Posted on — Leave a comment

Clean Water Rule Now In Effect

Swamp Stomp

Volume 18 Issue 35

On August 16, 2018, the US District Court of South Carolina, Charleston Division issued an injunction to remove the 2-year delay of implementation of the Clean Water Rule. This arises out of a case brought before the Court by a number of environmental groups represented by the Southern Environmental Law Center against the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the American Farm Federation as well as a number of agricultural groups.

The result of this case was to make Clean Water Rule effective immediately and nationally. However, 26 other states have other Clean Water Rule stays that would remain in effect. The states that are affected by this decision include; California, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Texas, Vermont, Virginia and Washington.

States included in this decision are now subject the 2015 Waters of the US (WOTUS) definition. For all intensive purposes, a 2015 WOTUS includes all waters with the exception of puddles. However, while puddles are mentioned in the regulation they are not defined so, perhaps some could be jurisdictional.

The decision handed down to the agencies by U.S. District Court Judge David C. Norton appears to be largely a political one. In a highly unusual statement by the Judge, it would seem that the Trump administration is being punished for Obama era injunctions. Judge Norton cites in his decision the case of the City of Chicago v. Sessions:

“[U]nder the Obama administration, such injunctions stymied many of the President’s policies, with five nationwide injunctions issued by Texas district courts in just over a year[.] At that time, then-Senator and now-Attorney General Sessions characterized the upholding of one such nationwide preliminary injunction as “a victory for the American people and for the rule of law.” Press Release, Sen. Jeff Sessions III, June 23, 2016. Now, many who advocated for broad injunctions in those Obama era cases are opposing them.”

He further adds a rather fascinating statement of his own:

“This court agrees that nationwide injunctions should be utilized “only in rare circumstances.” Id. This is one such set of rare circumstances. Just because the political shoe is on the other foot does not mean that nationwide injunctions are no longer appropriate. What is good for the goose is good for the gander.”

His decision is based upon a perceived violation of the Administrative Procedures Act. This Act governs how the US government issues among other things regulations. The 2-year delay in the implementation of the Clean Water Rule was issued as a regulation with a 10-day public comment period. Apparently, this was not enough for the Judge. The rule was simply to delay the implementation of the new WOTUS definition.

It should be noted that the Clean Water Rule only defines what is a WOTUS. Not one word of the Rule has anything to do with cleaning up water. A number of environmental groups have rallied around the Clean Water Rule as some sort of water and wetland protection rule. It is not. It simply defines what waters are subject to federal regulation. The assumption is that if it is regulated by the federal government it must be cleaner. It is a bit ironic to make this assumption as the federal government has been responsible for more wetland loss than any other single entity. Just a few decades ago it was the policy of the federal government to drain and fill wetlands. Why then do you suppose that giving the federal government unilateral control over wetlands and waters would guarantee their protection? History would seem to dispute this.

In the meantime, it is safe to expect a delay on the issuance of any permits or Jurisdictional Determinations in the affected states. The Corps will need to issue some guidance on how it will comply with the Court’s findings as there is no current 2015 WOTUS guidance in place. As soon as it breaks we will post it on our FaceBook page and publish a follow-up newsletter.

References: August 16, 2018, Order No. 2-18-cv-330-DCN

Definition of Waters of the United States-Addition of Applicability Date to 2015 Clean Water Rule

Posted on — Leave a comment

2018 Soil Auger Buyer’s Guide

The Swamp Stomp

Volume 18, Issue 33

Wetland Soil Augers

One of the most frequently asked questions by our wetland delineation students is, “what type of soil auger should I buy?”

A quick browse through any of the forestry supply companies catalogs and you are quickly overwhelmed. Who would have thought that there we so many different types of soil augers? Some of them are quite expensive. Many are modular and you end up buying part of an auger and have to order more parts. You do not want to drop a grand on an auger only to find out it is not what you needed or expected.

To help you get a handle on this I have put together brief pros and cons of the most common soil augers used for wetland delineation. This list is based upon my personal field experience with these augers. Each has its place so be prepared to buy a few. I do have a favorite all around auger which I will also cover, but I own a bunch.

Tube Sampler

This is a favorite for the beginning wetland delineator. One of its biggest assets is it is the cheapest. However, it has limitations. The basic construction is a simple tube that is cut open at the bottom. There is usually about a 16 inch half pipe slice that is used to examine the soil profile in-situ. The very end is a ring that everyone gets their fingers stuck in. A good one is about 24 inches in length with an opening extending about 16-18 inches. There is a short t-handle on the top. Sometimes this is detachable with a screw fitting. Others have the handle welded on. The former is a bit more expensive.

One of the biggest advantages of this type of auger is the small footprint it makes. In glacial regions, it is sometimes the only auger that can get in between the rocks. It is also very handy for quick assessments.

The biggest disadvantage is the relatively small amount of soil sample this auger extracts. Oftentimes, it just is not enough sample to make a wetland determination. Small rocks are also a problem as they will plug up the tube end. The issue of cleaning it the sampler end out is also a challenge. Don’t stick your finger in the end. It is sharp and just the right size to get your finger stuck. Use a stick to clean it out.

Screw Sampler

This auger looks like a giant corkscrew. The screw is about a foot long and is about 2-3 feet in total length. The screw is usually attached by extension bars that can be added to achieve a comfortable length. It has a slightly larger footprint than the tube sampler and is similarly useful in glaciated regions.

The biggest challenge with using this auger is the ability to measure the thickness of a hydric soil feature. The screw blades are about .5 inches thick. This results in a stretching of the soil sample. It is hard to estimate how thick a feature may be using this auger. It also provides a very small about of soil sample.

Bucket Auger

 

This is probably the most common type of auger used by soil scientists. Not necessary wetland delineators, however. The basic design looks like a coffee can with one end open and the other end has two blades welded onto it. An extension bar connects in between the bucket and a t-handle on the top. All of these items can be customized to fit the user’s needs.

If you are just starting out delineating, you will probably be handed one of these bucket augers. There always seems to be one hiding in a closet in the office. Someone bought it, used it once and there it sits.

I do not have a lot of pros to offer with this type of auger. The biggest problem is that it grinds up the soil profile making it very hard to distinguish the hydric features if the soil. It also requires that once you auger down and grab a sample you then have to tip the bucket upside down and bang out the sample. This also obscures the features.

Soil scientists like these augers because they are trying to obtain a discrete sample at a specific depth. This is usually why the extension bars are so long. I have seen some augers used in the field that were over 6 feet long. This is very hard to use if you are 5’6” tall.

Dutch Auger (My Favorite)

This auger was made for wetland delineations. It is a double blade at the end of an extension bar and t-handle. It cuts a very nice sample without disturbing the profile integrity. You can usually auger down several feet fairly easily and lay out the samples in more or less the same way they would be found in the pit. You also get a decent amount of sample to play with.

There are a number of brands and styles of this type of auger. The biggest difference between the individual styles is a represented by the size and pitch of the blades. The original use of the Dutch auger was for muddy soils. However, there have been many modifications to the design and there is such a thing as a combination auger that works well in loamy soils as well as mud.

Sharp-Shooter

 

This is also known as a tree planting spade. It is simply a shovel that is 4 inches wide and 16 inches long. It digs a small hole and cuts a nice sample. In a pinch, this shovel will work in almost any circumstance.

The biggest advantage of this sampler is the cost. You can pick one of these up in your local home improvement center for about $25. Most of the other augers mentioned are well north of $200.

The biggest downside to this device is the work associated with it. Digging a hole is a lot of work. You get a nice amount of sample and you can even cut a nice sidewall to see the profile. However, this took a lot of work.

Quick Connect or Not

 

One last note on the issue of quick connects. To be frank, I have yet to see one of these work once they were put into field use. The fittings get gummed up with dirt and the quick connects jamb. I would suggest going with an all welded design. You are not going to take these apart anyway so why spend the extra money. If you need to travel by airplane, TSA is not going to let you carry these on so there is no need to break them down. Just check them or better yet, buy a shovel for $25 when you get to the job site.

Soil Auger Sources

Posted on

Wetland Delineation Instructor

The Swamp School is looking for an experienced wetland delineator to present our PWS Pre-Approved Wetland Delineation Training program to groups in various locations around the United States.  The ideal candidate should have extensive experience with the 1987 Wetland Delineation Manual and the Regional Supplements.  Regular travel (1 week per month) is required.  This position does not require the applicant to relocate and can be coordinated from a home office.

Interested applicants should send a cover letter and resume to jobs@swampschool.org

Posted on — Leave a comment

US Supreme Court WOTUS Ruling

Swamp Stomp

Volume 18, Issue 5

On Monday, January 22, 2018, the US Supreme Court in a unanimous decision ruled that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency cannot shelter its “waters of the United States” rule from judicial review by limiting where victims can sue. This decision is in response to the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals nationwide stay of the Clean Water Rule in October 2015. Oddly enough it is considered a victory for both the Plaintiff (National Association of Manufacturers) and a repudiation of the Trump Administration plan to repeal the Rule. The other odd thing about this ruling is that it exclusively directs its admonition to the US Environmental Protection Agency when the defendant was the US Department of Defense.

In case you have not been following this issue, what is at stake is what waterbodies are regulated by the US Government under the Clean Water Act.

This ruling is important because it does two important things. First, by having the challenges to the rule reviewed at the District Court level it expands the timeframe in which plaintiffs can bring challenges to six years. If the decision were to have left it at the Appeals Court as EPA had argued, those challenges would be limited to 120 days. In essence, if someone is aggrieved by the issuance of the Rule they now have six years to file a lawsuit. Not only that, it can be filed at the lower District Court level. There are 94 Districts Courts in the US and only 11 Circuit Courts of Appeals. The EPA had argued that the Circuit Court venue was more efficient, but the Supreme Court did not feel that “Congress did not pursue that end at all costs” in its drafting of the Clean Water Act.

The second issue that comes up as a result of the case relates to the Nationwide Stay of the implementation of the Clean Water Rule. That Stay came from the Sixth Court of Appeals. The Supreme Court ruled that that Court did not have jurisdiction. Therefore, the Stay will be lifted, thus implementing the Clean Water Rule. This is seen by many media sources as a setback to the Trump Administration’s attempt to repeal the rule. However, if it had gone the other way it would be up to the Sixth Circuit to lift the Stay anyway and make a decision. As it is not their jurisdiction, the decision goes back to the District Courts.

By the way, the U.S. District Court for the District of North Dakota also has a 13 state stay on the Clean Water Rule. This was in effect the day before the Rule went into effect on August 28, 2015. When the Sixth Circuit Court Stay is lifted it will only pertain to 37 states. It is not known what the ND Court will do.

In November 2017, the Trump Administration put forth a 2-year delay proposal on the implementation of the Clean Water Rule as a new regulation. This is yet another draft regulation that we may or may not see. However, if it is not implemented the 2015 Clean Water Rule will become effective the day the Sixth Circuit Court removes the Stay.

Looking forward, the Trump Administration has been meeting with stakeholder groups to formulate a new Waters of the US definition. In light of last Monday’s Supreme Court decision, I think we can expect to see this regulation fairly soon.

Posted on — Leave a comment

What is the New “Waters of the US” rule going to look like?

Swamp Stomp

Volume 17, Issue 35

There are two things going on with the “Waters of the US” rule in the next few weeks.  First, the EPA, U.S. Army Move to Rescind 2015 “Waters of the U.S.”  Comments on this rule have been extended until September 27, 2017.  If this rule is finalized the old “Waters of the US” will recodified.  Meaning, the 1986 definition will be used until it is replaced with a new definition.

Speaking of new definitions, the second item on the agenda is that EPA and the Army are seeking public input in the review of the “Waters of the U.S. Rule.”  They are holding online and limited in-person stakeholder meetings from September to November to discuss what is and what is not a “Waters of the US.”  The stakeholders are divided into interest groups and you can register for an opportunity to speak your mind.  We at the Swamp School highly recommend that you consider attending one of these meetings as the future of what will and what will not be regulated is on the table.

More information and instructions on how to register to speak can be found in the following EPA/USACOE press release dated August 25, 2017.

EPA and the Army Seek Input in the Review of the Waters of the U.S. Rule

Stakeholder sessions will be held weekly between September and November

08/25/2017

Contact Information:

(press@epa.gov)

WASHINGTON – The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and U.S. Department of the Army (the agencies) will hold 11 sessions to give stakeholders an opportunity to provide recommendations on a revised definition of “waters of the United States.” The agencies will hold nine two-hour long teleconferences that will be tailored for specific sectors, plus one that will be open to the general public. The agencies will also hold one in-person session for small entities.

“EPA is committed to an open and transparent process for reviewing the definition of ‘waters of the United States,’” said EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt. “Receiving input from across the country will help us make informed decisions as we move through our two-step process that will return power to the states and to provide regulatory certainty to our nation’s farmers and businesses.”

These sessions follow the February 28, 2017, Presidential Executive Order on “Restoring the Rule of Law, Federalism, and Economic Growth by Reviewing the ‘Waters of the United States’ Rule.” The February Order states that it is in the national interest to ensure that the Nation’s navigable waters are kept free from pollution, while at the same time promoting economic growth, minimizing regulatory uncertainty, and showing due regard for the roles of Congress and the States under the Constitution.

To meet these objectives, the agencies are following an expeditious, two-step rulemaking process. The recommendations gathered through these stakeholder sessions, in addition to the feedback the agencies are hearing through ongoing outreach to state, local and tribal governments, will help inform the step two rulemaking, which would revise the definition of “waters of the United States” under the Clean Water Act.

The stakeholder sessions will be held on a weekly basis beginning September 19 and will continue each Tuesday thereafter for ten weeks.  Each will run from 1:00 p.m. to 3:00 p.m. eastern time. Information on how to register for each of these meetings is available on the EPA website.  Registration for each webinar will close a week prior. Those wishing to provide verbal recommendations during the teleconference will be selected on a first-come, first-serve basis. Due to the expected volume of participants, individuals will be asked to limit their oral presentation to three minutes.

Stakeholder Sessions Schedule

  • September 19, 2017 –  small entities (small businesses, small organizations and small governmental jurisdictions)
  • September 26, 2017 – environment and public advocacy
  • October 3, 2017 – conservation, e.g., hunters and anglers
  • October 10, 2017 – construction and transportation
  • October 17, 2017 – agriculture
  • October 24, 2017 – industry
  • October 31, 2017 – mining
  • November 7, 2017 – scientific organizations and academia
  • November 14, 2017 –  stormwater, wastewater management and drinking water agencies
  • November 21, 2017 –  general public

The agencies are also planning an in-person meeting with small entities, which will be held on Monday, October 23, 2017, from 9:00 to 11:00 a.m. Eastern Time at the U.S. EPA’s Headquarters.

The agencies will also be accepting written recommendations on the step two rulemaking effort through a non-regulatory docket (EPA-HQ-OW-2017-0480), which will be available when the notice is published in the Federal Register. The agencies ask that this information be submitted on or before November 28, 2017.

Additional information: www.epa.gov/wotus-rule

Source:  https://www.epa.gov/newsreleases/epa-and-army-seek-input-review-waters-us-rule

 

Posted on — Leave a comment

EPA, U.S. Army Move to Rescind 2015 “Waters of the U.S.”

Swamp Stomp

Volume 17, Issue 28

WASHINGTON – (June 27, 2017) The Environmental Protection Agency, Department of Army, and Army Corps of Engineers (the agencies) are proposing a rule to rescind the Clean Water Rule and re-codify the regulatory text that existed prior to 2015 defining “waters of the United States” or WOTUS. This action would, when finalized, provide certainty in the interim, pending a second rulemaking in which the agencies will engage in a substantive re-evaluation of the definition of “waters of the United States.” The proposed rule would be implemented in accordance with Supreme Court decisions, agency guidance, and longstanding practice.

“We are taking significant action to return power to the states and provide regulatory certainty to our nation’s farmers and businesses,” said Administrator Scott Pruitt. “This is the first step in the two-step process to redefine ‘waters of the U.S.’ and we are committed to moving through this re-evaluation to quickly provide regulatory certainty, in a way that is thoughtful, transparent and collaborative with other agencies and the public.”

This proposed rule follows the February 28, 2017, Presidential Executive Order on “Restoring the Rule of Law, Federalism, and Economic Growth by Reviewing the ‘Waters of the United States’ Rule.” The February Order states that it is in the national interest to ensure that the Nation’s navigable waters are kept free from pollution, while at the same time promoting economic growth, minimizing regulatory uncertainty, and showing due regard for the roles of Congress and the States under the Constitution. To meet these objectives, the agencies intend to follow an expeditious, two-step process that will provide certainty across the country.

The proposed rule would recodify the identical regulatory text that was in place prior to the 2015 Clean Water Rule and that is currently in place as a result of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit’s stay of the 2015 rule. Therefore, this action, when final, will not change current practice with respect to how the definition applies.

The agencies have also begun deliberations and outreach on the second step rulemaking involving a re-evaluation and revision of the definition of “waters of the United States” in accordance with the Executive Order.

“The Army, together with the Corps of Engineers, is committed to working closely with and supporting the EPA on these rulemakings.  As we go through the rulemaking process, we will continue to make the implementation of the Clean Water Act Section 404 regulatory program as transparent as possible for the regulated public, ” said Mr. Douglas Lamont, senior official performing the duties of the Assistant Secretary of the Army for Civil Works.

For the pre-publication Federal Register Notice and additional information: http://www.epa.gov/wotus-rule

Source:  USEPA

(press@epa.gov)

Posted on

Enrollment Representative

The Swamp School is a well-known and well-respected wetland delineation and plant identification training institute with classes on EPA and Army Corps of Engineers rules, wetland delineation, assessment and design, ecological risk assessments, and more including certifications programs and a variety of classroom courses and online. Our students have diverse backgrounds across many industries and are located all over the US.

We are looking for motivated individuals who can help us expand our training programs across the country.  Your typical week includes following up on leads, making new contacts, obtaining referrals, performing one-on-one and group presentations by phone, closing sales and handing customer questions.

A successful enrollment representative will be an aggressive prospector with excellent sales pipeline management skills. You will need to identify decision makers, build relationships, schedule firm appointments, convey a sense of urgency, inform the customer, close for a decision and provide timely service. You should demonstrate a genuine interest in our industry and knowledge of our customers’ needs.

Necessary Skills and Experience:

  • Inside sales experience
  • Business to business sales experience
  • Ability to work remotely
  • Self-managed and disciplined

Educational sales experience is preferred but not required.  First year expected income is between 60k – 95k with each subsequent year an additional 20% to 50% depending on performance.

If you feel you can contribute to our mission and find this work rewarding we invite you to apply. Our website is swampschool.org. No phone calls please. Send applications to:  jobs@swampschool.org

Posted on — Leave a comment

International Wetland Plant Project

The Swamp Stomp

Volume 17, Issue 18

For the past couple of years, we have noticed an increase in our international student body. Wetland identification and delineation is becoming more important as countries expand their economies and run into complicated water quality and quantity issues. Wetlands play an important part in the overall water management of a given country.

Recently the Swamp School released a new online class entitled, International Wetlands Assessment and Delineation. This class is tailored to meet the needs of the international community and has been put together based upon Ramsar, Wetlands International, USACE and other standards.

One of the principal features of a wetland is the plant community that exists in the wetland. In the United States, we have the benefit of a wetland plant list that is decades in the making. It was originally created by the US Fish and Wildlife Service and has since been updated by the US Army Corps of Engineers.

What many people do not know is how the original list was compiled by the USFWS. In the 1980’s the USFWS was completing the National Wetlands Inventory (NWI). They needed to ground truth some of the areas that were under consideration for refuges and they needed a way to qualify if a site was a wetland. One of the developing criteria was that the site had to have 50% hydrophytes to be a wetland. What was a hydrophyte?

The USFWS sent out a survey to a limited group of USFWS employees and some from academia asking them to categorize common plants found in wetlands in their area based upon the now familiar wetland ratings of obligate (OBL), facultative- wet (FACW), facultative (FAC), facultative-up (FACU) and upland (UPL). Originally, the ratings were based upon a numeric experience estimate. For example, a wetland plant with a rating of FACW would be expected to be found in wetlands 67%-99% of the time. There was no real data collected. Rather, it was more of an opinion survey of qualified professionals and has served us well for nearly 30 years.

To this end, we are conducting a similar survey of wetlands plants found around the world and we need your help. Both by spreading the word about this project and by participating in it. If you can provide plant data for your area, we have the database up and running. We will need scientific name, common name, location information and your rating opinion. We also ask for a reference source that helps verify the habitat of the given plant. Due to the size of the database, we are not asking for any pictures. At least not yet.

Request Project Access Here

If you would like to participate in the project, we have a very simple registration process. Just go to this page and fill out the contact information. We ask for location information of the main area that you will be working in. However, you can submit data from others areas once you are registered. We do not need any USA data as the USACOE does a fine job of keeping up with the US wetland plants. We have had many requests for this data from Canada, New Zealand, India, China, the United Kingdom, Brazil, and South Korea. We need data from all over the world, but these countries are in high demand.

The database is open and accessible to anyone who is registered. The data is processed in real time so you will see continuing updates. If you have a spreadsheet of this data for your area, we do have the ability to upload this into the database. Just let us know if you need to do this and we will be happy to help.

Please note:  This project is open to botanists everywhere.  We just do not need any data for US plants.  US botanists are most welcome to participate.

This is an ongoing project and we do not ever expect it to be finalized. The International Wetlands Assessment and Delineation students will be submitting data as part of their class into this project so you will see ongoing updates. We are also hoping to be able to publish national wetland plant guides once we have enough data to share.

Lastly, this project requires a fair amount of database server space and utilization. We want to make the information free to anyone who wants to use it. We have set up a GoFundMe account to help us cover some of the backend computer costs. Even if you are not able to help with the database, please consider helping us by contributing. Any amount if very much appreciated. If there are any philanthropists out there we would love to also add photographs to the database, but the amount of server space for this is enormous and outside what we can self-fund.
Please circulate this post to anyone you think can help and please let us know your thoughts by commenting below. Please feel free to repost this blog post, tweet it out, share on Facebook, copy in an email or use whatever social media avenue you like. We need to get the word out!

Help Fund the Project Here

Thanks for all your help and support! – Marc

Posted on — Leave a comment

Waters of the US – Where are we today?

The Swamp Stomp

Volume 17, Issue 15

We at the Swamp School have been keeping up with and attempting to teach the ever-changing rules related to what is a Waters of the US. Much like the waterways they regulate they twist and turn disappear and re-appear finally ending up in the sea of government regulation. Then they are left to evaporate on the whims of the courts soon condensing in yet another regulation. We will call it the Waters of the US cycle.

This all began in the late 1890’s when a concern about blocking waterways used to transport good and services was seen as a threat to the national economy. The use of structural steel to cross great rivers was now presenting problems of railroads blocking traditional water based shipping. Free trade across state lines needed to be maintained and Congress (not the President – he vetoed the Act) passed the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899. Ever since then the Federal government has been regulating waters of the US.

Much later in 1972 Congress passed the Clean Water act. The President at the time (Nixon) also vetoed the Act. This law like the Rivers and Harbors Act did not explain what a Waters of the US was. Rather, it directed the Army Corps of Engineers to come up with a definition. They did and in 1986 they published the definition as a rule in the Federal Register. It is the same rule that we use today.

In the spring of 2011 the Obama administration leaked (pun intended) a draft Waters of the US guidance document. The guidance was never published but it did give notice to what the new administration was up to. In 2013, another leak of a new draft Waters of the US rule was revealed and in turn, a draft regulation that was published in the Spring of 2014.

The draft Waters of the US regulation has the unique honor of being the most commented regulation in the history of the United States. At the close of the public comment period it had received a little more than 1.2 million public comments. Other regulations tend to sport a few hundred to perhaps a thousand comments. Generally, this means that the regulation gets flushed and the agency starts over.

However, the EPA took the lead on the final version of the regulation and made some major changes including the regulation’s name. The new Clean Water rule was born. This rule was so different that half of the States field lawsuits along with a few private organizations alleging a number of procedural violations along with the Constitutional challenges to the merits of the regulation. For a brief while in 2015 about two thirds of the US was regulated by the Clean Water rule and the plaintiff states were not.

In October 2015, a nationwide stay of the Clean Water rule was imposed by the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals and that is where we float today. The Army Corps and EPA issued a directive that the 1986 definition of Waters of the US would be used until further notice.

The nationwide stay and the court cases bubbled and percolated in the courts until finally rising to the attention of the Supreme Court in 2016. President Obama had asked the Court not to hear the case but they turned him down. This was seen as a loss for the President as the regulation appeared all but domed and likely to go down the drain.

In an interesting turn of events, the new President Trump has also asked the Supreme Court to not hear the case. He was also turned down. However, this has been described as some sort of victory for the rule. Nothing new has happened between December 2016 when President Obama made the request and in early 2017 when President Trump made the request but the interpretation of the response seems very sinuous.

It appears that the high Court will render some sort of decision before the end of the year. Late fall is likely. So, we need to wade through another growing season with the old rule.

Just a few days ago, President Trump announced that there would be some new guidance, an executive order or the like regarding the implementation of the old rule. In a rather clever move, it was announced that the old 2008 US Army Corps guidance developed in response to the Rapanos case and based upon the lone Justice Kennedy option would be updated to reflect the plurality option of Justice Scalia in that same case. In short, what was become to be known as significant nexus would no longer apply. Justice Scalia only required a physical nexus to a navigable waterway. Justice Kennedy’s model would allow a chemical or biological connection in addition to or instead of a physical connection.

The establishment of the Scalia rule would simplify the jurisdictional process but as one might expect there will be lawsuits. In the meantime, we will keep a careful eye on the ebbs and flows of this turbulent process and await the next wave of regulations.