studies

For consultants, this may result in more integrated, multi-program project roles, rather than reduced demand.

Reduced Procedural Rework

Limiting withdrawal-and-resubmittal practices may reduce repeated sampling and analysis driven solely by administrative delay, shifting consultant effort toward getting the science right the first time.

An Integrated Environmental Takeaway

From an environmental and environmental scientist perspective, EPA’s proposed Section 401 rule represents a re-definition of responsibility rather than a reduction in protection.

The proposal:

  • Strengthens scientific defensibility by focusing on discharge-based impacts
  • Clarifies regulatory expectations for data and analysis
  • Limits Section 401’s scope, increasing reliance on other Clean Water Act tools for ecosystem-scale protection

The critical question moving forward is not whether Section 401 should address every environmental concern, but whether the entire Clean Water Act framework is functioning as an integrated system capable of protecting the chemical, physical, and biological integrity of aquatic resources.

Public comments on the proposal are due February 17, 2026, offering environmental scientists, nonprofits, consultants, and regulators an opportunity to shape how clarity, scientific rigor, and environmental protection advance together.

Posted on — 4 Comments

NEPA Changed in 2026. Here Is What That Means for Wetlands

In January 2026, one of the most significant procedural changes to federal environmental review in decades quietly became final. The Council on Environmental Quality, commonly known as CEQ, removed all of its National Environmental Policy Act implementing regulations from the Code of Federal Regulations.

For wetlands professionals, this change does not eliminate environmental review, nor does it remove wetlands from federal decision making. What it does change is who controls how wetlands are analyzed under NEPA and how consistent that analysis will be across agencies.

Understanding this shift is now essential for anyone working in wetland delineation, permitting, mitigation, or environmental compliance.

A Quick Look Back at CEQ’s Role

NEPA was enacted in 1969 as a procedural law. It requires federal agencies to consider environmental impacts before making decisions, but it does not dictate exact methods for doing so.

That gap was filled in 1978, when CEQ finalized government wide NEPA regulations under authority granted by Executive Order 11991. For nearly fifty years, those regulations provided a shared structure for NEPA reviews across all federal agencies.

Wetlands were consistently addressed under this framework as part of the affected environment. Agencies followed similar expectations for impact analysis, alternatives evaluation, and mitigation discussions, even when project types differed.

Why the CEQ Regulations Were Removed

In January 2025, Executive Order 14154 rescinded Executive Order 11991. With that action, CEQ determined that it no longer had authority to issue binding regulations governing how other federal agencies implement NEPA.

CEQ issued an interim final rule in February 2025 removing its NEPA regulations and invited public comment. After reviewing more than 100,000 comments, CEQ finalized the rule without changes. As of January 8, 2026, the CEQ NEPA regulations are officially gone.

What Did Not Change

This is where many misconceptions arise.

NEPA is still federal law. Agencies must still analyze environmental impacts, consider alternatives, and document their decision making. Environmental Assessments and Environmental Impact Statements still exist.

Wetlands are still subject to NEPA review when affected by federal actions. This includes projects involving Clean Water Act Section 404 permits, federal transportation funding, energy development, flood control, and federal land management.

The rule also did not eliminate agency specific NEPA procedures. Every federal agency has its own NEPA procedures, many of which closely resemble the former CEQ regulations. Those procedures remain in effect unless revised.

What Actually Changed for Wetlands

The key change is structural rather than substantive.

There is no longer a single, government wide set of NEPA rules issued by CEQ. NEPA implementation now depends on three things:

  • The statutory text of NEPA as amended in 2023
  • Each agency’s NEPA procedures
  • CEQ guidance, which is advisory rather than binding

For wetlands professionals, this means agency specific practice now matters more than ever.

Why Agency Procedures Matter More Now

Under the former CEQ framework, wetlands analysis looked broadly similar across agencies. With CEQ regulations removed, that uniformity may erode over time.

For example:

  • U.S. Army Corps of Engineers NEPA procedures will drive how wetlands are analyzed for Section 404 permits
  • Federal Highway Administration procedures will control wetland analysis for transportation projects
  • Bureau of Land Management or Department of Energy procedures will guide wetlands analysis on federal lands or energy projects

All of these approaches can satisfy NEPA, but they may differ in emphasis. Some agencies focus heavily on acreage and mitigation ratios. Others emphasize wetland functions, avoidance measures, or land use context.

This does not mean wetlands are less important. It means the framework for discussing wetlands is no longer centralized.

Increased Importance of Wetland Documentation

With courts now relying more heavily on agency specific procedures, the quality of wetlands documentation becomes even more critical.

Wetland delineations, jurisdictional determinations, impact calculations, and mitigation plans must be clearly aligned with the lead agency’s NEPA process. Assumptions based on old CEQ templates may no longer be sufficient.

This rule does not change Waters of the United States definitions or Clean Water Act jurisdiction. However, NEPA documents often include both jurisdictional and non jurisdictional wetlands. How those wetlands are described and analyzed may now vary more by agency.

For wetland consultants, this increases the importance of early coordination with the lead federal agency and careful attention to agency guidance.

What This Means in Practice

In the short term, most wetland projects will continue largely unchanged. Agencies are still using existing procedures, and many procedures reflect decades of CEQ based practice.

Over time, however, greater variation among agencies is likely. Wetlands professionals should expect:

  • More agency specific expectations
  • Less reliance on one size fits all NEPA templates
  • Greater scrutiny of how wetland impacts support agency decision making

The Swamp School Takeaway

The removal of CEQ’s NEPA regulations does not reduce the importance of wetlands. Instead, it shifts responsibility for how wetlands are analyzed directly to individual federal agencies.

For wetland scientists and practitioners, success under NEPA now depends on understanding agency specific procedures, aligning wetland studies with those procedures, and clearly documenting how wetlands were evaluated.

At The Swamp School, this reinforces the need for strong technical foundations, regulatory awareness, and practical application. NEPA did not disappear. It evolved. Wetlands professionals who adapt will continue to play a critical role in federal environmental decision making.

Posted on — Leave a comment

The 2026 Nationwide Permits and Florida’s Status Under Nationwide Permit 24

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers finalized the 2026 Nationwide Permits (NWPs) on January 8, 2026. These permits replace the 2021 Nationwide Permits and will govern a large portion of Clean Water Act Section 404 authorizations nationwide for the next five years. While the overall structure of the nationwide permit program remains largely unchanged, the final rule includes clarifications and targeted revisions that affect how permits are applied, how Clean Water Act Section 401 is implemented, and how state and federal permitting authority is understood.

One of the most discussed changes in the final rule is the removal of Florida from Nationwide Permit 24, which applies in states that have assumed administration of the Section 404 program. Understanding this change requires looking at both how nationwide permits function and how Florida’s assumed program has evolved.

Overview of the Nationwide Permit Program

Nationwide permits are issued by the Corps under Section 404(e) of the Clean Water Act and, where applicable, Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act. They authorize categories of activities that the Corps has determined will result in no more than minimal individual and cumulative adverse environmental effects.

Nationwide permits are designed to streamline permitting for common activities such as utility crossings, bank stabilization, minor road crossings, and maintenance work. They operate subject to:

  • Nationwide permit specific terms and limits
  • Nationwide General Conditions
  • Regional conditions imposed by Corps divisions
  • Clean Water Act Section 401 water quality certification
  • Pre construction notification requirements where applicable

The 2026 Nationwide Permits become effective March 15, 2026 and are scheduled to expire on March 14, 2031.

Key Themes in the 2026 Nationwide Permits

The 2026 NWPs do not represent a major expansion or contraction of the program. Instead, the final rule emphasizes clarity and consistency. Notable themes include:

  • Clarification of how Section 401 water quality certification applies to nationwide permits
  • Greater emphasis on compliance with general conditions
  • Reinforcement of district engineer discretion through regional conditions
  • Clarification of how multiple nationwide permits may be used for a single project

These changes reflect a broader trend toward strengthening the administrative record and reducing ambiguity in permit implementation.


What Nationwide Permit 24 Is

Nationwide Permit 24 is different from most nationwide permits because it applies only in states that have assumed administration of the Clean Water Act Section 404 program under Section 404(g).

When a state assumes the Section 404 program, it becomes the primary permitting authority for most discharges of dredged or fill material into waters of the United States. Federal law, however, does not allow states to assume jurisdiction over all waters. The Corps retains authority over traditionally navigable waters, waters subject to Section 10, and certain adjacent waters.

Nationwide Permit 24 exists to authorize activities in those retained federal waters within assumed states. Its use depends on a clear and legally stable division of permitting authority between the state and the Corps.

Florida’s Section 404 Program Background

Florida began administering a state Section 404 program in December 2020 following approval by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. The assumption did not transfer all federal permitting authority to the state. As a result, Florida operated under a divided regulatory framework in which both the state and the Corps issued permits depending on the type and location of waters affected.

Following EPA’s approval, litigation challenged whether the approval complied with the Endangered Species Act, particularly with respect to program level consultation. Federal courts vacated portions of the approval, creating uncertainty regarding the legal foundation of the assumed program.

Removal of Florida From Nationwide Permit 24

In the 2025 proposed Nationwide Permits, Florida continued to be listed as an assumed state under Nationwide Permit 24. The proposal did not suggest removing Florida or solicit comment on that issue.

In the 2026 final rule, the Corps removed Florida from Nationwide Permit 24. The Corps described this change as administrative and stated that it does not affect the number of activities authorized by nationwide permits. The removal aligns the nationwide permits with the current legal status of Florida’s Section 404 program at the time of finalization.

The change becomes effective March 15, 2026, when the 2026 Nationwide Permits take effect.

Practical Implications for Permitting in Florida

With Florida no longer listed under Nationwide Permit 24, the Corps remains the primary federal permitting authority for Section 404 activities involving waters of the United States in Florida, subject to the limits of federal jurisdiction.

Projects in Florida may still rely on other applicable nationwide permits or individual permits issued by the Corps, provided all applicable requirements are met. Clean Water Act Section 401 water quality certification remains required before a nationwide permit authorization becomes valid.

From a practical standpoint, the change underscores the importance of:

  • Verifying permitting authority early in project planning
  • Confirming which nationwide permits apply
  • Tracking state Section 401 certification decisions and conditions
  • Accounting for regional conditions imposed by the Corps

Broader Context

The Florida Nationwide Permit 24 issue highlights how nationwide permits depend on program level legal stability. Nationwide permits are intended to operate consistently across Corps districts. When the status of a state assumed program is uncertain, applying a permit designed specifically for assumed states becomes more complex.

The final rule does not resolve broader questions about the future of Florida’s assumed Section 404 program. Those issues remain subject to future administrative actions and court decisions.

Looking Ahead

The 2026 Nationwide Permits will guide federal wetland permitting through 2031. While many aspects of the program remain familiar, understanding targeted changes and state specific issues such as Florida’s status under Nationwide Permit 24 is essential for effective compliance and project planning.

The Swamp School will be addressing these topics in upcoming training, including a Nationwide Permits webinar on February 19, 2026, which will provide a detailed review of the final permits and their practical implications.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Why Commenting on the New WOTUS Rule Matters and How to Do It Effectively

The Environmental Protection Agency’s proposed update to the definition of Waters of the United States directly affects how wetlands and streams are identified, regulated, and permitted across the country. For wetland professionals and engineers, this rule is not an abstract policy discussion. It influences daily field decisions, jurisdictional determinations, permitting timelines, mitigation requirements, and the advice provided to clients. Because of this, participation in the public comment process is an important professional responsibility rather than a symbolic exercise.

Many people assume that public comments function as a vote on whether a rule is popular or unpopular. That assumption is incorrect. The federal rulemaking process does not operate as a poll. The EPA does not count how many comments support or oppose a proposed rule, nor does it change a rule based on the volume of public sentiment. Instead, the agency is legally required to consider and respond to substantive comments that raise meaningful technical, scientific, legal, or economic issues.

A substantive comment provides information the agency must address in the final rule. Courts reviewing EPA regulations focus on whether the agency considers relevant evidence and responds to substantive issues in a reasoned manner. They do not evaluate how many people object to a rule or support it. As a result, comments that simply express agreement or disagreement are acknowledged but do not influence the outcome of the rulemaking process.

For wetland professionals and engineers, substantive comments have a real and lasting impact. Well-supported comments influence how key terms are interpreted, how jurisdictional determinations are made in the field, and how consistently the rule is applied across different Corps districts. They affect how seasonal wetlands are treated, how intermittent streams are evaluated, how wet season concepts are implemented, and which technical tools regulators rely upon. When practitioners submit clear and technically grounded comments, they help create a regulatory framework that is more predictable, scientifically defensible, and workable in practice.

A meaningful comment does not need to be lengthy or written by an attorney. It does, however, need to be specific and grounded in professional experience. Effective comments identify the exact regulatory language being addressed and explain how that language affects field practice, engineering design, or permitting outcomes. Drawing on real-world experience with delineations, hydrologic assessments, mitigation planning, or jurisdictional determinations adds credibility and relevance to the comment.

Substantive comments rely on science and practice rather than opinion. Referencing hydrology, soil science, geomorphology, engineering constraints, or established federal guidance strengthens a comment significantly. Explaining why a provision may be difficult to implement, lead to inconsistent outcomes, or conflict with existing methods carries far more weight than stating that a rule weakens protections or increases regulation. EPA gives greater weight to comments that clearly describe implementation problems and explain their practical consequences.

The most effective comments also propose solutions. This does not require rewriting the rule, but it does involve suggesting clarifications, alternative language, or implementation standards that make the rule more workable. Comments that explain how existing tools or guidance could be incorporated or clarified are particularly valuable because they help EPA understand how the rule can be applied consistently in the field.

A good example of a substantive comment reads as follows.

The proposed definition of relatively permanent waters in Section V.C.1 relies on the presence of standing or continuously flowing surface water during the wet season, but the rule does not define how the wet season is determined in the field. In my experience conducting jurisdictional determinations across multiple Corps districts, hydrologic indicators differ substantially depending on the timing of site visits. Without a defined methodology or reference to existing tools such as the Antecedent Precipitation Tool and the Regional Supplements, this provision is likely to result in inconsistent determinations for similar sites. EPA can improve consistency by clarifying that wet season determinations are evaluated using multi-year precipitation data and established hydrology indicators rather than single site visits or short-term observations.

Example Comment

This type of comment identifies specific regulatory language, explains a real-world implementation problem, references accepted technical tools, and proposes a practical solution. As a result, it creates an issue EPA must address in the final rule or response to comments.

By contrast, certain types of comments rarely influence a final rule. Statements that simply support or oppose the rule without explanation do not require a response from the agency. Form letters that repeat identical language add no new information to the administrative record. Requests for more time to comment, while sometimes appropriate, do not provide substantive input unless followed by technical analysis. Emotional or political appeals that lack technical grounding also carry little weight in the rulemaking process.

A significant number of environmental organizations are currently submitting comments that focus almost exclusively on requesting an extension of the public comment period rather than addressing the substance of the proposed WOTUS rule. These comments typically argue that the review window is too short, overlaps with holidays, or does not allow sufficient time to analyze a complex regulatory proposal. While these concerns may be understandable, extension requests do not engage with the regulatory text or provide technical, scientific, or implementation analysis of the rule itself.

By submitting extension requests in place of substantive comments, these groups are effectively postponing participation in the rulemaking process. If EPA grants the extension, the organizations preserve the opportunity to submit detailed comments later. However, until substantive comments are actually submitted, EPA has no obligation to evaluate or respond to any concerns related to the rule’s content. Extension requests alone do not contribute to the administrative record in a way that can influence the final rule language or its implementation.

This approach creates a significant problem if the requested extensions are not granted. If the comment period closes on the original deadline, organizations that submitted only extension requests and no substantive comments lose their opportunity to shape the rule through the public comment process. In that situation, technical, scientific, or legal concerns that were not raised during the open comment period are unlikely to be considered by EPA or reviewed by a court. As a result, reliance on extension requests rather than timely substantive comments risks leaving key issues unaddressed in the final WOTUS rule.

Requests for additional time are common in federal rulemakings, but they are not automatically granted. The Trump administration has approved extensions for some rules while allowing others to proceed under the original deadlines, making each decision rule-specific. As a result, environmental groups that submit only extension requests and do not provide substantive comments during the existing comment period assume a real risk. If EPA declines to extend the deadline, those groups may lose the opportunity to place technical, scientific, or legal concerns into the administrative record, leaving key issues unaddressed in the final WOTUS rule.

As of now, the EPA has received over 13,000 comments on the proposed WOTUS rule, and the comment period remains open until January 5, 2026. While many comments express concern or support, only a small fraction raise unique, substantive issues that require agency response. Less than 150 comments have been posted. Groups that submit detailed, text-specific comments help define the issues EPA must address in its final decision.

For wetland professionals and engineers, the lesson is clear. Public comment remains one of the few opportunities to directly influence how federal regulations are written and implemented before they become binding. If practitioners want clearer standards, more consistent jurisdictional determinations, and field practices that reflect sound science, they must engage in the process now with substantive, evidence-based comments.

Opinions express concern, but substantive comments shape the rule.

Posted on — Leave a comment

WOTUS Listening Session December 12, 2025: What Sackett Means for Prairie Potholes, Ephemeral Streams, and Wetland Jurisdiction

The first official public listening session on the proposed new definition of Waters of the United States (WOTUS) was held on December 12, 2025, in Bismarck, North Dakota. Hosted at Bismarck State College, the meeting brought together leadership from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, North Dakota state government, and Congress to discuss how the Clean Water Act will be implemented following the Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Sackett v. EPA.

For wetland delineators, environmental consultants, engineers, regulators, farmers, and landowners, this meeting provided one of the clearest signals yet about how federal jurisdiction over wetlands, streams, prairie potholes, and ditches is changing under the new WOTUS rule.

The session opened with remarks from Dan Langan, Interim President of Bismarck State College, who emphasized the importance of aligning federal policy with real-world conditions in energy, agriculture, and workforce development. That theme carried through the entire meeting.

Senator Kevin Cramer of North Dakota framed the discussion around cooperative federalism, explaining that the Clean Water Act assigns primary responsibility for water management to the states, not Washington. He emphasized that prior WOTUS rules presumed federal jurisdiction over isolated wetlands, ephemeral streams, and dry land features, creating regulatory uncertainty and unnecessary permitting burdens. According to Senator Cramer, Sackett restores a clear legal boundary by limiting federal jurisdiction to relatively permanent waters and wetlands with continuous surface connections.

Governor Kelly Armstrong echoed those concerns, describing earlier WOTUS rules as an existential threat to North Dakota agriculture, ranching, and energy development. He pointed to prairie potholes and ephemeral drainages as examples of features that were swept into federal jurisdiction under prior interpretations, despite having little connection to navigable waters or interstate commerce. Governor Armstrong expressed support for the proposed WOTUS rule while emphasizing the need for precise definitions to prevent future expansion through interpretation.

Senator John Hoeven placed the rulemaking effort in historical context, noting years of litigation, congressional action, and regulatory reversals driven by shifting WOTUS definitions. He stressed that regulatory durability depends on strict adherence to Supreme Court precedent and respect for private property rights.

EPA leadership explained how the proposed rule implements Sackett v. EPA. Jessica Kramer, Assistant Administrator for EPA’s Office of Water, stated that the rule is designed to fully implement the Supreme Court’s direction, reduce regulatory burden, and restore cooperative federalism. She explained that wetlands and water features lacking continuous surface connections to relatively permanent waters—such as most prairie potholes—would generally fall outside federal jurisdiction. Peggy Brown, Principal Deputy Assistant Administrator for EPA’s Office of Water, emphasized that EPA and the Army Corps are focused on practical, field-level implementation and were in North Dakota to listen to stakeholder input.

Lee Forsgren, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil Works, reinforced that Sackett resolved decades of legal ambiguity. After Sackett, the key jurisdictional question is no longer whether a feature meets a technical wetland definition, but whether it is indistinguishably part of a relatively permanent waterbody. This shift has significant implications for wetland delineation, jurisdictional determinations, and permitting under the Clean Water Act.

Public comments during the December 12, 2025 listening session reinforced these themes with real-world examples from agriculture, transportation, construction, engineering, and business.

The North Dakota Attorney General’s office described the state’s leadership in multi-state litigation challenging earlier WOTUS rules and the substantial public resources required to repeatedly fight federal overreach. Speakers emphasized that litigation should not be the primary tool for defining Clean Water Act jurisdiction, and that a clear, lawful WOTUS rule is essential to avoid continued court battles.

Agricultural testimony focused heavily on prairie potholes, ephemeral streams, and isolated wetlands. State agriculture officials explained that prairie potholes are typically shallow depressions that hold water only sporadically, often after rainfall or snowmelt. Under prior WOTUS rules, these features were frequently treated as jurisdictional waters, triggering federal permits for routine farming activities such as planting, fencing, drainage, and tile installation. Producers often had to hire environmental consultants, engineers, and attorneys to navigate permitting processes for land that was dry most of the year.

Transportation officials highlighted similar challenges with roadside ditches. The North Dakota Department of Transportation described how uncertainty over whether ditches were jurisdictional delayed projects, increased costs, and shortened already limited construction seasons. Roadside ditches are essential for drainage, snow storage, and roadway safety, and speakers urged EPA and the Army Corps to clearly exclude ditches that do not carry relatively permanent flow.

Engineering firms, builders, and contractors emphasized how shifting WOTUS definitions created confusion, inefficiency, and rising project costs. Several speakers explained that regulatory uncertainty directly affects housing affordability, with some developments incurring tens of thousands of dollars in additional costs per home before construction begins due to permitting and mitigation requirements.

Business organizations stressed that clear WOTUS definitions are critical for economic growth. In a state with short construction seasons, even small permitting delays can push projects back an entire year. Predictable Clean Water Act jurisdiction allows businesses to plan, secure financing, and invest with confidence.

State environmental regulators explained that waters not regulated under WOTUS are still protected under North Dakota law. The state regulates both surface water and groundwater and supports a WOTUS rule that aligns with Sackett while recognizing state primacy in managing water resources.

Farmers and ranchers returned repeatedly to the importance of clarity. Representatives from cattle and farm organizations explained that for decades, landowners have struggled to determine whether features on their own property were federally regulated. Prairie potholes, ephemeral tributaries, and isolated wetlands have long existed in jurisdictional gray areas, creating confusion, delays, and enforcement risk. Speakers emphasized that a workable WOTUS rule should allow an average landowner to walk their property and make a reasonable preliminary jurisdictional assessment without hiring specialists.

Across all testimony, several conclusions were consistent. Stakeholders broadly supported aligning WOTUS with Sackett v. EPA and narrowing federal jurisdiction to relatively permanent waters with continuous surface connections. Prairie potholes, ephemeral streams, roadside ditches, and isolated wetlands were repeatedly identified as features that should remain under state authority. Regulatory clarity, predictability, and durability were viewed as essential for effective wetland regulation, infrastructure development, agriculture, and economic growth.

Taken together, the December 12, 2025 WOTUS listening session demonstrated that Sackett has fundamentally reset Clean Water Act jurisdiction. The central question is no longer how broadly federal agencies can regulate wetlands and streams, but how narrowly federal authority must be defined to comply with Supreme Court precedent. For North Dakota and similar states, this shift represents a return to lawful, practical, and field-workable regulation grounded in science, constitutional limits, and cooperative federalism.

Posted on — Leave a comment

Unseen but Binding: How Technical Standards Quietly Shape WOTUS—and Why That Must Change

Why Technical Manuals Must Go Through Full APA Rulemaking

As the agencies move forward with the new proposed Waters of the United States (WOTUS) rule, the biggest issue may not be the definitions themselves—but the technical materials used to apply them in the field. Our recently submitted public comment focuses directly on this problem, and we want to highlight its core message for our community of wetland professionals.

(A link to the full, formal comment is provided below.)

The Central Issue: Substantive Technical Standards Require APA Rulemaking

Our comment emphasizes a straightforward principle supported by longstanding administrative law:

When a technical manual or scientific tool determines whether a water or wetland is jurisdictional under the Clean Water Act, that document functions as a substantive rule—and must be adopted through the Administrative Procedure Act’s notice-and-comment process.

Today, many of the documents that control jurisdictional decisions are not regulations. They were never put out for public comment, never published in the Federal Register, and never formally adopted as rules. Yet they are treated as mandatory in the field.

This gap creates legal risk, regulatory inconsistency, and confusion for the regulated public.

A Key Distinction: The Regional Supplements Did It Right

One important point we stress in the comment is that the Corps’ Regional Supplements did go through a full, structured public vetting process, including:

  • publication of drafts,
  • scientific peer review,
  • stakeholder engagement, and
  • incorporation of public feedback.

They stand as an example of how technical standards should be developed—transparently, scientifically, and with public involvement.

However, the problem arises because the Regional Supplements rely on a suite of other documents that did not undergo this process.

This includes:

  • The Field Indicators of Hydric Soils (v9.2)
  • The 2025 National OHWM Manual
  • The Streamflow Duration Assessment Method (SDAM)
  • The Antecedent Precipitation Tool (APT v3.0)
  • WebWIMP
  • The 1987 Wetland Delineation Manual

Although the Regional Supplements themselves were publicly vetted, they incorporate these additional materials—some even through dynamic incorporation—causing jurisdictional criteria to change outside any APA process.

The Exception That Proves the Rule: The National Wetland Plant List

One of the clearest examples of proper procedure is the National Wetland Plant List (NWPL).

The Corps—and its federal partners—recognized years ago that classifications of plant wetland status have real regulatory consequences. Whether a species is classified as obligate, facultative wetland, or upland can determine whether a site has hydrophytic vegetation and thus whether it is jurisdictional.

Importantly:

  • The NWPL was published in the Federal Register.
  • Revisions do undergo public notice and comment.
  • Stakeholders can review, challenge, and respond to proposed changes.
  • The agencies respond publicly to comments and issue updated lists based on that record.

This process is transparent, predictable, and legally defensible.

It is also the only major jurisdictional technical framework that has been treated this way.

The NWPL proves that the agencies know how to properly adopt a scientific standard through APA rulemaking. The comment argues that the same process must be applied consistently across all jurisdictional tools.

Hydric Soil Indicators: A Central Example

The NRCS Field Indicators of Hydric Soils are scientifically rigorous and invaluable to delineation, but they were created for internal USDA program use—not Clean Water Act jurisdiction.

When the Corps relies on these indicators to determine whether a wetland is regulated, the indicators effectively become federal rules. Revisions to these indicators can shift jurisdictional outcomes without:

  • public notice,
  • opportunity for comment, or
  • a formal rulemaking record.

Our comment argues that this places both landowners and practitioners in an untenable position and exposes the agencies to unnecessary legal vulnerability.

The Same Issue Appears Across Key Hydrologic Tools

Several critical methodologies—now widely used and often considered mandatory—were also never adopted as rules:

  • Streamflow Duration Assessment Method (SDAM)
  • Antecedent Precipitation Tool v3.0 (APT)
  • 2025 National OHWM Manual
  • WebWIMP geospatial screening system

Each directly influences jurisdictional determinations. Each can change outcomes. And none were formally promulgated.

Courts have repeatedly held that agencies cannot enforce such documents without following proper rulemaking procedures.

Why Listening Sessions Are Not a Substitute for APA Rulemaking

Although EPA has held various listening sessions, outreach meetings, and stakeholder briefings on technical wetland materials over the years, these activities do not constitute Administrative Procedure Act (APA) notice-and-comment rulemaking. Listening sessions provide opportunities for discussion and information exchange, but they are not published as proposed rules, do not open a formal docket, do not create an administrative record, and do not require the agency to respond to public input. Under the APA, substantive standards must be adopted through a structured process that includes Federal Register publication of a proposed rule, written public comments, agency responses, and publication of a final rule. Listening sessions can complement that process, but they cannot replace it. For technical materials that determine Clean Water Act jurisdiction, only full APA rulemaking ensures transparency, public participation, and legal durability.

What We Recommended to the Agencies

Our comment proposes a clear and workable solution:

  1. Adopt all jurisdiction-determining manuals and tools through APA notice-and-comment rulemaking.
  2. End the practice of dynamic incorporation, which allows external committees or other agencies to change federal jurisdiction without public participation.
  3. Include regulatory text in the new WOTUS rule stating that no technical standard may be used to determine jurisdiction unless it has been formally adopted as a rule.
  4. Require all future revisions to such technical standards to undergo the same APA process.

This would bring clarity, transparency, and legal durability to the entire WOTUS implementation framework.

Why This Matters for Wetland Professionals

If adopted, these changes would:

  • provide greater certainty for consultants,
  • ensure transparency in future revisions,
  • strengthen jurisdictional determinations against legal challenge, and
  • support consistent application of the WOTUS rule nationwide.

In short, formalizing the technical backbone of delineation work is essential for the long-term stability of Clean Water Act implementation.

Learn More in January: 2026 Wetland Status & Trends Webinar

This issue, along with the broader implications of the new WOTUS proposal, will be a major focus of our upcoming:

2026 Wetland Status & Trends Webinar

January 22, 2026 • 1 PM Eastern

We’ll break down:

  • evolving jurisdictional standards,
  • the status of technical manuals and tools,
  • anticipated regulatory shifts in 2026, and
  • how consultants can prepare for the coming changes.

Read the Formal Comment

For those who want the detailed and technical reasoning, including citations, our full public comment is available here:

Disclaimer: This summary is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Readers should consult qualified legal counsel for guidance on specific regulatory or compliance matters.

Posted on — 1 Comment

WOTUS and Swampbuster Compliance for Agricultural Producers

Why Non-Jurisdictional Wetlands Can Still Trigger USDA Penalties

Disclaimer: This document is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Producers and consultants should seek guidance from qualified legal counsel regarding specific compliance obligations under the Food Security Act, the Clean Water Act, or related federal programs.

I. Introduction

The Environmental Protection Agency and the Department of the Army released the 2025 Proposed Definition of Waters of the United States. This action has generated significant confusion among agricultural producers about which wetlands fall under EPA authority and which remain subject to the Food Security Act administered by the United States Department of Agriculture.

A common misconception is that a wetland must be regulated under the Clean Water Act in order for a producer to face federal penalties for filling it. This is incorrect. The Food Security Act often applies to wetlands even when those same wetlands are not considered Waters of the United States. The purpose of this brief is to explain the legal frameworks and clarify when and why USDA penalties apply.

II. Statutory Framework

A. Clean Water Act Jurisdiction

The Clean Water Act governs the discharge of dredged or fill material into navigable waters as defined at 33 U.S.C. 1362(7). The 2025 Proposed WOTUS rule emphasizes two key factors: relatively permanent flow and a continuous surface connection. Wetlands that do not meet these criteria are not jurisdictional under the Clean Water Act and do not require permits under Section 404.

B. Food Security Act Wetland Compliance

The Food Security Act of 1985 creates wetland conservation requirements known as the Swampbuster provisions. These are codified at 16 U.S.C. 3801 through 16 U.S.C. 3862. The statutory provisions relevant to wetland identification and conversion include:

  1. 16 U.S.C. 3801(a)(27) which defines wetlands for USDA purposes.
  2. 16 U.S.C. 3821 which makes producers ineligible for USDA benefits following a wetland conversion.
  3. 16 U.S.C. 3822 which outlines certification processes including restoration, minimal effect, and mitigation criteria.

These statutory requirements are implemented through USDA regulations at 7 C.F.R. Part 12. NRCS defines wetlands based on hydric soils, hydrophytic vegetation, and wetland hydrology. There is no requirement for hydrologic connection to navigable waters. This means USDA wetland determinations operate independently from the WOTUS definition.

III. Independence of USDA Wetland Determinations

The 2025 WOTUS rule explicitly reaffirms that USDA makes its own determinations for the Food Security Act. EPA and the Corps acknowledge that the USDA retains full authority over prior converted cropland determinations and wetland certification for agricultural programs.

The agencies state that the USDA is responsible for making determinations as to whether land is prior converted cropland for its Food Security Act purposes.¹

They also state that USDA determinations of prior converted cropland will continue to be recognized for Clean Water Act purposes.²

This confirms that USDA wetlands are governed by the Food Security Act, not the Clean Water Act, and that the WOTUS rule has no bearing on Swampbuster applicability.

IV. USDA Penalties Apply Regardless of WOTUS Status

Under 16 U.S.C. 3821(a), a producer who converts a USDA-designated wetland becomes ineligible for a wide range of USDA program benefits until the wetland is restored or mitigation is approved. This penalty applies even if the wetland is not jurisdictional under the Clean Water Act.

Example

A producer fills a depressional wetland that has no continuous surface connection. The wetland is not WOTUS under the 2025 rule so no Section 404 permit is required. However, NRCS identifies the area as containing hydric soils, hydrophytic vegetation, and wetland hydrology. It is therefore a Swampbuster wetland. The producer becomes ineligible for FSA subsidies, crop insurance premium assistance, and other USDA benefits until compliance is restored.

This scenario illustrates the independence of the two systems. EPA and USACE may lack jurisdiction, yet USDA penalties still apply.

V. Prior Converted Cropland Under Both Statutory Schemes

Prior Converted Cropland is defined at 7 C.F.R. 12.2(a)(8) and 16 U.S.C. 3801(a)(8). The 2025 WOTUS rule continues to exclude PCC from jurisdiction unless abandoned. Abandonment occurs when the land has not been used for agricultural purposes for more than five years and wetland characteristics return.³

Importantly, abandonment for Clean Water Act purposes may not result in abandonment under USDA rules, and vice versa. USDA PCC determinations are made independently using the Food Security Act and the National Food Security Act Manual.

VI. USDA Conservation Programs Use USDA Definitions

USDA conservation programs, including the Wetland Reserve Program and Wetland Reserve Easements, rely exclusively on NRCS wetland determinations, not EPA jurisdiction. If a producer alters or damages a wetland protected under a USDA conservation contract, penalties, repayment obligations, and restoration requirements may be imposed regardless of Clean Water Act jurisdiction.

VII. Conclusion

A wetland does not need to be a Water of the United States for the Food Security Act to apply. Clean Water Act jurisdiction is not required for USDA to impose penalties for wetland conversion. The two statutes provide distinct definitions, regulatory standards, and enforcement authorities. Compliance with one statute does not guarantee compliance with the other, and producers must consider both before altering land that could contain wetland characteristics.

Agricultural producers and consultants should seek qualified legal counsel before conducting activities that may affect wetland areas or prior converted cropland, particularly under changing federal regulatory frameworks.

Endnotes

1. Environmental Protection Agency and Department of the Army, Updated Definition of Waters of the United States (Proposed Rule), prepublication version signed Nov. 17, 2025, p. 149.

2. Ibid., p. 150.

3. Ibid., pp. 143 to 144.

4. Food Security Act of 1985, Pub. L. 99 198, codified at 16 U.S.C. 3801 et seq.

5. 16 U.S.C. 3821. Ineligibility for program benefits for certain conversions of wetlands.

6. 16 U.S.C. 3822. Certification of wetlands including restoration, mitigation, and minimal effect provisions.

7. 7 C.F.R. Part 12. Highly Erodible Land and Wetland Conservation.

8. 7 C.F.R. 12.2(a)(27). Definition of wetland for USDA purposes.

9. 7 C.F.R. 12.2(a)(8). Definition of prior converted cropland.

10. USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service. National Food Security Act Manual, Parts 513 to 527.

Posted on — 3 Comments

The 2025 Proposed WOTUS Rule: Less Federal Jurisdiction, More Required Data, and Major Implications for Development and Environmental Consulting

On November 17, 2025, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Department of the Army announced proposed revisions to the 2023 definition of “waters of the United States” under the Clean Water Act. The proposed rule is intended to fully implement the Supreme Court’s 2023 decision in Sackett v. EPA. The agencies describe the proposal as a way to increase regulatory clarity, reduce federal overreach, and focus jurisdiction on relatively permanent waters and wetlands with a clear continuous surface connection.

While the new rule reduces federal jurisdiction, it significantly increases the technical documentation required from applicants. This shift will directly affect developers, landowners, agricultural operations, and environmental consultants.

A Narrower Definition of Federal Jurisdiction

The 2025 proposed rule restricts jurisdiction to two primary categories:

  1. Waters that are relatively permanent. These are waters that have standing or continuously flowing water year round or at least during the wet season.
  2. Wetlands that have a continuous surface connection to such waters. A new two part test requires that the wetland directly abut a jurisdictional water and hold surface water during the wet season.

The proposal also clarifies exclusions for ditches, prior converted cropland, waste treatment systems, and groundwater. This results in a narrower federal jurisdictional footprint.

However, determining whether a feature is or is not jurisdictional now requires significantly more technical evidence than in previous years.

Less Jurisdiction, But More Required Data From Applicants

Although fewer areas may fall under federal jurisdiction, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers has increased the level of scientific documentation needed to support a jurisdictional determination.

The Corps does not conduct these studies.
Applicants must supply all required data, typically through environmental consultants. These data now must be collected using standardized methods and meet specific digital formatting requirements.

Applicants may be required to submit:

  • Detailed hydrology monitoring records
  • Documentation of wet season observations
  • Flow path and surface connection evaluations
  • Soil and vegetation characterizations
  • High resolution mapping and spatial analysis
  • Surveyed boundary data and elevation profiles
  • GNSS verified location data
  • Long term observations and wet season verification evidence

These requirements increase project costs and timelines and may lead some developers to reconsider projects with marginal feasibility.

New 2025 Technical Documents Underscore the Increased Data Expectations

Several technical documents used in 2025 illustrate the increasing expectations for hydrologic evidence, soil analyses, vegetation characterization, wet season confirmation, ARDR reporting, survey requirements, and GNSS accuracy. These documents form the scientific and procedural foundation for jurisdictional determinations under the proposed rule.

1. National Ordinary High Water Mark Manual 2025
The updated OHWM Manual includes expanded geomorphic indicators, improved hydrologic signatures, and strengthened survey requirements. Surveyed cross sections, elevation profiles, bankfull indicators, and GNSS verified field points are now expected. OHWM determinations must show spatial accuracy suitable for ARDR inclusion.

2. Antecedent Precipitation Tool Update 2025
The updated APT introduces more rigorous assessments of antecedent moisture conditions and standardized data tables for ARDR reporting. The new format requires applicants to correlate hydrologic indicators with wet, normal, or dry season status and to provide GNSS located hydrologic monitoring points.

3. Streamflow Duration Assessment Tool and 2025 Technical Guide
This guide refines methods for classifying streams as perennial, intermittent, or ephemeral. It includes new flow indicators, revised scoring thresholds, expanded field examples, and detailed data sheet requirements. Surveyed longitudinal profiles, surveyed cross sections, and georeferenced photo stations must meet GNSS accuracy standards appropriate for ARDR submissions.

4. Proposed 2025 WOTUS Definition Technical Support Materials
These materials provide the scientific and regulatory foundation for terms such as relatively permanent waters, tributaries, abutting wetlands, and continuous surface connections. The materials outline expectations for documenting wet season surface water, surveyed elevation relationships, and GNSS supported analyses.

5. USDA Hydric Soil Technical Standard and Hydric Soil Field Indicators 2025
The updated hydric soil materials require more detailed field characterizations, including morphological transitions, redoximorphic features, saturation depth measurements, and high accuracy GNSS located soil profile points. These updates support more defensible wetland boundary determinations and align soil documentation with ARDR standards.

6. New ARDR, Survey, and GNSS Requirements Across All 2025 Manuals
The Corps has standardized Aquatic Resource Delineation Report requirements across all 2025 field manuals. Key expectations include:

  • Surveyed wetland boundaries rather than approximate delineations
  • GNSS data with sub meter or decimeter accuracy depending on feature type
  • Georeferenced photo logs with GNSS metadata including elevation
  • Survey grade elevation data to evaluate surface connections
  • Required surveyed cross sections for streams and wetland connections
  • Standardized ARDR data tables for hydrology, soils, vegetation, and connectivity
  • Wet season verification windows with supporting field evidence
  • Digital formats compatible with Corps geospatial review systems

These standards ensure that all field data are spatially precise, repeatable, and defensible.

The Role of the RSS Input System in 2025 ARDR Submittals

Another significant development in 2025 is the expanded use of the RSS Input System. The RSS platform serves as the Corps standardized digital interface for receiving and evaluating Aquatic Resource Delineation Reports.

The RSS Input System requires applicants to upload geospatial, hydrologic, soil, vegetation, survey, and photo documentation using structured templates. Because the system performs automated completeness checks, all data must be correctly formatted, georeferenced, and internally consistent before the Corps will begin review.

Key functions of the RSS system include:

  • Standardized digital submission of ARDR materials
  • Required use of Corps approved data tables and metadata structures
  • Mandatory GNSS located data for soils, hydrology, vegetation, and connectivity points
  • Integration with surveyed boundaries, digital maps, and spatial files
  • Automated checks for missing data, inconsistent coordinates, and errors
  • Compatibility with internal Corps geospatial analysis systems

The RSS system reinforces the Corps movement toward data driven jurisdictional determinations. Reports that do not meet these standards risk being delayed or rejected.

Increased Demand for Environmental Consultants

The combination of reduced jurisdiction and increased documentation requirements will significantly expand the role of environmental consultants. Consultants will be needed to prepare ARDR compliant assessments, conduct field surveys, collect GNSS verified data, monitor wet season conditions, prepare vegetation and soil analyses, and compile digital submittals that meet the RSS system requirements.

This represents a substantial increase in workload and technical expectations across the environmental consulting sector.

The Swamp School Response

In response to these new regulatory expectations, the Swamp School is developing a unified wetland assessment protocol that integrates all required studies, field methods, survey standards, GNSS accuracy requirements, and data formats suitable for ARDR and RSS submissions. This comprehensive protocol will provide wetland delineators and environmental professionals with a fully standardized approach aligned with the 2025 technical manuals and the proposed WOTUS rule.

To learn more and stay ahead of these changes, you can download our free white paper and receive updates on the protocol’s release, along with early training opportunities. Click the button below to get your copy and join the interest list.

Posted on — Leave a comment

USACE Launches Powerful New Tool to Track Rainfall and Streamflow Conditions Nationwide

Published: November 13, 2025

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) has released Version 3.0 of the Antecedent Precipitation Tool (APT). This is a major upgrade that transforms one of the Corps’ most widely used hydrologic evaluation tools into a far more comprehensive system. Once focused only on rainfall patterns, APT now integrates streamflow analysis, offering an unprecedented view into how water behaves on the landscape.

For environmental professionals, regulators, and landowners working with wetlands and streams, this release arrives at an important moment. With new Waters of the United States (WOTUS) rules expected before the end of the year, APT 3.0 will have a direct role in supporting the implementation of those upcoming regulatory changes.


APT 3.0: A Major Step Forward for Water Resource Evaluation

Historically, APT has been the go-to tool for determining whether hydrologic conditions at a site were drier than normal, normal, or wetter than normal based on precipitation data. APT 3.0 maintains its precipitation analysis. The significant addition is something practitioners have long requested.

Streamflow Normalcy Analysis

APT 3.0 now draws from two key sources:

  • USGS observed streamflow
  • NOAA National Water Model (NWM) modeled streamflow

These data allow the tool to determine whether streams near a site were flowing below normal, normal, or above normal on a selected observation date.

This shift from rainfall only to rainfall plus streamflow represents a major advancement in the Corps’ hydrologic assessment capabilities.


Why This Matters for the New WOTUS Rules

The environmental community is anticipating new WOTUS regulations before the year concludes. These rules are expected to place a clearer focus on several hydrologic factors such as:

  • Hydrologic connections
  • Flow duration
  • Surface water pathways
  • Seasonal and climatic variability

APT 3.0’s new streamflow capabilities directly support these areas.

Because WOTUS determinations often depend on understanding how water moves, connects, and persists across a landscape, the ability to evaluate streamflow normalcy offers a more accurate and defensible hydrologic baseline. This is precisely the type of information practitioners and regulators will need under the new rule.

In practical terms:

APT 3.0 is positioned to become a key supporting tool for documenting hydrologic conditions in future WOTUS assessments.

The timing of the release supports the nation’s transition to the new rule by improving the ability to evaluate the hydrologic context at a site.


How the New Streamflow Feature Works

When users enable the “Calculate Local Streamflow Normal?” option, APT 3.0 automatically:

  1. Finds nearby USGS gages based on the site location
  2. Pulls daily flow values for the full period of record
  3. Computes flow percentiles for the specific calendar day
  4. Determines if the streamflow at the site date was below normal, normal, or above normal
  5. Performs the same analysis using NWM data for ungauged reaches

APT outputs the results in several user-friendly formats including:

  • KML files for Google Earth or GIS
  • CSV summary files
  • Color coded normalcy indicators
  • Distance based gage listings

Expanded Geographic Coverage

APT 3.0 supports hydrologic evaluations throughout:

  • All 50 states
  • Puerto Rico
  • U.S. Virgin Islands

For the continental United States, streamflow normalcy is available from 2022 onward using updated NWM and historical data.


Precipitation Analysis Remains the Foundation

All traditional precipitation based functions remain in place, including:

  • Thirty year precipitation climatology
  • Weighted 90 day Antecedent Precipitation Score (APS)
  • Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI)
  • Wet and dry season determinations using WebWIMP

Combined with streamflow data, APT 3.0 now provides a multi dimensional view of hydrologic normalcy that earlier versions could not achieve.


Where to Access APT 3.0 and the New User Guide

Installation is simple. Extract the .7z file, run main_ex.exe, and APT will create a desktop shortcut and automatically update datasets as needed.


Final Thoughts

The release of APT 3.0 could not be better timed. With new WOTUS rules arriving soon, environmental professionals will need tools that provide clear and defensible information about hydrologic connections and flow patterns.

APT 3.0 delivers exactly that. Whether you are preparing a jurisdictional determination, conducting a site visit, or reviewing hydrologic data, APT 3.0 offers a streamlined, data driven approach to understanding water behavior on the landscape. This update strengthens the nation’s ability to make well informed decisions that align with the new regulatory environment.

Questions and feedback can be sent directly to USACE at:
APT-Report-Issue@usace.army.mil