A Subtle Change That Speaks Volumes
There has been a recent update to the definition of “distinct” in the USDA NRCS publication Field Indicators of Hydric Soils in the United States, Version 9.2. For most people, this might sound like a minor edit, but for soil scientists, delineators, and wetland professionals, this kind of change matters.
To understand why, we are taking a trip down memory lane to see how the definition of “distinct” has evolved through multiple versions of the Field Indicators of Hydric Soils. Over time, these small adjustments have influenced how we identify and classify hydric soils and, by extension, how wetlands are mapped and regulated across the country.
The 2016 Standard: Version 8.0
When Version 8.0 was released in 2016, the definition of “distinct” was as follows:
“Readily seen but contrasting only moderately with the color to which compared. The contrast is distinct if:
Delta hue = 0, then
Delta value <2 and delta chroma >1 to <4, or
Delta value >2 to <4 and delta chroma <4.Delta hue = 1, then
Delta value <1 and delta chroma >1 to <3, or
Delta value >1 to <3 and delta chroma <3.Delta hue = 2, then
Delta value = 0 and delta chroma >0 to <2, or
Delta value >0 to <2 and delta chroma <2.Regardless of the magnitude of hue difference, where both colors have a value <3 and a chroma <2, the contrast is faint.”
Two years later, Version 8.2 (2018) kept this exact definition. Everything about “distinct” remained the same, and most practitioners got comfortable with the established interpretation.
The 2024 Update: Version 9.0
Then came Version 9.0 in 2024, and with it, a small but meaningful change. The definition now read:
“Readily seen but contrasting only moderately with the color to which compared. The contrast is distinct for the following:
Delta hue equal to 0, then
Delta value of 2 or less and delta chroma 1 to less than 4, or
Delta value of 2 to less than 4 and delta chroma less than 4.Delta hue equal to 1, then
Delta value of 1 or less and delta chroma more than 1 to less than 3, or
Delta value greater than 1 to less than 3 and delta chroma less than 3.Delta hue equal to 2, then
Delta value equal to 0 and delta chroma greater than 0 to less than 2, or
Delta value greater than 0 to less than 2 and delta chroma less than 2.Exception: if the compared colors have both a value of 3 or less and a chroma 2 or less, then the color contrast is faint regardless of hue difference.”
At first glance, it looked nearly identical to the 2016 version. But upon closer inspection, the mathematical operators had changed: “less than” and “greater than” were replaced by “less than or equal to” and “greater than or equal to.”
This seemingly small edit expanded the range of contrasts that could qualify as “distinct.” In other words, soils that previously might have been considered faint could now be interpreted as distinct.
The 2025 Revision: Version 9.2
In 2025, with the release of Version 9.2, the NRCS reversed course and restored the original wording from Versions 8.0 and 8.2:
“Readily seen but contrasting only moderately with the color to which compared. The contrast is distinct if:
Delta hue = 0, then
Delta value <2 and delta chroma >1 to <4, or
Delta value >2 to <4 and delta chroma <4.Delta hue = 1, then
Delta value <1 and delta chroma >1 to <3, or
Delta value >1 to <3 and delta chroma <3.Delta hue = 2, then
Delta value = 0 and delta chroma >0 to <2, or
Delta value >0 to <2 and delta chroma <2.Regardless of the magnitude of hue difference, where both colors have value <3 and chroma <2, the contrast is faint.”
This change effectively narrowed the criteria again, making it slightly harder for a soil color contrast to be classified as distinct.
A Tale of Two Definitions: NRCS vs. USACE
Here is where things get complicated. The USDA NRCS and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) do not currently use the same definition of “distinct.”
The Field Indicators of Hydric Soils provides one version, but the USACE’s Regional Supplements, which are published in the Federal Register, use another. The USACE’s glossary defines “distinct” as:
Delta hue = 0, then
Delta value ≥0 to ≤2 and delta chroma >2 to <3, or
Delta value = 3 and delta chroma ≤1 to <3.Delta hue = 1, then
Delta value ≥0 to ≤2 and delta chroma of ≤1 to ≤2.Delta hue = 2, then
Delta value ≤1 and delta chroma ≤1.If both colors have values of ≤3 and chromas of ≤2, the color contrast is faint (regardless of the difference in hue).
Because the Regional Supplements are the versions published in the Federal Register, their definitions hold greater legal authority under the Clean Water Act Section 404 regulatory framework. The NRCS’s definitions, while scientifically important, serve as technical guidance rather than a regulatory standard.
What This Means in the Field
For wetland delineators and soil scientists, this is not just about math symbols. The interpretation of “distinct” directly influences whether a soil feature meets hydric criteria. A shift in definition can affect:
- Field classification: whether a soil horizon meets hydric indicators.
- Regulatory determinations: whether a site qualifies as a jurisdictional wetland.
- Consistency: ensuring delineations align with federal guidance and withstand regulatory review.
Understanding which definition applies, and when, is essential. The NRCS provides the science, but the USACE provides the rule.
Quick Reference: Comparing Definitions of “Distinct”
How has the definition of “distinct” evolved across versions of the Field Indicators of Hydric Soils and the USACE Regional Supplements?
Use this side-by-side comparison to see what changed and why it matters.
| Version / Source | Definition Summary | Effect on Field Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Version 8.0 (2016) | Delta values and chromas defined with < and >. “Distinct” = moderate contrast; faint if both value <3 and chroma <2. | Narrowest range; fewer soils qualify as distinct. |
| Version 8.2 (2018) | Same as Version 8.0. No changes. | Consistent with 8.0; no impact on delineations. |
| Version 9.0 (2024) | Revised to use ≤ and ≥ instead of < and >. Added exception clause clarifying faint contrasts. | Slightly expanded range; more soils could be classified as distinct. |
| Version 9.2 (2025) | Returned to the Version 8.0 wording using < and >. | Range narrowed again; restored traditional threshold. |
| USACE Regional Supplements | Published in the Federal Register. Uses unique mathematical thresholds and a separate faint definition. | Legally controlling for delineations; overrides Field Indicators when definitions differ. |
Example: When NRCS and USACE Definitions of “Distinct” Disagree
To see how these differences play out in the field, let’s look at a practical example involving real-world hydric soil indicators.
Scenario 1
Soil matrix: 10YR 4/2
Redox concentrations: 7.5YR 4/4
- Δhue = 1
- Δvalue = 0
- Δchroma = 2
NRCS (Version 9.2): Distinct ✅
USACE (Regional Supplements): Distinct ✅
Both agree, so there is no conflict.
This color relationship could meet the contrast requirements for the F3 Depleted Matrix indicator.
Indicator F3: Depleted Matrix identifies soils that have a matrix color of value ≥4 and chroma ≤2, with at least 2 percent “distinct” or “prominent” redox concentrations in the form of pore linings or soft masses. These redoximorphic features are formed by the reduction and oxidation of iron and manganese under prolonged saturation.
When 10YR 4/2 matrix colors display 7.5YR 4/4 redox concentrations that both NRCS and USACE agree are “distinct,” those redox features count toward the required 2 percent threshold. This would satisfy the contrast and abundance requirements for F3, confirming that the soil shows evidence of long-term reducing conditions and qualifies as hydric.
Scenario 2
Soil matrix: 10YR 3/2
Redox concentrations: 7.5YR 4/4
- Δhue = 1
- Δvalue = 1
- Δchroma = 2
NRCS (Version 9.2): Not distinct ❌
USACE (Regional Supplements): Distinct ✅
In this case, the same soil would be classified differently depending on which definition you apply.
This color pattern could correspond to an F6 Redox Dark Surface indicator.
Indicator F6: Redox Dark Surface applies to surface horizons with a dark-colored matrix (value ≤3 and chroma ≤2) and at least 5 percent “distinct” or “prominent” redox concentrations as pore linings or soft masses. These redox features indicate periodic reduction and oxidation close to the soil surface, where organic matter and reduced iron are commonly present.
Under the NRCS Version 9.2 definition, this color contrast would not meet the “distinct” threshold because the Δvalue and Δchroma combination falls outside the required range. The redox features would therefore not count toward the required 5 percent abundance for F6, potentially causing the soil to fail to qualify as hydric based on color evidence alone.
Under the USACE Regional Supplement definition, however, the same Δvalue and Δchroma would qualify as “distinct.” Those redox concentrations would then count toward the 5 percent threshold, allowing the horizon to meet the requirements for F6 and be classified as hydric.
Why This Matters
These examples highlight how small numerical differences in the definitions of “distinct” can influence whether a soil qualifies for hydric indicators such as F3 or F6.
- Under NRCS Field Indicators (Version 9.2), the stricter “less than” and “greater than” limits mean that some redox features may not show enough contrast to count as distinct. Even if redoximorphic features are present, they cannot be included in the required 2 or 5 percent if the color contrast fails the definition.
- Under USACE Regional Supplements, the broader “less than or equal to” and “greater than or equal to” ranges make it easier for redox features to meet the “distinct” criterion. That can make the difference between having enough redox concentrations to satisfy the 2 percent for F3 or the 5 percent for F6 indicators.
This difference can be the deciding factor in whether a soil horizon is classified as hydric or nonhydric. Because USACE definitions are the legally controlling standards for delineations under the Clean Water Act, field practitioners must use those definitions when determining whether redox features count toward a hydric soil indicator.
In other words, a soil that fails to meet the NRCS “distinct” standard might still be classified as hydric under USACE criteria, which could change the outcome of a jurisdictional determination.
The Takeaway
The evolution of “distinct” highlights the delicate balance between scientific interpretation and regulatory application. A single mathematical symbol can subtly shift how wetlands are identified and protected.
As always, Swamp School will continue tracking these updates and helping you stay ahead of the curve. After all, when it comes to wetlands, every color change tells a story.
Acknowledgments and Community Shoutout
A special thank you goes out to one of our former students, Matthew Goessling, for bringing the latest edition of the Field Indicators of Hydric Soils and the recent change to the definition of distinct to our attention. We always appreciate it when our students share updates, insights, and discoveries from the field.
At the Swamp School, our community of wetland professionals, scientists, and enthusiasts is what keeps these discussions alive and evolving. We love hearing your questions, your comments, and your “breaking soil science news.” We are also eager to hear what you have been up to since completing our classes.
So do not be a stranger. Give us a call, drop us a note, or share your latest field adventure. You never know, your next observation might inspire our next lesson or article.
