Cattail marsh in the Bosque del Apache National Wildlife Refuge in New Mexico. Photograph courtesy of Sue Major Holmes, the Associated Press, and E&E News by Politico.
Just when it looked like the latest “Waters of the United States” rulemaking was moving toward a final rule, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) appears to be taking another step back. According to reporting by Miranda Willson of GREENWIRE and E&E News by POLITICO, the EPA has sent a supplemental proposed rule to the White House for review. The article reports that the EPA sent the proposed supplement to its WOTUS definition for review on Tuesday, signaling that the administration is amending some part of the original proposal released in November 2025. ([Willson and E&E News by POLITICO][1])
That is significant. The November 2025 proposal was presented as an effort to provide a clearer, more durable definition of WOTUS following the Supreme Court’s decision in Sackett v. EPA. The EPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) said the proposed rule was intended to clarify federal jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act, improve predictability, and respect the role of states and Tribes in managing local water resources. The comment period for that proposal closed on January 5, 2026. Now, only months later, the agencies appear to be preparing a supplement.
Why This Matters
A supplemental proposal does not necessarily mean the EPA is abandoning its original approach. It may mean the agency is trying to clarify, revise, or strengthen part of the rule before it becomes final. But for landowners, developers, consultants, engineers, and regulators, the practical message is simple: the WOTUS uncertainty is not over.
The Clean Water Act definition of WOTUS determines which wetlands, streams, ditches, ponds, and other aquatic features may require federal permits. That definition affects wetland delineations, jurisdictional determinations, project planning, mitigation requirements, enforcement risk, and real estate development decisions. When the rule changes, the risk profile changes; when the rule is delayed, uncertainty remains.
The Likely Pressure Points
The biggest unresolved issue appears to be how the agencies will define and apply terms from the Sackett decision, especially “relatively permanent” waters and wetlands with a “continuous surface connection.” The November 2025 proposal attempted to narrow and clarify federal jurisdiction by focusing on waters that are relatively permanent and wetlands that are directly connected to those waters. The EPA’s own materials state that the proposal would define several key terms, including “relatively permanent,” “continuous surface connection,” “tributary,” “ditch,” “prior converted cropland,” and “waste treatment system.”
Those terms sound simple, but they are difficult to apply in the field. For example, what does “relatively permanent” mean for a stream that flows during the wet season but dries out later in the year? How should the Army Corps evaluate a wetland that has surface water connection during part of the year, but not at the time of inspection? What evidence should be used to decide whether a surface connection exists? How should regional differences in rainfall, evapotranspiration, and hydrology be handled?
These are not minor technical questions. They are the questions that determine whether a feature is federally jurisdictional.
The Wet Season Problem
One of the most important issues to watch is the “wet season” concept. The November 2025 proposal discussed waters that flow year-round or at least during the wet season. That approach creates an immediate practical problem: the wet season is not the same everywhere, and it does not always line up neatly with the day a field inspection occurs.
In some parts of the country, the wet season may be obvious. In other regions, especially arid or highly seasonal areas, it may be more complicated. Even in the eastern United States, a stream or wetland may respond to rainfall, groundwater, soil saturation, or evapotranspiration on a delayed schedule. That means the agencies may need to be more precise about how field staff, consultants, and regulators should document wet-season flow or surface connection. If they do not, the final rule could invite the same kind of inconsistent application and litigation that has followed prior WOTUS rules.
This May Be About Legal Durability
The EPA has repeatedly stated that the goal is a durable WOTUS rule that follows the Supreme Court’s direction in Sackett. That is easier said than done. The agencies must write a rule narrow enough to satisfy the Supreme Court’s limits on federal authority, but clear enough for field implementation. They also need to explain their reasoning well enough to survive the next round of litigation.
That may be why a supplemental proposal is now in play. The supplement could provide additional explanation, revise a definition, respond to comments, or reopen a specific issue for public input. Until the text is released, we do not know exactly what the EPA is changing. But the fact that the rule has gone back to the White House for review suggests the agencies are still working through important details.
What This Means for Current Projects
For now, project teams should be careful about assuming that the November 2025 proposal represents the final rule. It does not. Until a final rule is published and effective, current jurisdictional decisions still need to be made under the applicable existing regulatory framework and current agency guidance. For projects involving wetlands, streams, ditches, or uncertain aquatic features, the safest approach is to document field conditions carefully and avoid relying on broad assumptions about what the final WOTUS rule will say. That is especially true for projects involving:
- Seasonal streams
- Wetlands near ditches or tributaries
- Wetlands with intermittent surface connections
- Prior converted cropland
- Roadside or agricultural ditches
- Older wetland delineations or jurisdictional determinations
- Sites where the presence or absence of surface water connection is disputed
The proposed rule may eventually narrow federal jurisdiction, but the details will matter. A small change in the definition of “relatively permanent” or “continuous surface connection” could make a significant difference on the ground.
The Practical Takeaway
The EPA may still be heading toward a narrower post-Sackett WOTUS rule, but the path to finalizing that rule appears less settled than officials suggested when the November 2025 proposal was released. For consultants and developers, this is a reminder that WOTUS is still a moving target. The key is not just watching the headlines. The key is watching the technical language. The next version of the proposal may tell us how the EPA and the Army Corps intend to handle the hard field questions: wet-season flow, surface connections, tributaries, ditches, and the evidence needed to support a jurisdictional determination.
Until then, the best advice is simple: document the site conditions, preserve the record, and be cautious about making final jurisdictional assumptions based on a rule that is still under revision.
[1] Willson, Miranda. EPA heads back to the drafting board on WOTUS rule. GREENWIRE and E&E News by POLITICO. https://www.eenews.net/articles/trump-admin-prepares-tweaks-to-wotus-rule/. Accessed on July 2, 2026.
#WOTUS #EPA #USACE #CleanWaterAct #Wetlands #WetlandDelineation #EnvironmentalConsulting #EnvironmentalScience #RegulatoryUpdate #WaterResources #WetlandWednesday #TheSwampSchool