Posted on — Leave a comment

Why Commenting on the New WOTUS Rule Matters and How to Do It Effectively

The Environmental Protection Agency’s proposed update to the definition of Waters of the United States directly affects how wetlands and streams are identified, regulated, and permitted across the country. For wetland professionals and engineers, this rule is not an abstract policy discussion. It influences daily field decisions, jurisdictional determinations, permitting timelines, mitigation requirements, and the advice provided to clients. Because of this, participation in the public comment process is an important professional responsibility rather than a symbolic exercise.

Many people assume that public comments function as a vote on whether a rule is popular or unpopular. That assumption is incorrect. The federal rulemaking process does not operate as a poll. The EPA does not count how many comments support or oppose a proposed rule, nor does it change a rule based on the volume of public sentiment. Instead, the agency is legally required to consider and respond to substantive comments that raise meaningful technical, scientific, legal, or economic issues.

A substantive comment provides information the agency must address in the final rule. Courts reviewing EPA regulations focus on whether the agency considers relevant evidence and responds to substantive issues in a reasoned manner. They do not evaluate how many people object to a rule or support it. As a result, comments that simply express agreement or disagreement are acknowledged but do not influence the outcome of the rulemaking process.

For wetland professionals and engineers, substantive comments have a real and lasting impact. Well-supported comments influence how key terms are interpreted, how jurisdictional determinations are made in the field, and how consistently the rule is applied across different Corps districts. They affect how seasonal wetlands are treated, how intermittent streams are evaluated, how wet season concepts are implemented, and which technical tools regulators rely upon. When practitioners submit clear and technically grounded comments, they help create a regulatory framework that is more predictable, scientifically defensible, and workable in practice.

A meaningful comment does not need to be lengthy or written by an attorney. It does, however, need to be specific and grounded in professional experience. Effective comments identify the exact regulatory language being addressed and explain how that language affects field practice, engineering design, or permitting outcomes. Drawing on real-world experience with delineations, hydrologic assessments, mitigation planning, or jurisdictional determinations adds credibility and relevance to the comment.

Substantive comments rely on science and practice rather than opinion. Referencing hydrology, soil science, geomorphology, engineering constraints, or established federal guidance strengthens a comment significantly. Explaining why a provision may be difficult to implement, lead to inconsistent outcomes, or conflict with existing methods carries far more weight than stating that a rule weakens protections or increases regulation. EPA gives greater weight to comments that clearly describe implementation problems and explain their practical consequences.

The most effective comments also propose solutions. This does not require rewriting the rule, but it does involve suggesting clarifications, alternative language, or implementation standards that make the rule more workable. Comments that explain how existing tools or guidance could be incorporated or clarified are particularly valuable because they help EPA understand how the rule can be applied consistently in the field.

A good example of a substantive comment reads as follows.

The proposed definition of relatively permanent waters in Section V.C.1 relies on the presence of standing or continuously flowing surface water during the wet season, but the rule does not define how the wet season is determined in the field. In my experience conducting jurisdictional determinations across multiple Corps districts, hydrologic indicators differ substantially depending on the timing of site visits. Without a defined methodology or reference to existing tools such as the Antecedent Precipitation Tool and the Regional Supplements, this provision is likely to result in inconsistent determinations for similar sites. EPA can improve consistency by clarifying that wet season determinations are evaluated using multi-year precipitation data and established hydrology indicators rather than single site visits or short-term observations.

Example Comment

This type of comment identifies specific regulatory language, explains a real-world implementation problem, references accepted technical tools, and proposes a practical solution. As a result, it creates an issue EPA must address in the final rule or response to comments.

By contrast, certain types of comments rarely influence a final rule. Statements that simply support or oppose the rule without explanation do not require a response from the agency. Form letters that repeat identical language add no new information to the administrative record. Requests for more time to comment, while sometimes appropriate, do not provide substantive input unless followed by technical analysis. Emotional or political appeals that lack technical grounding also carry little weight in the rulemaking process.

A significant number of environmental organizations are currently submitting comments that focus almost exclusively on requesting an extension of the public comment period rather than addressing the substance of the proposed WOTUS rule. These comments typically argue that the review window is too short, overlaps with holidays, or does not allow sufficient time to analyze a complex regulatory proposal. While these concerns may be understandable, extension requests do not engage with the regulatory text or provide technical, scientific, or implementation analysis of the rule itself.

By submitting extension requests in place of substantive comments, these groups are effectively postponing participation in the rulemaking process. If EPA grants the extension, the organizations preserve the opportunity to submit detailed comments later. However, until substantive comments are actually submitted, EPA has no obligation to evaluate or respond to any concerns related to the rule’s content. Extension requests alone do not contribute to the administrative record in a way that can influence the final rule language or its implementation.

This approach creates a significant problem if the requested extensions are not granted. If the comment period closes on the original deadline, organizations that submitted only extension requests and no substantive comments lose their opportunity to shape the rule through the public comment process. In that situation, technical, scientific, or legal concerns that were not raised during the open comment period are unlikely to be considered by EPA or reviewed by a court. As a result, reliance on extension requests rather than timely substantive comments risks leaving key issues unaddressed in the final WOTUS rule.

Requests for additional time are common in federal rulemakings, but they are not automatically granted. The Trump administration has approved extensions for some rules while allowing others to proceed under the original deadlines, making each decision rule-specific. As a result, environmental groups that submit only extension requests and do not provide substantive comments during the existing comment period assume a real risk. If EPA declines to extend the deadline, those groups may lose the opportunity to place technical, scientific, or legal concerns into the administrative record, leaving key issues unaddressed in the final WOTUS rule.

As of now, the EPA has received over 13,000 comments on the proposed WOTUS rule, and the comment period remains open until January 5, 2026. While many comments express concern or support, only a small fraction raise unique, substantive issues that require agency response. Less than 150 comments have been posted. Groups that submit detailed, text-specific comments help define the issues EPA must address in its final decision.

For wetland professionals and engineers, the lesson is clear. Public comment remains one of the few opportunities to directly influence how federal regulations are written and implemented before they become binding. If practitioners want clearer standards, more consistent jurisdictional determinations, and field practices that reflect sound science, they must engage in the process now with substantive, evidence-based comments.

Opinions express concern, but substantive comments shape the rule.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *