Posted on — Leave a comment

A Two-Acre Turning Point? What the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act Could Mean for Wetlands

Dawn scene of a wetland with still water, grasses, and trees, a construction excavator on a dirt hill to the right.

September 30, 2026 | Washington, D.C.

A proposed federal permitting bill could substantially change how the United States authorizes wetland impacts, even without rewriting the definition of “waters of the United States.”

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 would change several important parts of the Clean Water Act, including nationwide permits, state water quality certifications, EPA oversight, and challenges to permit decisions.

The legislation was introduced September 30, 2026, as S. 5653. It remains a proposal, so the changes discussed here depend on what Congress ultimately passes.

For wetland scientists, landowners, engineers, and environmental consultants, the central issue is straightforward: a wetland could remain federally jurisdictional while becoming substantially easier to impact through the permitting process.

WOTUS and permitting answer different questions

Wetland regulation involves two separate questions.

First, is the wetland a water of the United States, commonly called WOTUS? That determines whether the Clean Water Act applies.

Second, if the wetland is jurisdictional, what authorization is needed to discharge dredged or fill material into it?

The bill’s Clean Water Act provisions focus heavily on that second question. They do not directly establish a new definition of WOTUS or a new continuous surface connection test.

Section 1201 would, however, change where challenges to federal WOTUS definitions are heard by adding those agency actions to the Clean Water Act’s direct federal appeals court review provisions.

For practitioners, this distinction matters. A broader permitting pathway does not make a wetland non-jurisdictional. Delineation and jurisdictional analysis would still be essential to determining which requirements apply.

Less than two acres would receive special treatment

One of the most consequential provisions appears in Section 1204.

For general-permit decisions, the bill would direct the Army Corps of Engineers to consider the effects of a discharge of dredged or fill material into less than two acres of navigable waters to be a minimal adverse environmental effect.

That is a significant policy choice. Congress would establish an acreage-based conclusion about environmental effects rather than leave the entire determination to agency evaluation.

The precise wording matters: the attached text says less than two acres, not two acres or less.

The bill would also require the Corps to maintain nationwide permits for qualifying activities associated with five specified permits:

Nationwide permitActivity category
NWP 12Oil or natural gas pipeline activities
NWP 14Linear transportation projects
NWP 43Stormwater management facilities
NWP 57Electric utility line and telecommunications activities
NWP 58Utility line activities for water and other substances

For this requirement, the bill uses a threshold of less than two acres for each “single and complete project,” incorporating specified regulatory definitions.

This would not create a blanket exemption allowing anyone to fill any wetland smaller than two acres. The provision concerns discharges, general permitting, specified activity categories, and project definitions. Permit conditions and other applicable requirements would still need to be evaluated.

The potential consequence is nevertheless substantial: more impacts could move through general permitting rather than a more extensive individual-permit process.

An acreage threshold cannot describe every wetland’s value

From a wetland science perspective, acreage provides useful information, but it does not fully describe function.

A small wetland may occupy an important position in a watershed, provide habitat, retain floodwater, or intercept pollutants. Its importance depends on its characteristics and location, as well as its size.

The bill’s proposed threshold raises an important question: Should a discharge into less than two acres be treated as minimally adverse because of acreage alone?

There is also a cumulative-effects concern. Numerous individually small impacts can add up across a watershed.

For linear infrastructure, how the incorporated “single and complete project” definitions apply to individual crossings would deserve close attention. A threshold applied to separate qualifying crossings is different from one applied to the entire length of a pipeline or utility corridor.

These are practical implementation questions with consequences for both project planning and aquatic resource protection.

General-permit review would focus on water quality

Section 1204 would also narrow the Corps’ analysis when determining environmental effects under the general-permit provisions.

The Corps would be directed to consider only the effects of dredged or fill discharges on compliance with defined water quality requirements.

That would constrain the ability to weigh wetland functions as independent considerations in that determination. Wildlife habitat, flood storage, and other functions would not necessarily receive separate consideration simply because they are environmentally important.

Some of those functions may relate to applicable water quality requirements. The concern is that the proposed statutory test would be narrower than a broader evaluation of wetland ecological effects.

My assessment is that this could simplify general-permit decisions while reducing the range of wetland values those decisions expressly address.

States and Tribes would face tighter certification limits

Section 1202 would substantially revise Section 401 water quality certification.

The bill would limit certification to compliance with specifically defined water quality requirements. It would also require a certifying authority to support a denial with clear and convincing evidence that no modification or reasonable condition could allow certification without violating those requirements.

Conditions would face similar scrutiny. The authority would need clear and convincing evidence that they are necessary, the least burdensome means of ensuring compliance, and consistent with the federal license or permit requirements.

For applicants, this could provide greater predictability and stronger grounds to challenge conditions.

For states and Tribes, it would narrow discretion and increase the evidentiary burden supporting their decisions.

The bill also establishes application procedures and review deadlines, including a maximum nine-month review period for specified interstate natural gas and electric transmission projects. Those projects would receive special treatment focused on direct point source discharges.

These changes concern federal Section 401 certification. They should not be read as automatically eliminating separate state wetland, buffer, stormwater, or other permitting requirements.

Permit programs could operate on longer cycles

The bill would extend the maximum term of Section 404 general permits from five years to ten years. It expressly preserves the ability to modify a general permit during its term or renewal.

Section 1203 would also extend the statutory maximum term for NPDES permits issued under approved state programs from five years to ten years.

Longer terms could reduce administrative workload and give applicants greater continuity. They could also mean longer intervals between routine program reconsideration.

For wetland professionals, the practical question would be how agencies use their remaining authority to respond to changing conditions during those longer permit terms.

EPA oversight and court remedies would be restricted

The proposal would limit EPA’s Section 404(c) authority to prohibit or restrict disposal sites to the period between submission of a complete permit application and issuance of the permit. That amendment would apply to applications submitted after enactment.

This would give applicants more certainty about when EPA could intervene, while removing that authority outside the specified window.

Section 1205 would also generally establish a 150-day deadline for challenges to Section 404 permits and general-permit verifications, unless a shorter deadline applies.

Even when a court finds a permitting decision unlawful, the bill would sharply restrict its ability to halt the authorized activity. The court would generally need to find an imminent and substantial danger to human health or the environment for which no other equitable remedy is available.

That matters for wetlands because correcting a permit decision after filling has occurred may not restore the resource that was lost.

What wetland professionals should take away

The legislation could change the consequences of a jurisdictional finding without changing the finding itself.

A wetland could remain WOTUS, yet its proposed impacts could qualify for a broader general-permit pathway, face narrower certification conditions, and receive stronger protection against later permit disruption.

Consultants would still need accurate delineations, defensible jurisdictional documentation, clear impact calculations, and careful analysis of project boundaries. They would also need to explain the difference between a jurisdictional determination, a permit authorization, and compliance with other applicable laws.

Faster and more predictable permitting is a legitimate goal. The scientific question is whether the proposed shortcuts preserve meaningful evaluation of wetland functions and cumulative losses.

For those who work in wetlands, this bill deserves attention alongside the continuing WOTUS debate. Which waters are protected and how impacts to those waters are authorized are equally important parts of the regulatory picture.

#Wetlands #CleanWaterAct #WetlandPermitting #EnvironmentalRegulations #WetlandWednesday #TheSwampSchool

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *